Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Magnetic Starters?

Posts

Magnetic Starters?

#1

Magnetic Starters?

Tom Norton

>I could use a simple explanation of why there are used and how to size and wire them.

Re: Magnetic Starters?

#2

Re: Magnetic Starters?

Bill Howatt

>There are two devices that get called magnetic starters. The first is a real motor starter and it can be very sophisticated by controlling parameters to soft-start the motor, switching starting windings on/off, overload protection, etc.

The other device that is usually what is being discussed is the magnetic switch. The magnetic switch is really nothing more than a big relay. The relay is pulled in by a low-power circuit that may run off the same voltage as the motor or may be a lower voltage, often 24V.

This permits smaller switch contacts to be used since they don't have to carry the motor current, just the relay coil's, particularly since motors can have high-inrush currents that will cause contact burning. A large relay takes care of this.

Another advantage is that the on/off switches can be momentary pushbuttons. A separate contact on the relay closes when the relay pulls in thus keeping the circuit energized even when the momentary normally-open push-buttonis released. Should the power fail then the relay opens this contact as well as the others and when the power comes on the relay will not close until the on button is pushed again. The off button is just a normally-closed pushbutton in series with the on button/relay contact combination; pushing it opens the the relay control coil circuit. The fact it won't start after a power failure is why they are considered safer than regular toggle switches.

The magnetic switches often have thermal overload protection in them to match the motor size. The switches are spec'd to motor size so the relay is adequate enough to carry the motor current and also for sizing the thermal protection. Some switches permit inserting different size thermal devices.

The best way to see how to wire them is to follow the manufacturer's diagram although if you know a bit about it you can usually figure a switch out without one.

Bill

Re: Magnetic Starters?

#3

Re: Magnetic Starters?

Larry Clinton

>I have designed 100's of circuits using magnetic motor starters as part of my job as a Manufacturing Engineer.

The purpose of a magnetic motor starter is 1) to start a motor with a large inrush current - the contacts are sized to allow multiple starts per hour. 2) the starter consist of a relay with heavy contacts rated to start the motor and also normally contain a set of "pilot relay contact" that close at the same time as the main relay contacts. These are used to "latch" the circuit and keep the relay on until either the "stop switch" (a switch with normally closed contacts) is pressed OR power is interrupted. 4) Motor starter are often (not required but really provide the best motor protection) equipped with a motor overload device which contain a type of fuse (commonly called heaters) in each line that open in the event the motor draws excessive current for a predetermined period of time. These are selected for the exact current the motor is rated for and provide excellent motor overload protection.

Sizing: Motor controls are sized from 00 to 6 - the attached link has a chart that can be used to determine what (minimum) size is needed for a given horsepower motor. The link also has a "heater" chart available. (I just Googled the site - no connection or recommendation to use them as a vendor) http://www.southlandelectrical.com/motorStarterSizingChart.asp?&url=IND

Advantages of using a magnetic motor starter vs a "off / on" switch: 1) the motor starter can be wired with momentary "start" and "stop" switches and will open if power is interrupted - This is a great safety feature - imagine you have a board ripped half way through and the lights go out, if you start to remove the board and the light go back on and the saw starts running again you could be in trouble. 2) Motor starters have large contacts and will normally wear longer than the equipment in normal applications. 3) A motor starter with proper heaters installed will protect the motor - you should never suffer a burned out motor or damaged windings if the motor is overloaded. If you need more information as to how these are wired into a circuit drop me an email - I will be glad to help in any way I can. Please also note - 100's of these devices are available used at Ebay and other surplus houses. Industries often discard machinery in excellent condition that is no longer needed and seldom remove any parts for reuse.

Re: Magnetic Starters?

#4

Petty additions.

Forrest Addy

>Most available motors starters are three phase. They consist of a contactor (essentially a large relay with contacts designed for starting surge current (as opposed to 10 amps or less control current) and an over current protection divice. A starter may also include auxilliary contacts, a reversing contactor with electrical mechanical interlocks, and many other configurations.

Controlling single phase motors from three phase starters is as simple as wiring in the line(s) conductors to the line terminals and the motor leads to the load terminals. Spare contacts can be simply left empty.

Only line voltage conductors above ground potential are switched. Neutral conductors are at ground potential or very near it and are never connected to contacts.

A ground is not a neutral. A neutral is a current carrying conductor. If your equipment is 230 volts and you need 115 vomnts to run a convenience outlet or to connect the starter's control station you have to wire in a neutral conductor. The ground is present only as a current path to ground in case of electrical fault.

Motor starters are actuated by solonoids. The solonoid voltage has to be matched to the control voltage which may be different from the line voltage (24 Volts is popular as is 115). Usually a small "control transformer" is provided to supply power for the motor control circuit.

Every starter design has passed tests mandated by NEMA UL CE RU and other organizations as their jusditions bear. The starter enclosure will have listings of the avialable over current trip devices (heaters) reccommented for the rated full load Amps of the connected motor. These may be obtained from electrical supply houses. They are time rated for motor starting service and should not be de-rated for motor starting or any other consideration.

Motor control circuits are strictly covered by the National Electrical Code and the relevant local code. Most motors are controlled by a simple start/stop motor control station sometimes installed in the motor starter's enclosure but they may be installed in the appropiate enclosure convenient to the operators working station. They consist of a normally open "start" button (normally flush or recessed slighty and black in color) and a normally closed "stop" button (red in color) that protudes (sometimes as an enlarged "mushroom" shape) to facilitate actuation in case of an emergency. The circuit itself is called the "three wire" control circuit and is thoroughly covered in trade school texts, the useful information sections of electrcal control devices catalogs, and many websites. Control stations cannot be safely replaced by a toggle switch; A toggle switch will not prevent an unintended re-start if power fails while the motor is running.

The lore of motors and motor starters has been worked out over a full century and their implementation has come down to us in as simple a form as good engineering and well designed electrical devises can make it.

I refer you or aanyone with a motor selection and control problem to the W W Granger catalog for a more complete discussion of starter selection and other electrical information. There a puruser will find several excellent how-to-select tutorals regarding motors motor starters, compressors, pumps, etc that no home shop owner sould be without.

Use of the term "magnetic switch" among the electrical cogniscenti will mark you as a rube. An intgrated devise used to control and protect motors is a "starter" which ocnsists of a "contactor" and an "oveload relay" (usually shortened to "overload"). You now see "magnetic switch" on Grizzly catalog pandering to general ignorance but what they sell as a magnetic switch is a motor starter.

Motor starters come in several forms including those with mechanical controls actuated by pushbuttos. Those equipped with an electro-magnetic hold will give you the unintended re-start protection. Those that do not should not be used for shop machinery.

Re: Magnetic Starters?

#5

Re: Petty additions.

Bart Castleberry

>I think in most cases, to avoid running a neutral for 115v, you can use a transformer, that will work for control, and if larger enough a light. Transformers and starters are all over e-bay. As Forrest said, most used starters are 3ph. Becarefull, some 3ph ones require you to loop thorugh all contactors, others do not to get proper overload protection.

I'd read that stuff on Grainger, also google OWWM Wikki, and go to the section on starters.

I'd also start looking on fleabay and note a particular brand that pops up all the time like an Allen Bradley 509, and download the manuals and catalogs for it from AB. Learn one maybe two brands and go from there, you will need to know coil voltage, heater size and starter size AND thier codes and or colors from the manufacturer. Sellers don't always know what they are selling... Coils and heaters can be found, but are more avaliable for some starters more than other. Look for a very common one. The AB 509's almost always have 115v coils and the 220v coils are rare other than for high$$ used, the workaround is a transformer, same goes for 24v coils.

The startes on the bay usually won't come cheap (like under $20) if they have an enclosure (box), you have to have one. But you can put it in other things, go to the local elec supply and get a box, maybe $20.

You will also need to learn pushbuttons and thier codes, again pick a brand that's common like the AB 800 series. There are a lot of little things to lean, none too complicated, but there's a LOT of options.

If you want a starter in the enclosure, single phase, with buttons those are on e-bay too, just be prepared to pay for it. The apperance of ease will drive the price up.