Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

OT Digital TV & VCR?

Posts

OT Digital TV & VCR?

#1

OT Digital TV & VCR?

Tom Norton

>Need help with understanding the changes that are on the way. I understand that Digital will replace analog for TV. I heard that my vcr will not work to record shows. Is this correct? If so what is my option to upgrade to?

Thanks,

Re: OT Digital TV & VCR?

#2

Steven Antonucci

What's a VCR?

steve antonucci

>Seriously. It's time to upgrade to a DVR. It can literally change the way you watch TV.

When I occasionally throw a tape in the VCR, I get nauseous looking at it because the video quality is so poor. A DVR is online (no tapes to find, degradation over time) and user friendly. My MIL fought it for years, and even she admitted that she couldn't live without it any more.

VCR is dead technology. Let it go.

Steve

Re: OT Digital TV & VCR?

#3

Unusable? Yes and no

Joe Pack

>If your TV signal comes via an antenna, your analog TV will not work with digital signals. If your TV signal comes from cable, you will have no problem (with or without a cable box); the signal is converted for your use by the cable company before it gets to you.

Your VCR will work just fine if you have a cable signal. I'm not sure about a direct antenna signal.

If I was buying new, I would probably look at the recordable/rewritable DVD, but my VCRs work just fine for me now. I have both a DVD recorder (bought to transfer VHS tapes to disc) and VCRs. The VCR is my choice of weapon to record things I will watch only once, ie., NASCAR when I'm not home, but only because I am used to programming it and it is in the basement where my shop and hangout are. The DVD would be just fine, though.

If you are buying anything new, look at digital, not analog. But don't run out and buy all digital just because someone tells you your analog equipment won't work anymore. This is NOT true if you have cable. My 36" Sony and my antique VCRs do just fine.

As for the picture quality, digital is better without a doubt. But unless I see them side by side, I don't notice a difference. It's just a TV picture. What dots don't get filled in by the signal get filled in by my brain. And with my old eyes, it doesn't make much difference! :-)

Best bet - if you have cable or any other non-antenna service, call your service provider and ask if your equipment will still work with their BASIC service.

Re: OT Digital TV & VCR?

#4

Re: OT Digital TV & VCR? *LINK*

JohnKJordan in East TN

>I strongly agree with the DVR suggestion. I still maintain machines for five different tape formats but mostly for archived work and when I need to send video out. Other options are far better for TV archiving and time shifting today.

1) If you typically record shows to keep (archiving), then recording them to DVD is the best way to go at the moment. I have one combo machine (Panasonic DMR-EH75V) that will record to hard disk (DVR) or DVD or VHS. For those shows you want to archive, you can record to hard disk, edit as desired to fix the beginning, end, and remove commercials, then copy to DVD. I usually put four 1/2 hr shows on one DVD. The included VHS will let you continue to play all of your old VHS tapes without needing too many boxes connected.

2) If you typically record shows only to watch later (time shifting), a DVR will do what you need, especially if you can get access the program directories. This feature is built into the DVRs sold/leased by the satellite and cable companies and the 3rd party DVRs sometimes have the means to automatically access the program schedules over the air but it may not work correctly over satellite (I could not get this to work correctly over satellite Dish network). It works great over Comcast cable using their DVR. With the program directories, you can searh for and mark future programs by name instead of channel/time - painless, intuitive, and error free. My better half uses it daily. Me, I try to watch 1/2 hour of TV a month whether I need it or not.

Note that if you access signals only over the air, you can get a digital/analog conversion box and continue to use your existing TV and VCR if you really want to. (There is a government assistance program planned.) However, what is not clear to me with this setup is if the D/A conversion will work like a cable converter box and feed all it's channels through a single channel to the TV (typically channel 3 or 4), or whether it will pass the individual channels to the analog TV tuner. This may affect how a connected VCR is programmed. Regardless, I still recommend dumping the VCR.

The link answers some questions about this whole topic.

JKJ


DTV consumer facts, FCC