Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Countertop material costs...

Posts

Countertop material costs...

#1

Countertop material costs...

Dan Manturi

>I am on the verge of replacing 2 kitchens - mine and my kid's. I plan on a butcherblock top for mine (I would think cost for butcher block is pretty cheap, so that need not be factored in. My kid will not want that, and my wife mentioned Zinc or stainless steel. My question - what is the cost varience, high to low, on common countertop materials with DIY materials installation costs factored? Ceramic tile not a candidate - I have one now and hate it. Heard concrete stain and is not as easy as it seems. It is a given that laminate is lowest, then we have Corian, Granite, soapstone, Stainless Steel, Zinc (Never heard of zinc till she mentioned it).

Interested in costs. Thanks for any input.

Dan M.

Re: Countertop material costs...

#2

Re: Countertop material costs...

Steve Schoene

>Granite has become much more popular because it's price has reached the point where it is quite similar to imitators such as Corian, and the varnious plastic products calling themselves Quartz. Stainless steel in custom fabrications will be quite expensive, and I haven't heard of Zinc either, though it recalls something galvanized (which is a zinc coating.) Granite has many more interesting patterns than the synthetic substitutes.

You may have detected a bit of animous toward the quartz products such as Zodiaq. They tell you they are heat resistant, but don't mention the limits are quite a bit less than that for granite. (We have a friend who had a quarts counter destroyed by a hot pan. The 440� level used in some tests, is quite a bit lower than the 525+ levels reached by frying pans when oil is smoking and your first reaction might be to slide the pan onto the countertop. It may be 96% quartz, but the 6% plastic is the weakest link.) Wood tops would have a scorched ring in that case, but likely would be repairable, at least the first time.

Re: Countertop material costs...

#3

Re: Countertop material costs...

Barry Irby

>I saw Martha Stewart cover a table with zinc. I was just channel surfing and stumbled across it. The piece of metal she had was so soft it looked more like a pie crust (before being baked) that metal. They laid it out and folded the edges around the top with their hands. Piece looked to be about two feet square and I believe she said it was $70. If all of it is like that it would get pretty battered in my kitchen. Maybe there are different alloys.

Re: Countertop material costs...

#4

ZINC - MARTHA STEWART! YIKES!

dan Manturi

>If it was on her show, I think I want to pass it up. Maybe it is like shelf paper - you change it every 6 months.

Re: Countertop material costs...

#5

Re: Countertop material costs...

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>If all of it is like that it would get pretty

>battered in my kitchen. Maybe there are different alloys.

Zinc is quite soft. Applied to steel, galvanized, puts soft metal on a hard backing. There is a related process called galvaneal which converts the zinc coating to zinc-iron alloy - the process I am familiar with used induction heaters on the steel web just after the hot zinc dip to create the alloy. (Our group developed a non-contact phosphor/laser-based temperature sensor for process control.) I understand the advantage to using galvanealed over galvanized is if the object is to be painted.

As for the battering, I found these notes from a countertop company:

Does Zinc scratch?

- Yes, That's part of the country charm

-Re-sanding on site to remove signs of wear and scratches is also a fairly simple process.

Do Zinc Counters Tarnish?

- Yes ,They acquire a pewter gray patina.

- Food and drink will also create their own pattern of use on your countertop.

- Zinc acquires an oxidation layer (patina), imprecise and charming like a crudely made early American artifact.

- Certain areas have water which , while standing or puddling, may produce a white coating.


I think I'll stick to granite.

JKJ

Re: Countertop material costs...

#6

Short Answer

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>"It starts out shiny and new, then turns to crap in a week or two."

That about sum it up?

Anyone wanna bet Dear Martha has a bunch of stock in a Zinc mine?

mm

Re: Countertop material costs...

#7

Re: Countertop material costs...

Howard Norman

>Like others have said Zinc is very soft and for me would be undesirable because of that fact. I am using granite tile in my own kitchen.

Howard

Re: Countertop material costs...

#8

Re: Countertop material costs...

Dan Manturi

>Well, my lovely wife may like zinc, but it seems like it would be a constant battle, so that is out. I think it will be either butcher block or granite / soapstone.

Thanks.

Re: Countertop material costs...

#9

Try some vinegar on the zinc...

John in NM

>though the acid may be so weak that it has to sit over night to give you a really nasty etch. I'd say it would be only slightly worse than marble for a kitchen.