What's the strongest...
john l. blue
>glue? Appreciate any answers in advance.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
What's the strongest...
john l. blue
>glue? Appreciate any answers in advance.
Depends
Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario
>What materials you are trying to glue to each other, more info needed please
:-)
Take care,
Jim
Re: What's the strongest...
JL
>FWW had an article where they tested a variety of glues. Their conclusions were that good old yellow glue was about as good as it gets.
Re: What's the strongest...
Patrick Schupbach
>A quality 2 part epoxy is the choice for tough jobs. Titebond 3 works well for me on woodworking projects. Depends on what your doing. Hope this helps.
Re: What's the strongest...
john lucas
>I'll second the question, it depends on what your using it for. We use PC-7 to glue rocks to brick walls to make a rock climbing walls. I haven't tried it but it's probably not the best for gluing wood. For one thing it's hard to spread and hard to clean up.
I've used yellow, white, polyeurethane and epoxy for wood. Polyeurethane is my last choice of the above. I just haven't been able to see any advantage of it over yellow glue for general glueing, and epoxy for waterproof of gap filling applications.
Gorilla Glue say's they are the strongest
del schisler
>
Hide Glue
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>
strength not the important criteria
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>With a properly prepared joint the alipahtic resin adhesives (yellow and white glue) result in wood failure, not adhesive failure. This adhesive is used by the furniture industry, which should be the end of the discussion for many people.
Strength of the adhesive is almost never the most important factor in deciding what adhesive to use. For a woodworker how fast the bond forms is more often the deciding factor in choosing an adhesive.
Re: Hide Glue
Steve Schoene
>The liquid hide glue is about on a par with the yellow glues and the like. But hot hide glue is stronger, and in some version, so strong that it can be used to bond to smooth glass so tightly that it chips out pieces of the glass when the glue shrinks as it hardens. (In more ordinary forms, the glue shrinking as it dries is a plus that pulls joints together. So even a rubbed joint can end up pretty darn tight even without clamping.
Different issues here
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>The fact that one glue sticks to a given material does not imply anything about its overall strength. The example of hide glue pulling chips off glass says three things: hide glue sticks to glass, it shrinks as it dries, and it has enough holding power on glass to pull chips of glass off. None of this is relevant if we stick (pardon the pun) to wood.
FWW's test looks like a good one (can't say that for all their reviews IMHO, the recent bandsaw test being another debatable one, but I digress). Overall, liquid hide glue had 79% of the holding strength of Titebond III (the best overall), and hot hide glue 76%. Both hide glues held their own in oak, but fared relatively poorly in the two other wood species (maple and ip�). This suggests that hide glue is a good choice for open pored species only.
This doesn't take away from hide glue's other characteristics (quick tack or long open time, depending on type, and reversibility), but the statement that hot hide glue is stronger than yellow glue doesn't fly, same for hot hide glue being stronger than the liquid type.
What I would like to see is a comparison between the various brands of yellow glue as to their strength, all three Titebond, Elmer's, LV 2002 GF, etc. Are these roughly equivalent in terms of strength? We don't know.
DC
Re: Different issues here
Larry Clinton
>Can't argue with their test data, but as I recall the conclusion was that all the glues were stronger than the wood itself so the differences in strength were kind of irrelevant as I see the situation. One aspect I know hasn't been mentioned and certainly hasn't been tested is the strength / life test. It is a fact that hide glue has been in use for thousands of years. Furniture taken from tombs in Egypt still glued together with hide glue for over 3,000 years as I read (believe it was something - possibly a casket - from King tuts mother). I just wonder what will happen to the furniture glued with the new (40 ~ 50 year since released), Plastic based glues in a hundred years or so?