Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Never say Never! *LINK*

Posts

Never say Never! *LINK*

#1

Never say Never! *LINK*

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Usually I like making decisions about tool purchases on my own. Who better knows what I want and how I'm going to use it? But this time I'm stuck!

I'm in the market for a small trim router, and for the life of me can't really decide which one would be best. I plan to use it on light routering, such as round-overs, shallow flutes,etc., and of coarse thin material trim work. I keep looking at the Porter-Cable 310 laminate production router, but then I also like the Bosch Colt trim router.Both have variable speed, which I like. Opinions? You guys might think something else might be better- I've an open mind!

This is an add-on to the router arsenal I already have, all of which are bigger, heavier models of both fixed and plunge based. Bosch, Porter-Cable, and(Gulp)Skil. I just want a small, under-powered one to cuss at when I'm in the need!

Below is the URL to the PC router;

Ron in Iowa


http://ec1.images-amazon.com/images/I/21JPS67838L.

Re: Never say Never! *LINK*

#3

Re: Bosch Colt Router

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Hello Ron,

I'd love to have both. So far I have resisted the urge to upgrade from my Chicago Electric $14.00 Harbor Freight special which I've had for 5 or 6 years now. I bought the other P+C laminate trimmer(forget the model number)for #3 son through Craig's List. It was nearly unused, and the price of $20 seemed reasonable. I did like the Ridgid very much at HD. Frankly I'd use a laminate trimmer infrequently, mostly to gain hinges. My guess is any of them wood work for basic stuff. Take your pick.

George

Re: Never say Never! *LINK*

#4

Ron - I'd

Howard In Toronto

>avoid the Bosch.

It's still a little new.

If memory serves it's already exhibited the alumium base problem their other routers had too.

If they were my choices, I'd lean towards the P-C.

It's been proven in many many heavy-duty production situations.

But I don't think they make a VS version.

However, if you think plunge capability might be useful, Makita makes a small light package.

It's the 3621.

While the base is larger than a more conventional laminate trimmer, the plunge and extra power are very very useful.

I use it regularly when my (Makita) laminate trimmer

HTH

Howard

Howard

Re: Never say Never! *LINK*

#5

A.J. Hamler

Re: Never say Never!

A.J. Hamler

>Be sure to check out the Ridgid trim router. It's quite nice.

A.J.

Re: Never say Never! *LINK*

#6

The router you love to hate...

Jesse Cloud

>I have a colt, early version, understand there have been some improvements. I like the concept, small form, adjustable, etc. But I have a hard time getting useful work out of it. The depth adjustment is really sloppy. Bit changing, in spite of their adverts, requires a wrench in a very small space - think bloody knuckles.

Given how often we need to make a mortise for small hinges or ease the edge of a small piece, you would think that the market would have produced better products. I'm definitely looking into Howard's Makita solution.

The other complaint is that I would really like to see where the darned thing is cutting, but the various parts always get in the way.

If someone could make a small router that has reliable depth adjustment, a good optional fence, and visibility of the bit, and dare I say dust control?? - surely they would be a millionaire overnight!!

Re: Never say Never! *LINK*

#7

Re: Thanks, Howard!

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>I think you've helped me decide on the PC. Reviews are good, though both routers had reviews that complained about bits not releasing from the collet. Heck, I'm used to that, as my old Skil has done that from day one, and I know how to handle that problem!

One reason I was looking hard toward the Bosch Colt is because I've had really good service from my 1619EVS plunge. It's just a little on the heavy side and is permanently in solitary confinement under my router table.

Just been wanting something a little lighter and easier to use on the small jobs where dragging out a big router seems to be overkill.

Ron in Iowa

Re: Never say Never! *LINK*

#8

Re: Thanks, Howard!

NickB

>Yes, do get the PC 310, and keep a stick of wood handy for releasing the bits (lube the collet regularly with some machine oil and things will go much easier). Pat Warner makes a clear offset base for the 310 that would be a substantial improvement (I think about it every time I'm doing something where it would be nice to see the bit from the topside, but for reasons not clear to me I haven't pulled the trigger on this purchase yet).

Mine lives with a 1/8" round over bit in it unless I'm doing something else like hanging doors-it's fabulous for things that are light cuts and only takes one hand to use.

Nick

Re: Never say Never! *LINK*

#9

I have a Colt and I like it a lot.

Hank Knight

>

Re: Never say Never! *LINK*

#10

Re: I have both

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>The PC310 is one I wouldn't let go of. It's got a Warner replacement base, and fits my hands well.

The Bosch is a good router, but not in the same class, from a 'this feels like a pro's tool' perspective. I've done a lot of work with it, but I'm happier with the results from the PC.

When I bought them, there couldn't have been $20 difference in what I paid, and now that I think about it, I couldn't say which was more money.

-owner and user of maybe 6 routers...