Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Laminate flooring user history sought

Posts

Laminate flooring user history sought

#1

Laminate flooring user history sought

Pete in Holland

>Guys -

Pondering a laminate floor in my kitchen. Have heard war stories about spilled liquids and raised joints. Are there better products out there regarding water tightness of the joints? Is gluing the joint better insurance? Is the risk of raised joints due to a water spill the nature of the beast ?

What have you installed, how was it installed, and how is it holding up ?

Many thanks !

Pete

Re: Laminate flooring user history sought

#2

Probably not much help

David Yoho

>Pete, I don't think I could bring myself to install that type of flooring in my kitchen. In fact, when we built this house about eleven years ago, people thought we were nuts to install real hardwood floors in our kitchen. I have to say it was a good choice for us and it still looks as good now as the first day.

My wife was very worried about water spills hurting the floor. We have five coats of poly finish on them and water or other liquids has never been a problem. Even when we found a leak under the sink that caused the builder to replace the base cabinet, the floor was just fine. It's been through a lot with our two boys and the amount of traffic our kitchen sees and still shows no signs of it.

So, my point simply is you might want to think about installing the real thing, if wood is what you want. It might cost you more but in the long run may end up being the better choice and dispense all those worries.

My 2 cents,

David

Re: Laminate flooring user history sought

#3

Re: Probably not much help....Either, but...

Barry Irby

>As a Home Inspector I see enough of this stuff to reinforce your concerns. I frequently see it with curled edges, swollen edges and a puffy looking surface. Its cleat tot me that there are a number of different qualities of product out there and if you don't get the good stuff, you will be disappointed. If I were considering it, I would get samples of the products and drop them in water for days or weeks and watch. It should be unaffected. I think you will find some of it fails rather quickly.

What really concerns me and puts me off the product is the curled or turned up edges. This is a common defect in the older floors I see. The flooring turns up for about a 1/4 or 3/8" at the joints. Not much. maybe one or two hundredths of an inch, but enough to create a poor appearance and a problem. The edges break or scuff off the pieces and the appearance of the joint loses that nice crisp line.

I recently saw hardwood floor that came primed all the way around. It had been dipped in some sort of clear sealer. The idea was that you install it, sand the top flat and finish it in the usual fashion. Leaves you with the edges and back sealed and the top finished. Seemed like a good idea to me.

David is right. An excellent finish on hardwood is the key to performance. Its the finish that you walk on, that seals it and protects it.

I have Bruce prefinished full thickness oak in my dining room. It does not have an excellent finish. I thought it came with some sort of super tough lifetime finish. NOT! The finish is crap. Every time I see it I tell people they should have it lightly sanded (screened) and a better finish applied, before they move in.

Re: Laminate flooring user history sought

#4

Re: Laminate flooring user history sought

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Check out Marmoleum. It's real linoleum topped 1x3 snap-together tile flooring. The seams disappear when it's together. I used it in a kitchen/breakfast area remodel, and am very pleased with the performance. Looks good, too.

Clint

Re: Laminate flooring user history sought

#5

Re: Laminate flooring user history sought

Tom

>I've put laminate in our last house and our current house, in many rooms. I've used Pergo, some cheap (68 cents/sq ft) Menard's brand and a name brand I bought from Home Depot but can't remember right now. The old kitchen got the Pergo. We were in it for about 2 years and never had a problem. The current kitchen got the Home Depot stuff. I elected to use the glue-together kind (not the snap-together), thinking the joints would be more waterproof. It looks the same now as it did when I put it in (once the dirt is cleaned up, that is). We've been on it for 5 years, and have three kids, an 8 yr old and 5 yr old twins. It sees A LOT of use/abuse, including a lot of spills, kids running through with muddy feet, leaking dishwashers, dropped appliances (there is one small chip, from the tip of an iron, about 1/8" diameter), etc.. If I ruined it tomorrow, I'd be happy with what I got out of it and would gladly put another one in. First though, I'd fight with the manufacturer to see what I could get out of the lifetime warranty.

Re: Laminate flooring user history sought

#6

A.J. Hamler

Re: How much water do you really spill?

A.J. Hamler

>First of all, as a couple people have mentioned already, get good laminate and not cheap stuff. That's the key. There's not all that much difference in pricing by the time you're done, so go for the better stuff.

Now, how much water do you plan to spill? And, when you spill it do you plan to just let it sit there or will you clean it up in short order? Sound like dumb questions, but they're not. Everyone assumes that just the idea of laminate in a kitchen is bad, but in practice you're not spilling gallons of water every day, if ever. Sure, an exploded water pipe or dishwasher would be one thing, and that would ruin just about any kind of floor if it got underneath of it, but in reality the volume of most kitchen spills is small. For that matter, most kitchen spills are food-related (thicker and slower-running) and not water. And if you're like most people, if you spill something in the kitchen you'll clean it up quickly.

Our house is going on eight years old and has had laminate in the kitchen since day one, and it looks just as good as the day it was put in. It's very easy to clean and take care of. I'd have no hesitation about having laminate in any future kitchen.

Of course, if you have five kids that spill/pour/splash/drop/spray copious amounts of water literally every day, that would be another kettle of fish. (If you spill a kettle of fish in the kitchen, that would be another kettle of, well, you know.) But for normal kitchen use by relatively careful people, it's not automatically the poor choice everyone makes it out to be. IMHO, of course.

A.J.

Re: Laminate flooring user history sought

#7

Re: Laminate flooring user history sought

David Hay @ Denver

>We put laminate flooring (Alloc brand) in our kitchen and haven't had any problems. We even had the dishwasher leak on it without any ill effects that I can see. So far we've been happy with it and it's much nicer than the nasty tile that it replaced.

The main problem with water, from what I understand, is when there's a spill and it's allowed to sit for a long period of time.

Hope that helps!

David

Re: Laminate flooring user history sought

#8

Re: How much water do you really spill?

paul in AZ

>That implies that nothing will ever go wrong.

A friend had a Pergo floor put into her kitchen; that had to get ripped out because of tented, swollen joints; then the replacement Pergo was ruined when her dishwasher erupted. Pergo delaminated and turned to cardboard.

I used two tests for a cottage porch floor. Pound with a hammer. Most are very dent and scratch resistant, some a bit better. Then I threw some samples into my fountain overnight. Pergo and some of the cheap ones delaminate. I wound up with Witec [sp?] for a glassed in porch that had a lot of in/out wet and muddy traffic.

None of the laminates will feel and sound like real floors. Cheap is cheap.

For a subsequent kitchen and back entry floor in my 'winter' house I put in cork planks. Fabulous but pricey. Great to walk on, exuding 'quality' if you ever sell the house and obviously resistant to almost everything. Dead simple to install if you have a chop saw.

Re: Laminate flooring user history sought

#9

Cork Planks?

Larry Marker in Alabama

>I've not heard of cork planks before. I have seen cork floor tiles.

We have ancient carpet in our bathroom that needs to be replaced. I've been considering cork tiles, but I had one remodler recommend against it. He said that unless I put sealer on it about every two years, I would be gravely disappointed in its tolerance for water.

What are cork planks and where do you get them? Have you found it necessary to apply sealer to them since installation?

Larry

Re: Laminate flooring user history sought

#10

Re: Cork Planks?

paul in AZ

>There are two common forms of cork flooring.

Tiles come in sheets around 12X12" and are something like 3/16" thick. These get glued down. This gives a cork look but is a second rate solution.

The planks are 12X36" by around 3/8" and have a central core of some supercompressed material with a layer of cork on the underside and about 3/16" of compressed cork chips on the face. The face comes in a wide variety of textures and colors. The planks are edge glued T&G and or snap joined. A floating floor seems to be the most recommended. They are prefinished and are easy to cut cleanly with a sliding miter saw and a good blade. Once down a couple of coats of water borne poly mopped on with a wool mop will seal the cracks. The cork itself is watertight [think wine] even without the poly and resists everything... I'm told even termites don't like it. Installation was pretty easy.

The surface is soft to walk on, quiet, and will indent but will bounce back.

I got mine from Natural Cork [based in Atlanta I think]. There are other makers but that is the one I wound up liking most.

Re: Laminate flooring user history sought

#11

Re: Laminate flooring user history sought

Dan Manturi

>I have one. It cleans well. Looks good. But I would not use it again. I put mine in in 2001. Did careful subfloor prep. Spot where dog dosh sits started to raise. Dog is not a careful drinker. I keep telling her she has a drinking problem... Anyway, we put a larger tray under the dog dish when we saw the seams start to raise. Also, make sure you have perfectly flat surface for installation as over time any peaks and valleys will transmit through in the form of seam problems. I mean perfectly flat!

I did not buy a cheap floor. Paid a premium price even with a discount. When it comes to kitchens, I think, as ordinary as it seems, sheet floor is the way to go. I like my slate floor in the dining room for wear and tear and ease of cleaning, but you drop something on it and it is history. Ceramic tile - same thing.

Good luck.

Re: Laminate flooring user history sought

#12

Try Wilsonart

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>We put down Wilsonart flooring in out kitchen, dining room and entry. Pergo wasn't warranted for kitchens or bathrooms due to the potential for water. Wilsonart does guarantee installation in those areas!

We've had our fooring in place for 5-6 years and it still looks like new. Mud water and the dog don't seem to have any impact on it. All the traffic in our house goes through the kitchen and dining room. We've never had any major water spills, but I didn have some water come under the door in the entry way and it was on the flooring sor several days before it was discovered (we weren't home). There is no sign of any raising or swelling despite the fact that I got a seam less than perfectly tight at the exact spot where the water was.

Lee

Re: Laminate flooring user history sought

#13

Interesting feed back thus far ! !

Pete in Holland, MI

>Cool flow of information. Some like. Some hate. Seems bout 50-50 for the likes -vs- dislikes thus far.

I have heard from some folks that the accoustic properties are a sign of "cheap", and have never thought of that. Twas in a buddies house this weekend. He had both real wood and laminate. The laminate survived the dog better than the real wood (claw marks), but it sounded cheap and a chip occurred when chair was slammed down that would have been a dent in real wood.

Nothing lasts for ever. Guess it just depends on how I'll want the floor to age.

Pete

Re: Laminate flooring user history sought

#14

Re: Laminate flooring user history sought

Geoff in Madison

>I put in Marmoleum two years ago in kitchen, dining room, entryway and powder room. It holds up great. Standing water on it won't help it any, but normal kitchen spillage is no problem.