Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

Posts

Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

#1

Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

Jim

>I have a shop that is approx. 550 Sq.ft, and a two hp, 2.5 m bag with a 6" main duct running approx 15' in a straight line, my question is "how much Static Pressure lose will I lose if I add a small cyclone (not a trash can) before the dust collector?

I worked on this for 4 month now, gathering information, measuring SP loses, and talked to Grizzly on Saturday in Springfield MO. The fellow at Grizzly said not to add anything, that the grizzly dust collector would handle even the small dust.

PLEASE ADVISE

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

#2

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

Rich Schneider

>I too have struggled with this issue...from what I have read your on the right track as far as maximizing the capability of your collector overall...the one thing I noticed is that you have 2.5m (which I assume is micron) bags...I've read a lot of Bill Pentz's thoughts on dust collection (and dust pumps) and would suggest you check out his info..just Google his name..one of his many thoughts lies in changing from a top bag to a cartridge filter..from what I understand it will improve air flow and also allow you to setup a system that captures down to 1.0 micron or less....I recently order cartridges for a couple of my portable collectors and am eager to see how it works out...

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

#3

One Guy's Experience

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You guys can run a search on my posts and see the pix after I completed mods on my 2hp dc system. You're certainly on the right track with the 6" ductwork. I too considered going to a filter rather than a filter bag, also as recommended on Bill Pentz's site [prodigeous amount of info there]. However, I sought out several woodworker who had done so because I wanted to find out issues like durability and such. Those filter ain't cheap, and I had no intention of putting a new one on every few month. Of, I think, 7 people I spoke to, 4 had switched back to bags, 2 had gone to a full (new) cyclone system, and the other had sold out his shop following an injury.

I asked the guys who had gone back to bags why they had done so and they all mentioned that the filters were absolutely great until they needed cleaning. They noted that their system's suction dropped off pretty fast once the filter got full, and the things were both hard to clean and never matched the performace of new. I then call a filter bag outfit here in NJ. A 6' bag with a special inner surface bonded layer, all rated at 1 mic, cost me about twice what one filter does, but the bag cleans up with a smack and shake. The guy at Precision Filter also reconfirmed what I had been told about the cartridge filters.

My problem now? The system moves so much air it's become noisy and I have to be very carefull to run it in short stretches because it will reverse the flues on both my furnaces and waterheater.

mm

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

#4

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>If I recall Pentz correctly, he disapproved of cartridge filters on a regular DC because they get battered up pretty badly and won't last long...

DC

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

#5

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

Nelson

>I have a Jet canister thats over a year old and still looks and works like when it was brand new,and its used everday. Don't understand the problem some people are having,at this point I don't think anybody knows how long they will last as they are new to the small shop. Canister's have been used in the industrial world for years with great success perhaps they are a higher quality I don't know, but whenever mine wears out I will replace it with another canister.

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

#6

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

Dan Manturi

>I too got a bag from these "progressive" folks. One micron. They made it to the size I asked, which was taller than the standard bag and I also had the bag made so that the diameter had a 20" opening where it connected to the DC but belled out to 24" to the top. Plastic bottom bag. These folks are decent to deal with and fast. Bag was incredible quality and is a "shaker" material that is lined on the inside to get the dust to fall into the lower bag by shaking. Works decent. Cost like $35 for one on a 2HP Grizzly 1029. Shipping was a little high.

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

#7

I meant precision..

Dan Manturi

>I typed "progressive". Guess I was thinking about motorcycle insurance..

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

#8

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

Bill White

>Dan,

How about a link to the Precision folks?

Bill

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

#9

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

Barry Irby

>My extremely limited experience with a cartridge was in a friend's shop. We were sanding walnut on his oscillating spindle sander and literally after a few minutes the performance(Air flow) dropped noticeably. We had to stop every five or ten minutes and twirl the cleaner know that ran the flapper brushes around the inside.

And that was not much help.

Bob Dodge used to post here fairly regularly and appeared knowledgeable on this stuff. I believe his opinion of the cartridges was that they were built on "Internet logic". That they worked initially because they did offer increased surface area, but degraded rapidly as the pleats packed full of fines. And that the brushes could not clean the fines out of the valleys. This matched my experience exactly. IIRC, he said the cartridges were not much use in industry. He gave references for where to buy superior bags.

I used a home made trash can separator on my system for about a year. My DC is out side and the dust goes out there, but the bag was hard to change, so I put in the trash can to make it easier and to have to change the bag less often. The trash can did not seem to hurt the performance of the system much, but I modified the DC outdoors to make it easier to empty and got rid of the separator because I have a small shop and it was always in the way.

If I understand cyclones correctly, if they separate all but the very fine stuff, I would use one of them now in stead of the filter bag and I would just blow the fines out into the world if I could get away with it. I don't want to collect dust, I want it to go away.

If your question is whether you can use some sort of cyclone as a pre-separator, I think the answer is yes, but I don't think it will help much. It will separate out all but the very fine stuff that will go through into you existing bag. It the really fine stuff that gets into the pores of the bag and stops it up, reducing air flow. So, I think your air flow will fall of at nearly the same rate it does now, but there will be very little stuff in the actual DC.

The other thing to come up to speed on is that what the DC should be doing is collecting the stuff that is invisibly fine. Down to or below 1 micron. That's the stuff that hurts you. The big stuff that falls on the floor is messy, but not much of a health risk. Most people put in an Ambient Air Cleaner to capture this stuff. The down side to them is that they must keep the air moving to draw the fines into the filters. This is exactly what you don't want. If those particles are flying int he air, they are available to inhale and that's where you are exposed. If the settle out, they are relatively harmless. What is really desirable is to capture them at the source so that you never have a chance to inhale them. And we should be wearing personal protective equipemnet (Masks) also.

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

#10

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

Norman (Metcalfe, Ont.)

>Whenever I read about pleated filters, my shop-vac pleated filter comes to mind. I need to go in and clean the individual pleats to restore performance when it gets caked up, not a good way to go, although the surface area is increased using pleats. Even shaking and messing with the pleats still left the inner part of the pleat caked up. For a decent job, the individual pleats had to be cleaned, so I'm a bit wary of pleated filter technology for this reason.

An interesting central vac system I had once was a fine particulate cloth (bag) enclosing around the intake of a central vacuum within a drum. Inside the bottom of this bag was a steel ball. The ball would vibrate with the vacuum running and shake and self-clean the fine cloth bag. The fine dust would then settle into the drum, worked well. Maybe this is fairly common, but I've only seen it done this way once.

Norman

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

#11

I agree with Mark and Barry

Paul Dwight

>My experience with cartridge filters was the same as Mark, Barry and some of the other posters have mentioned. When the filter was newly installed, suction was significantly better than with the prior bag filter. Once the cartridge had been in use for a while, the pleats became clogged and I never, ever managed to restore the airflow to what it had been in that short golden period when the filter was new. As more and more fines packed into the pleats, it seemed like no amount of cleaning was enough to keep the air flow up.

I own a cyclone now.

I'm happy with my cyclone (a 2HP Grizzly), but I suspect that a well-designed DC using good bags would be perfectly adequate for most home shops. If your current DC has an impeller that's 12" or more in diameter, I would try upgrading the filter bags before I did anything else. A lot of folks used to recommend American Fabric Filter as a source for upgraded and oversized filter bags.

Good luck! -- Paul

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

#12

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

Larry Clinton

>I will certainly always use the cartridges. I have a Grizzly 3 hp Cyclone(about 2 years now). Grizzly did send out a retrofit brush/cleaner system for my unit after it was in service for about 6 months. During the dis-assembly , knowing the cleaning brush initially installed did not work properly (per Grizzly information with the retrofit), I did clean the filter completely outside the shop using an air gun. I really had not noticed any major deterioration prior to the cleaning. I have overflowed the 55 gallon drum 3 or 4 times resulting in derbies in the bag below the cartridge filter. I just pull the cleaning brushes up and down the filter a few times and have had no problem, these brushes do fit down into the pleats clear to the bottom. Due to the amount of surface area in the cartridge filter, it would be impossible to replace it with similar bag units as I would fill up my shop with bags. Industries that do a lot of filtration, (my son works at one, a soybean processing plant that produces soybean oil and meal) use bags - but they are located in separate "bag houses) and have elaborate pulsed air systems to remove the dust from the bags. My older son worked at Donaldson as an Engineer. They produce the large cartridge filters used on Cat equipment and huge stationary engines (and the Abrams tank engine air intake). He certainly sees no advantage in the bag type filters.

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

#13

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

Barry Irby

>My ancient Sears shop vac (the biggest one they made) has a pleated filter. Well, sort of. They failed to install anything like combs to keep the pleats open on the side the air comes out of. The pleats have collapsed and sucked themselves flat. This makes the inlet side of the pleats much larger. Whenever I empty it, I take the filter off and beat it against the side of my trash can. Over and over until I get most of the dirt out. I once used it with my Performax and there was almost no dust in the drum, but the filter looked like a large fluffy basketball. I would take it apart in figure out some way to insert spacers in the pleats, but its not designed for disassembly.

If the Grizzly canisters have brushes that clean between the pleats, that would be a lot better than the flapper type that just go round and round and do little or nothing. Wonder if the wear affects the micron rating?

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

#14

Not Precision - Process systems! *LINK*

Dan Manturi

>Here is the URL for Process Systems & Components in Mt Holly. The fact that I got there name right on the third try would tell you that i have no affiliation with them, other than being impressed by the quality of the bag they sent. The bag was only about $35, but they whacked me $18 for shipping. i did understand that but did not appeal it. From Mt Holly NJ to Bethlehem for a non fragile that is really high.


http://www.processsys.com/

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

#15

Re: Dust Collector- The Eternal Struggle

arw01

>

You mean caked up like this?

I just made myself a pleat whacker to fit inside the cartridge. Every couple of bag empties on the bottom and I take the filter off, put a black garbage bag over it and roll it around the shop for a few minutes. Give it some whacks with the hand, slap it on the concrete, etc..

Seems to dislodge a lot of it. The airflow goes back up.

All that fine stuff in here is really NOT from sanding, done very little of that.

Alan