>I'm in the process of building a fireplace surround, using a mix of soft maple and maple plywood and marble-ish looking tiles. It's a little too white looking right now, so SWMBO wants to darken it a bit, but not golden yellow. Any suggestions and or procedures on how I can finish this. Any magic recipes?
>What have you done so far? Are you still at the sample stage, or have you put on some finish and want to darken from their. If you have put something on what was it--ie what brands.
>The recipe is patience. Maple yellows naturally. It will go from white to a soft amber fairly quickly in a bright room eg a kitchen, a little more slowly in a darker room, but in both cases it will get there.
Using poly as a finish will impart a yellow tone immediately, but it will darken further over time, and then stabilize.
>I built a master bath of soft maple and maple ply, and finished it with shellac and thinned spar varnish, wiped on. I could have, and perhaps should have, left the shellac off. It imparted a nice, soft, warmth to the wood, but not too much darker. Three years and counting.
Sample boards are your ticket. Get her to mark the choice, so you 'don't forget which one she chose'. DAMHIKT.
>Warren, if you want a particular hue and value (lightness/darkness) that will remain fairly constant, you need to play with some dye stains. Left to its own devices, maple will yellow, as several have said. A lot of people don't care for the look of yellowed natural maple, and it sounds like you are one of them.
What I suggest is that you decide what hue you like, perhaps something in the brownish range. Make up some dye stain -- I like water-soluble powders myself, but Trans Tints are well regarded by many people -- in either a cool or a warm brown color and then dilute it until it isn't too dark. Make up some samples of wood and plywood that are sanded just like your mantle will be, stain them with your dye, and then finish them just as you plan to finish the real deal. This will show you exactly what to expect, so you can change the dilution or hue if necessary.
You might find that the plywood takes stain a little differently than the solid wood. Dyes are your best bet for as even a finish as possible.
>Great, the time to consider the finish is early in the process. Ellis is right about the benefits of dye on woods like maple. Much less potential for blotching, and you can get just about however dark you want with dye. Lots of sample boards. Remember, dye may look VERY different when it dries on the wood than it will look when a top coat is applied over it, so put at least a coat of your top coat on the samples. (You can get a pretty good idea of the look under finish by wiping with mineral spirits.)