Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

cordless drill quandary

Posts

cordless drill quandary

#1

cordless drill quandary

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>My trusty B&D Industrial Univolt 9.6V drill has bit the dust. After only 15 years! How ungrateful! Actually, what happened is, the charger bit the dust and there are no replacement chargers available, either from the company or on Ebay. And B&D tells me they can't be fixed. I tried to help Bill Tindall with a minor job, and the drill just let me down.

So, I need a new drill. I'm torn between the Makita 18V Lithium and the Panasonic 14.4.

I do mostly cabinets and furniture, occasionally build an addition to the house, a deck, etc. The 9.6V has really been all the power I needed. After all, if it could twist off 3" Torx screws, how much more power do I need?

What I would really like is a Makita 12V lithium. I think the power of a 12 - 14 V drill is just fine, and the weight of both these drills is great, actually a little less than my 9.6.

1. Will the 18V be overkill for the purposes I've described?

2. Is the lithium battery the wave of the future?

3. What is your experience?

Thanks for your thoughts.

Bruce, in suddenly beautiful fall MN weather.

Re: cordless drill quandary

#2

Re: cordless drill quandary

Hank Knight

>You'll get lots of opinions here. Mine opinion is that 12V or 14.4V drill drivers are plenty powerful enough for woodworking. The big stuff is for construction and other rough work. I have a 12V Panasonic and a 14.4 V Bosch in my shop and I've never needed more. I'm a fan of the Panasonics. The machines are tiny compared to most others on the market and are really easy to handle - light, well balanced and perfect for getting into tight places. They have a new lithium ion model that I've not used, but I bought a 12V Panasonic digital impact driver last year. It's NiMH batteries are strong and hold a charge a long time. My guess is that the LIONS are even better, but I have no personal experience with them. I don' think you can go wrong with a Panasonic.

Standard disclaimer: No affiliation with either Panasonic or Bosch. Just a satisfied customer.

Hank

Re: cordless drill quandary

#3

Re: cordless drill quandary

Garrett in Victoria

>Hi Bruce

1. Will the 18V be overkill for the purposes I've described?

I have the large Makita 18v Li-ion and it's a great tool. However, it is not only heavy it's big. Before deciding on the 12-14v models, check out the new Makita 18v compact, esp the combo with the hex head driver. The size, weight and price are right. Performance is terrific, and the battery charger is really good. Just as important, battery life between charges is amazing compared ot he ni-cads.

2.Is the lithium battery the wave of the future?

The battery future has arrived, and it's Li-ion.

3. What is your experience? Excellent.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: cordless drill quandary

#4

Re: cordless IMPACT DRIVER

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Bruce,

First, my experience is that the 12 vt models are fine in a wood worker's shop. I presently have three cordless drills, a Ryobi and two P+C's. The P+C drills are charged in 1 hour, the Ryobi takes three. Easy to work around a lifeless drill. If some of your work involves driving screws, take a look at a cordless impact driver. I love the size and it is superb functionally.

Re: cordless drill quandary

#5

Re: cordless drill quandary

Joseph Mulherin

>Bruce, I mentioned before in another posting....go to your local ACE hardware and get a 18V. cordless/w/drill/screwbits for only $29.00.

Re: cordless drill quandary

#6

Re: cordless drill quandary

Jim Dillon

>Bruce,

I got by for a long time with a 9.6 volt Bosch and it had more than enough power for my needs in normal woodworking. I used it hard, and when it died, I got another 9.6 volt Bosch. Again more than enough power, but the clutch or something died in less than 2 years. I couldn't pass up a deal on a 12 volt Panasonic and I have to say that I like it a lot. For normal woodworking, I think 12 volt - whatever the brand - is more than enough. And the last time I shopped, the 9 volters were rare. For more difficult needs, I have resisted getting a bigger cordless, and just pull out my 25-30 year old corded 3/8 inch Milwaukee. I have no experience with the Li-ion batteries, but they have some nice advertised advantages. Good luck.

Jim

Re: cordless drill quandary

#7

Re: cordless drill quandary

JohnKJordan in East TN

>I have two Dewalt 18v and three 12v. I use the 18v most, but much of what I do is outside around the barn, fencing, etc. The 12v drills stay in the shop/garage/tack room for smaller jobs - as others have said, they are lighter weight and smaller but still powerful enough for shop work.

Lithium batteries are very lighweight and have a high power density. If I didn't have any tools, I'd probably buy one, but I think they will come down in price in a few years.

A more important thing to me is that as many cordless tools as possible share the same battery. I keep six 18v batteries charged for the big drills, circular saw, and a couple of reciprocating saws - being able to grab a battery from a saw and clip it into a drill in an instant is helpful. It sure would be nice if the makers got together and used a standard battery base.

JKJ

Re: cordless drill quandary

#8

Buy/Try this *LINK*

Andy Lincoln,In Dearborn MI

>Bruce,

We've bought these kits at work,150 + shop employees and the only complaint is we don't have more of them.

I'm using Home Depot as a reference but sure this could be purchased other places as well.

Andy


Makita Kit

Re: cordless drill quandary

#9

Thanks to eveyone

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I really appreciate your direct experiences and your advice. I'm off on a quest this weekend, to the nearest borg, and your advice will help make this decision easier.

I'm pretty sure what I need is a medium-power drill. 18V is nice, but overkill for what I use it. It would be nice if the Lithium drills were a bit cheaper in that voltage range, and I suspect they will be by the time my next one wears out.

Thanks again.

Bruce

Re: cordless drill quandary

#10

Re: Look at the Ridgid at HD

Larry Clinton

>I recently had my Dewalt cordless battery charge shorten enough to make me want to replace it. I, like you found the 12V more than adequate for my shop use. I looked at several brands, settled on the Ridgid due to the extended service agreement. Lifetime tool repair and battery replacement! As every cordless drill I have owned has been trashed due to battery death and the fact a new "kit" with batteries cost almost the same as replacement batteries. I looked at all the Ridgid drills and impact drivers, would have liked to have the same batteries for both. I decided the larger drills were just too unhandy - large and heavy for my use. I purchased the 14.4 V impact driver and 12 V drill. I really like the ergonomics of both. I purchased & registered them in my son's name so he should have them for life.