Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

wood movement by species chart?

Posts

wood movement by species chart?

#1

wood movement by species chart?

Michael Dresdner

>I'm looking for a chart, preferably online or in one of the books I already own, that shows the movement of already kiln dried wood (furniture components for example) due to the change in relative humidity, and divided by species. In other words, which woods move the most and least in use. In particular I need to know how poplar stacks up against other common woods.

Also, I'd like to find the average relationship between tangential shrinkage and linear. Hoadly cites one particular wood (red oak) and shows it as 0.1% to 8.6%, but does that hold for all woods?

Thanks.

Re: wood movement by species chart?

#2

JL

Re: wood movement by species chart? *LINK*

JL

>I downloaded the Wood Movement calculator a long time ago. The link is still valid.


Larry Marker's Calculator

Re: wood movement by species chart?

#3

Shrinkulator *LINK*

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Hope this helps. Ed


Shrinkulator

Re: wood movement by species chart?

#4

Re: wood movement by species chart? *LINK*

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Michael,

>chart...movement...kiln dried...

The table on pg 117 in Hoadley's "Understanding Wood" has the tangential and radial shrinkages for many species. The spreadsheet in the link below has the same info but for more species. While the table refers to green-to-oven dry, the way I read Hoadley, (estimation of) the movement you mention is calculated (pgs 118-122) based on this table and on the delta-MC, regardless of how the wood is dried, i.e., by kiln or otherwise. (The MC is everything, regardless of how it got there.) For a more accurate forumla for partially dry wood, note the box at the bottom of pg 120.

The Wood.xls spreadsheet from Oregon State University Extension (link) is one of the best I've seen for data and calculations. It should be possible to compare the species you mention. The dimensional calculations appear to use the more accurate formula. Another thing - all these calculations assume a FSP (fiber saturation point) of 30% where Hoadley assumes 28%. (And don't forget that MC and shrinkage depend on temperature as well as RH.)

If you want to make your own spreadsheet for a custom table, to save a lot of typing I suspect you can start with the data files that Lary Marker includes (JL's link). They should import nicely into Excel.

>average relationaship...

Between tangential and linear? By linear do you mean along the grain (longitudinal)? I haven't seen a table of comparing longitudinal shrinkage by species, perhaps due to what Hoadley implies (top of pg 117) that the 0.1% (green-to-oven dry) is typical for all woods. You could run the same dimensional calculations for that orientation. The 8.6% you mention comes directly from the species table in the N. Red Oak entry.

Another thing not always clarified in various calculators and tables - for our convenience wood can vary a lot from tree to tree even within the same species. For more fun, consider that in the real world a given board might have a combination of radial and tangential shrinkage across it's width. I like what Larry Marker says in his "A Word on Accuracy" (in JL's link) about not being fooled by computations to three decimal places!

JKJ


wood.xls, Oregon State Univ Ext

Re: wood movement by species chart?

#5

Re: wood movement by species chart?

Robin Corell, in Atascadero CA

>There is a table in Hoadley's book that shows a map of the US with an overlay of moisture content of interior wood work for summer and winter. this is the closest I have seen to something showing moisture level and relative humidity. most tables or calculators list shrinkage rates for radial and tangemtial and require you to know the amount of change in moisture in the wood. Don't know about you but if I knew that I probably wouldn't be looking for a shrinkage calculator in the first place.

One of the most valuable shrinkage calculators is a scrap of wood. take a scrap of a wide board and make a mark at something convienient like 1' then every couple of months make another mark at 1' and lable it with the date. afer a year or so you will have a visual record of the movement of that species of wood for 1'. this is particularly helpful when you work with local woods that are not usualy listed tables and calculators.

Robin

Re: wood movement by species chart?

#6

diff Tangential:Radial shrinkage for diff species *LINK*

Andrew F in Australia

>HI Michael,

I know of your background and reputation.

The Tangential:Radial shrinkage definitely varies for different species.

The ones you know as difficult to keep stable probably have a high difference between Tangential and Radial shrinkage.

The linked article below has a fairly good summary at the bottom of the article for various woods, including the poplar you're looking for.

Our local 'bible' is by one of our former CSIRO (US equivalent to the FPL) specialists - Mr Bootle.


http://www.shopsmithacademy.com/Index_files/wood.pdf

Re: wood movement by species chart?

#7

longitudinal shrinkage

Andrew F in Australia

>Sorry Michael,

Longitudinal shrinkage, I've always been told, was negligible.

Can't help you out with the longitudinal to tangential ratio.

But the higher the T/R ratio, the greater the movement.

CHeers,

Andrew

Re: wood movement by species chart?

#8

Re: wood movement by species chart?

Barry Irby

>The others have given you information on websites and charts for radial and tangential shrinkage.

I was always lead to believe that longitudinal shrinkage was negligible. Turns out that may not be true at least for some softwoods. Juvenile wood is the bane of the truss industry. In rapidly grown trees there may be enough juvenile wood to get a couple of 2x4's. This is the wood the tree produced when it was sapling and growing like a weed. Some of it has longitudinal shrinkage and expansion characteristics thirty times that of older slower grown timber. All the truss charts and engineering were based on fabricating trusses out of lumber that was essentially stable longitudinally. Not so with juvenile wood. We occasionally see trusses fabricated of it that arch or lift at the center as much as an inch or and inch and a half in winter. (Called Truss Lift)

I do not know if the phenomenon applies to anything other than soft woods, but I thought I would just throw it out there. It amy not apply to your situation at all.

Re: wood movement by species chart?

#9

me too, but

Michael Dresdner

>I always believed the same thing, but negligible is not a number, and in cases like this numbers matter.

The best I could conclude from various readings is that the average ratio from width to length movement is about .1 to 8.6 in green wood to dry, and varies by species from a low of .1 to 12 to a high of .1 to 6. Assuming the relative rates of movement are the same in dry wood as they are in wood going from green to dry (a huge assumption) that means you would get only one inch of movement for every 344 feet of length. Again, that assumes the green to dry rate is the same as the already dried rate of movement. I would assume the latter is lower.

Re: wood movement by species chart?

#10

Lee Grindinger

Many moons ago, in a galaxy far, far away

Lee Grindinger

>Michael, a while back I reviewed a program that does just that for FWW. Bill Duckworth was the editor in charge of product reviews at that time and asked for the CD back when I had finished with it. I would assume that CD is collecting dust in Bill's drawer so an email to him could provide you with just what you want.

I gave the program good marks, it was designed to act as a "shrinkalator" type program with specifics for hundreds of species, both North American and Exotics.

I don't have Bill's email but you know enough Taunton guys to run that down.

Lee

Re: wood movement by species chart?

#11

table assumptions

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The values in tables are computed by measuring the total shrinkage from some high value (can't remember what, probably about 30%) to 8% or 0% and from this total shrinkage an average shrinkage is calculated. This value will approximate what a wood worker really wants to know, which is how much does the piece change as a result of a moisture change from its KD state. The variance of what a piece of lumber actually shrank varied by a factor of 2 over a range of pieces of lumber according to some USDA data. And then sap wood shrinks more than heat wood. Added to all these variables, there is a bit of hysteresis such that lumber dried below its final equilibrium value will be a bit more stable than lumber dried to an equilibrium value. So, what ever you find in a table consider that in a given piece of lumber the actual stability may be more or less. Poplar is about average. White pine is best and mahogany is very good. Beech poor.

In my experience slow growth poplar will be more stable than poplar with big growth rings.