using compound on strops
wayne
>Am making a couple of strops and need to know how much compound to put on them, and can valve grinding compound be used as I can get it from 280-1200 grit.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
using compound on strops
wayne
>Am making a couple of strops and need to know how much compound to put on them, and can valve grinding compound be used as I can get it from 280-1200 grit.
I wouldn't use valve grinding compound.
Forrest Addy
>I wouldn't use valve grinding compound. Too coarse. I have good results using rouge or white buffing compound. Rub it in good using a little mineral spirits to soften it for easier apreading.
I get razor keen edges.
Aout rubbing compound
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>
That's Auto rubbing compound
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>
Re: using compound on strops
Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.
>For polishing metals I use a compound called Simi Chrome. Really a jewelers polish but will create a mirror like finish. Available many places. Just Google Simi Chrome.
Re:Forrest...
Dale Lenz
>does it matter what color rouge a person uses? Seems like everyone talks about the green, I've got white. Where's the normal places to purchase a piece of rouge, beside a jeweler? Everytime I ask, I get a funny look, I tell'um, I'm straight, : ' >. I'm new to stropping irons on leather.
TIA
Re: Clint...
Dale Lenz
>Myself and another guy, David (likes to mess with metal) was talking about honing metal on leather the other day, he suggested I try Auto rubbing compound. Then David said, but paint is softer than metal. Just asking and wondering. Dale
Ken-works better for polishing Harleys!!
Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa
>
Re: using compound on strops
jmohnike
>Sears, at one time, carried the product. You may be able to buy it in a kit with 4 types or just a single stick.
I use the red jewelers rouge.
Joe
Re: Clint...
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>Rubbing compound can also be used to polish metal and it will absorb into the leather a lot easier than a rouge stick. In general, I don't think it necessary to charge a strop. I finish my knives on an old barber's strop, which is actually two belts: a waxed linen strop to transition from the stone, followed by a cordovan leather strop. I occassionally dress the leather with a squirt of WD40, and that's enough to finish an edge suitable for shaving.
Clint
Re: Thanks, Joe
Dale Lenz
>
Re: Clint...thanks for the reply
Dale Lenz
>
you could try Lee Valley. *LINK*
Bruce, a MN Galoot
>
Lee Valley honing compound
Buffing compound colors
Forrest Addy
>Buffing compound colors are an artifact of the abrasive use in their formulation.
Here's a link to a discussion of the abrasives and their uses: http://www.hobbytool.com/jewelers-rouge.htm.
Red rouge (iron oxide) and white rouge (aluminum oxide) are the ones I've found most effective for refining cutting edges but the distinctions are actually small. People who love to argue can devote entirew careers supporting or rejecting one common buffing compound compared to another.
The important thing is to charge the strop with some finely divided abrasive to perform the final step in producing a keen cutting edge. Bare leather along will not do the job except for removing the edge burr. However the firm fiberous nature of leather provided a good "tooth" to trap the abrasive grains and present them to the metal surface passing over them. The result is a finer cutting edge than can be readily attained with stones or commonly available abrasive paper.
Now is a good time to suggest that people in search of a good sharpening system should conduct some research, pick a likely method that suits them, and stick with it. Do not get lost in mystique or the blather of alledged experts promoting mystical messages and expensive equipment. The woodworking magazine reqularly publish articles in sharpening equipment that confuse more then they clarify.
There are several good systems in common use and they are roughly equivalent in results. They are the Tormek, the scary sharp, the bench stone and strop, and varations of these themes forming a field too wide for a forum discussion. Some are more expensive than others but no system replaces practice and skill development. The Tormek system is almost bullet proof. If can you follow instructions for using the Tormek gadgets, you will get good results in the form of keen edges. A bench stone and a strop gets as keen a cutting edge in about the same time as a Tormek with about 1/10 the initial investment but the skill level is bumped up several notches.
Edge sharpening is not an end in itself but a means of refreshing cutting edges so you can go back to work. If it takes you more than a minute or two to restore a used cutting edge to razor keenness you are wasting time. You need to work on speed and understanding if not both.
Re: using compound on strops
Bill White
>I have both aluminum oxide powder and the green compound stick. Both work well for the final polish.
Bill