Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Need beam suggestions for bridge

Posts

Need beam suggestions for bridge

#1

Need beam suggestions for bridge

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>We have a creek through our property that rises about 8� in a heavy rain. The bed is clay and small gravel that washes out easily with the high flow rate during floods.

I need to build a 40� long bridge that will carry me (200 lbs. +/_), the yard tractor (about 300 lbs.) and a trailer with a 55 gal. water tank (about 600 lbs.) from the top of one bank to the other. Because of the soft bottom I think piers would wash out in a fairly short time so I�d like to make it a clear span.

There are a bunch of methods for building beams, horizontally laminated, vertically laminated, plywood I beams, steel, truss and humongo timbers.

Does anyone have experience with something like this? I tried Googeling span tables with no luck.

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

#2

I think you will need steel

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>When you do the calculations of a 1200 lb load in the middle of a 40' span plus safety margin you probably rule out wood. Especially without piers. Go to a steel supplier and they will do the calculations for you and make the proper recommendations. Then box in the steel with wood and brag to everyone about your wooden beams. We figured one for a small addition and the steel was much less than we had anticipated.

Ray

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

#3

Re: Agree-Steel or pylons

Brian in Brighton

>I can't see how you are going to span something like that otherwise. Unless you can find 4 telephone poles and you don't mind the toxic mess from the coating coming off.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

#4

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Pick up a retired flatdeck (semi) trailer and use it. They can be had cheap and I'm sure they'd have no trouble at all taking the load you mention.

Rob

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

#5

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

John Veerkamp

>I have a neighbor who built a bridge of similar demensions for the exact use you anticipate. Same problems except at times the creek came up 12 feet. One humongus amount of water. This same creek is our eastern property line. Flash foods are something to behold. but I digress. He made a suspension bridge. He used four 5/8 cables anchored to trees at either end. The upper cables were attached to the lower cables with smaller cable every few feet. The bed is 2x6 treated lumber laid on top of the lower cables attached with I bolts strung on the cable. There is a 2x4 curb on each edge cut into four ft lenghts and attached with screws. The upper cables are about 30 " above the lower.

He figures the four cables have about a 6000 lb capacity. If you don't have handy trees at each end, concrete deadmen could be used instead.

Good luck and have fun,

John

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

#6

Wheres Ray Carson when you need him ?

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>....if I recall correctly he works for a structural engineer/detailer.

I agree that steels prolly the way to go here.....unless you have access to some big ole logs that is.

Maybe Ray can comment further on this here subject ?

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

#7

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>The suspension bridge sounds interesting! Can you shoot a pic of it?

I wanted to make a draw bridge with towers at each end but SWMBO vetoed it.

We had an 8"/hour rain a couple of years ago. The creek came up maybe 10' and spread about 200 yards. Luckily for us there is a road bridge on the up stream side of our property that acts as a dam. The water was about 6' higher on the other side of it. It was supposed to be a 500 year flood but we had another this spring. The town doesn't have a plan for dealing with runoff and there is a lot of new construction adding to the problem.

Of course the building code here doesn't cover bridges either :>)

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

#8

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

teflon_jones

>Yup, the suspension bridge is definitely the way to go. Get yourself some 5/8" steel cable and attach it to either some trees or pour some large concrete anchors weighing 2000 lbs each, buried 3 ft deep. You can make the concrete anchors more efficient by making them larger and flatter and burying them deeper, but in the end, a square is the easiest to make and it'll hold fine as long as you bury it 3+ ft deep. The larger and flatter you make the anchor the more you have to worry about reinforcing it. Put some eye bolts into the back corners of the concrete to anchor the ends of the cable to. Put steel pipes into the front corners of each block and run the cable over the top of them by notching the tubes.

You can then use 2x4 to make pretty much the entire bridge. Just suspend short lengths of 3/8" cable from the 5/8" cable every 2 ft and drill holes through some 2x4 the long way. You could also use 2x6 and suspend them every 3 ft. Once you're done with that, you can simply lay boards on top and screw them down. Just alternate where they end for strength and stability.

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

#9

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

DB

>There is a lake near here with a couple of bridges that goes all of the way across. There is no suspension system (except at the very ends) and no massive beams. The bridges are floating on the water.

You could try that on your stream. Just make something like the floating docks that people use on there waterfront property. Just tie and anchor them securely.

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

#10

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>I have seen a couple of bridges around here that were made from old railroad flat cars with the trucks removed and set on a concrete footing / retaining wall, I even seem to recall one that was set on rock filled wooden cribbing

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

#11

JL

Re: Maybe a engineered truss system might do it... *LINK*

JL

>I've seen steel truss systems holding up the roofs in the warehouses and factories of my old employer. If they can hold up a multi-ton air handler, they should be able to hold up you, your tractor and your trailer. As I recall, the span between supports was more than 40'.

In regards to engineered wood trusses, the one in my house spans something like 28'. It is 24" on center and holds up the floor reasonably well. If you put it 16" on center (or closer), it would probably support more weight.

Below is a link that I found that lists some engineered truss data.


Truss table

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

#12

Re: Need beam for bridge....

Ray Carson, Lawrenceville NJ

>Phil,

In my proffesional opinion, steel would be your best bet.

The old truck trailer flatbed idea is a good one. A laminated, arched or cambered wood design would have to utilized.

Next thing that would have to be considered is weight of a structure. That size bearing on what sounds like soft to semi-hard ground. Clay is great when it's hard, but......

There are 2 bridges of similar condition down at our local county park, and the bridge is made of cambered steel 'C' channels. Another in the same park is made of laminated 2x8's and the depth of the member is 24" deep. I know because our firm was involved in both designs. It was an experiment in cost and asthetics. Most people like the wood bridge, but it was expensive. Both require maintenance, however, the steel bridge life span (no pun intended) was projected to be greater with proper painting, etc.

My 2 cents worth,

Ray

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

#13

Re: Need beam suggestions for bridge

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>Why not attach the decking directly to the top of the cables?

I'm thinking of setting 8" concrete posts 5' deep and putting a 1' wide x 2' deep beam across the top front. 3 sets of cable with 2x10 stapled on top. The clay here is subject to extreme drying and cracking.