I am renting a 59 year-old brick building, 40'x100' with 12' ceilings. The front 40'x40' is divided from the rear area by a wall, though there is a double door with an arched transom above connecting the two areas. The very front of the building is mostly glass, facing East/Southeast, so there is considerable solar gain. That means I need less heat up front in the winter, but more A/C in the summer. The front area will be a retail space.
I'll be adding at least 12" of insulation to the ceiling, but I plan to leave the double brick walls as is.
I'm going to need to heat and cool this space as energy efficiently as possible. I do have lots of roof space for solar and the possibility of an old well that could be used for a water-source heat pump.
Anyone have suggestions or ideas for an integrated system?
Obviously, I'm just beginning my research. I don't know yet how many BTU's a space that size would need in East TN.
>Gary, you have a huge number of variables and before anyone could accurately advise you they would need more info. You mentioned the front is retail space, what will the rear be? That helps determine the quality of the system you need.
Some stray thoughts:
The 12" of insulation in he ceiling is good.
The East south east facing glass is a blessing and a curse. Yes is gains significant heat during the day, but loses as much or more at night. At least in the winter. In summer it gains more than it loses and the light may damage or fade whatever it is you are retailing. Give this a lot of thought. The quality of the treatment of the windows will dramatically affect eh perception of the quality of the space and the comfort and expense. You may want UV coatings on the glass and an over hang?awning to cut direct gain in summer. This is tricky because if there is a sidewalk in front of the space it makes an excellent reflector and the light bounces up from below. Just handling the front is a huge topic.
Sound is another issue. You can get ductless heat pumps that have an indoor unit or units and an outdoor unit, but no ducts. These are sort of like a window or thru wall unit split into two pieces. I would suspect it would be noisy and a bit crude because without ducting, they dump all the heat or cool in at the unit.
So, Where are you going to hide the ducts?
The water source or ground coupled heat pumps are excellent, but they need a huge amount of water. I am not an expert but I believe they need 3 to 5 GPM per ton. Your retail space would probably need three tons and the balance of the building would need about five. Just guessing at those numbers, but not many wells will reliably produce thirty or forty gallons per minute. There are other issues with these systems as well. (note pun here) I believe many jurisdictions are restricting the use of well water because you are extracting huge amounts of water from the aquifers and dumping it down the drain. They have gotten touchy about using a second well as a discharge point because of the possibility of polluting the ground water. At the very least you would be changing the temp of the ground water. Another concern is dumping the water into the municipal sewer. It goes to the sewage treatment plant even though it does not need to. (If everybody did it they would need a much bigger plant and the aquifer would run dry.) Remember, if that well runs out of water, you are out of heat and AC and have some very useless equipment.
Hence, the ground coupled heat pump. You install hundreds or thousands of feet of high density plastic pipe, either in trenches or vertically in wells. Your water/fluid circulates in the pipes and is never dumped. It just goes around and around. This largely eliminates the concerns about contaminating the aquifers and flooding the treatment plant, and reduces pumping costs. But all this pipe and installation is expensive. Often ten or even tens of thousands of dollars. This requires an economic analysis. If you borrow 10k at $10 per month per thousand the ground source system would cost you $100 a month more than an air source system. The question becomes does it save you more than that in energy costs? And will it last longer than the mortgage?
I have not seen a functioning solar system in ten years. They were treated like a fad. They were built by start-up companies and the government put ridiculous demands on them. These fledgling companies had to provide five (or ten?) year warranties when the mainstream companies were not required to prove any warranty) I suspect your TN climate is like mine here in VA. Too much dreary weather in the winter to make it work well.
>Find a local HVAC company to run a "J manual" on your building and tell you the results. This will give you the heat loss/ heat gain you are dealing with. A calculation on this building would be relatively simple, most or all the glass is in the front and the rest of the building is pretty consistent and mundane.
Be aware that many of these systems are installed on the SWAG method often based on what equipment the guy has handy or can get at a discount. Also, Its a "hard sell" but the equipment should be the right size or slightly too small. Much more efficient that way, but many installers and customers fear undersized equipment, thus most of it is way over sized. Think about it. It sized for almost the hottest or coldest day of the year. Any other day its oversized anyway. So, if you have it slightly too small for the worst day of the year, its closer to the right size the rest of the time. Then, on that freak day when its 97 outside, its 80 inside instead of 75. Or, when its 10 outside, its 65 inside instead of 70. You don't die, you are just a little uncomfortable for a few hours.
Another thought. Heat pumps don't do well at starting cold and racing to catch up. If you are going to use heat pumps, you should plan on setting the temperature and leaving it alone 24/7 or getting a thermostat designed to set it back at night and bring it up slowly in the morning.
Barry gave you good advice based on my own experience several years ago. To make a long story short, I found a reputable HVAC contractor (out of four) who was willing (without our asking) to take the time to do a heating/cooling load calculation for our house. It took the contractor around an hour to walk through the house measuring everything, then a week or so to get back to us. The multiple-page printout was fascinating to read (and see where the greatest loss was), but then I sorta like those type of things. He said they would like to do this on all new installs, but customers want it done NOW rather than wait a week.
The link below to a HVAC forum might help you. If you are so inclined, go to the link at the top of this forum page and download the trial version of HVAC-Calc. It is a well regarded program that is easy to use, but again I like that sort of thing. The trial version (free for one-time use, IIRR) got fairly close to the contractor's values, but I really wanted an experienced contractor to do it as well. And the quality of the installation is extremely important as well. As Barry said, most installs are done using the SWAG method, or based on floor dimensions, not good especially if you have a house that is different than the standard tract house. Hope this helps. Good luck.
>Gary, I'm in Central Indiana, so we are a few degrees colder than you. I would not look at solar - I had one friend that installed a major brand of solar panels and another that had a company install them on his fairly new home. The one that installed them had lots of complaints - the heat gain was far less than people anticipated. The friend that installed them on his roof did a pretty fair cost analysis. He had them installed while the Federal government was subsidizing the cost, so paid about half the actual cost. His figures suggested he would pay for (his cost) in about 20 years. On cold days - 20 degree or below - he saw very little if any heat gain, colder than that it was shut off to prevent loss. This was even on sunny days. It seemed to work very well at around 50 deg and above, suggesting they may be good for very mild areas. Not sure what the requirements for the water - heat transfer - heat pump systems are as I have never installed any or had any experience. May be a good option if the details work out. Near my city we do have a community built around an artificial lake, the developer installed heat pumps using the lake water as a source. This seems to have worked out very well. In your area, I believe I would look at a conventional heat pump system with a NG or propane fuel source incorporated if natural gas is not available in your location. These seem to be the best value / most efficient system in the temperature range you will encounter.
>I run a 50K btu unit to heat my house (1900 sq ft ranch) and it costs less than $130 a month for all my electricity (lights, cooking & HW). We do not have A/C. We have had the system in place for over 25 years with only insiginificant maintainence issues. We use a two well system and use about 8-10 gpm when the system runs. They are clean and quiet and will run practically forever. Note: newer systems use circuit boards a which are more prone to fail than the old systems.
I love our system and think highly of geothermal systems, but if you are renting it is unlikely you would ever get a return on your investment unless you rent for more than 15 years. The initial cost of a ground source heat pump is more than a conventional heaitng system. I went from baseboard electric to geothermal and it took 8-10 years to pay off in savings.
I just priced a new system for my house that would also include A/C and to get the same heating capacity and sufficient cooling my cost would be about $9,000 installed. I can add a conventional A/C system to my present system for less than $3500. Energy savings of the new heatpump is so small compared to the existing one there would be virtually no payback during the heating season. Obviously the A/C would use less energy than a conventional unit, but it would never pay off the $5.5K difference.
The other suggestions for coating the window and installing insulated glass with Low E capability would problably pay off sooner.