Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Decline of Western Civilization . . .

Posts

Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#1

Decline of Western Civilization . . .

steve mackay

>Came out of Dillard's getting LOML's Christmas "smell-good" and wandered into the Craftsman door just for a RECON. Looked at the new bench sander. Eh Gods, plastic houseing and base. No iron left in the whole joint. So much for Craftsman. My two old cast iron ones will have to " become one " next break down.

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#2

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>I have a Craftsman 6"X48" belt sander I bought in 1962. Never needed one repair in all those years. Little wiggle in the bearings now but nothing else. Them days is gone forever------

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Pssst, the 20th century is history......

Jesper, Denmark

>What you are seeing is good 'ol Amurrican ingenuity!

Also called engineered plastics.

I recently spent some time in a car bumper plant. What used to be bumpers are now the complete front, including grille, headlights etc. Molded in one piece and weighing about a couple of pounds. How much fuel it saves I do not know, but the weight saving and labor savings are significant over the way they used to be built.

I think you better get used to it.

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#4

Re: Pssst, the 20th century is history......

Charles Wiggins

>Jesper,

I'd rather have my 1/4" steel channel bumper that will destroy anyone foolish enough to hit me!

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#5

Re: Pssst, the 20th century is history......

Ernie Miller

>Charles the bumper on the truck is 4" steel pipe with caps welded on the ends it doubbles as an air bubble so if it fractures in a colision I guess there is a little more umph in mine

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#6

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

Mac in Indy

>Yes, Jesper, engineered plastics are a wonderful thing, but I think what Steve and Ken are lamenting are the loss of perceived durability that the metal housings have over the plastic. There is no doubt that a properly designed and manufactured plastic housing/part can be as strong as it's metal counterpart and it's less expensive to make, ship and sell however those of us who are a little older have seen those good old tools made with metal housings and parts last multiple decades whereas the plastic generation of tools have yet to prove they are as durable so in our eyes metal is still better. In 20 to 30 years that perception will likely shift but for now metal has the perceived edge.

Mac

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#7

Bumper hitches.

Basil

>I think they got thrown into the last load of scrap steel I sold but I had two "bumper hitches". One was for a '55 Chevrolet and the other a '57 ford. They clipped onto (fit the shape of)the rear bumpers of said models and had pulled many a overloaded trailer load of hay/feed/wood/livestock/whatever.

My daddy used a car like many people use a pickup these days.

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#8

Re: Bumper hitches.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>"My daddy used a car like many people use a pickup these days."

My dad had a 57 Desoto 4-door hardtop that we used for a work car. It held his Delta contractor saw in the back seat. Plus other stuff. That trunk was big enough to smuggle an entire family.

Bruce

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#9

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

Dick Coers

>An engineer friend of mine had a great thought on this. He blames the "decline" on the invention of the process to chrome plate plastic. When they came up with that process, it was all over!!!! LOL

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#10

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

Pete in Holland, MI

>Yea, older cars used to have a lot of steel in them making them pretty tough, and yea, plastic cars don't take as much abuse, BUT, cars are designed to collapse during a collision and absorb the stopping energy, rather than impart that energy to the occupants.

Remember cars from the 50's & 60's? Steel dash boards? Zink knobs as big as your thumb? Next time you go to a car show, take a look at your current dash board and decide whether you would like to be thrown against it or something from the past.

How many people do you know that were in accidents going highway speeds and walked away from them with little bodily damage ? Yea, your car is schmucked, but you aren't.

Good trade-off.

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#11

Re: Pssst, the 20th century is history......

Charles Wiggins

>Maybe. It depends a lot on how thick the wall of your tube is. My 1/4" channel is welded to a 1/4" angle, to which the mounting brackets are welded, so mine bumper is actually 1/2" thick across the middle, to within 2" of the ends.

Of course, if I ever get hit really hard the frame of the truck is going to bend before the bumper does (not good)!

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#12

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>Coincides with a thread on the neander side about plastic.

Personally, I'm not opposed to plastic but I am opposed to low quality. Unlike some, I don't equate plastic to low quality (although it may be the case of the c'man sander ... don't know for sure). If the correct type of plastic is used in parts that won't hurt the product functionally, I'm fine with it. Especially if I can get good quality stuff for less.

I got one of the first Unisaws with a plastic motor cover. I believe it was called the decline of western civilization back then on Badger Pond. Everyone was going to have to buy PM66s since they were the only other US made saw and they had a metal cover (for another 6months or so anyway). Personally I thought it was pretty slick, there's a place to stick my wrenches and miter gauge molded in. Haven't misplaced my wrenches yet (one of the few things that size in my shop I can say that about).

If steel prices continue on their current course, we'll have to get used to it. I'm ready to embrace the change, but I won't change my mind about cheap poor performing tools.

Jay

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#13

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

Stuart Hough

>I am like several others, in that , I don't have a problem per se with plastics themselves, just the overuse in structural parts. It just seems that too many things have been "reverse-engineered" so that even the plastics cost can be reduced.

Oh and by the way, when talking about the injuries received in an old-style '50s vehicle, I don't believe I have ever seen power tools going 50-60 mph and wrecking, unless you count that 3x18 belt sander that got away...it was really funny until my Dad walked out to see what the uproar was, and saw the sander do a backflip when it reached the end of the cord! Man! I still feel the "heat-on-the-seat"!

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#14

Jesper, Denmark

I guess the most logical extension would be.....

Jesper, Denmark

>Moving up from a PU truck to a Hummer? .....Nah, better go the whole hog and drive an armored personnel carrier.

But then your neighbor is going to look around for an old Sherman tank?

Where will it all end?

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#15

Other considerations

Dan Donaldson

>There are a couple of other considerations also. One is safety. Cars today are designed to have controlled crushing of the structure in a crash to absorb the energy. This makes it a lot safer for the passengers, but, unfortunately, greatly increases the cost of repairs. The same type of philosophy is used in crash helmets. If you ever wear one and hit your head, you should replace the helmet, or at least get it checked by the mfr. The inside of the helmet is designed to destroy itself to protect your head. Cars are designed the same way today. Personally, I would much rather have a dead car than a dead driver ;-)

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#16

(chuckle ! ) Mine was . . .

steve mackay

>the " new & improved " lock button on the drill Dad had. Just kept going and going !

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#17

Amen !

steve mackay

>

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#18

Re: I guess the most logical extension would be...

Charles Wiggins

>I'm guessing you've never seen what happens to a plastic car out on a worksite. My truck has been backed into four times (that I know of), and there's the times I've had to back into trees and walls because there was so little room to turn around. After 18 years I'm still driving it without one body repair. It's not about what the neighbor has, it's about keeping what I've got.

Re: Decline of Western Civilization . . .

#19

Jesper, Denmark

Don't get me wrong.....

Jesper, Denmark

>I am hanging on to my tools with stiff and heavy cast iron components, because that is an advantage in some areas. The best saw I ever worked on was a 2 ton 1� hp flat belt driven 20" tablesaw in a boatshop. NOTHING YOU DID WOULD STOP IT. What it did not have in HP, it had in stored up energy and stability.

On the other hand, with consumers of tools wanting lower prices and better performance, you just cannot throw lots of cast and heavy components into the design and expect to build it and ship it competitively.

I also liked my Buick Le Sabre 1972, but today, it is a dinosaur compared to the Skoda Octavia i am toodling around in. It was fun at the time, but this is better, faster, more economical, handles better, accelerates better and gets 45+mpg compared to 10. I will admit that you cannot stretchout completely across the back seat while the missus drives you across Iowa.