Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative

Posts

Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative

#1

Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative

Roger

>Since California is going to single handedly save the environment, they have banned nitrocellulose lacquer, among many other products that actually work. I have used lacquer exclusively as my topcoat on furniture projects for many years. Can someone recommend an alternative that is as easy to apply with an HVLP gun and give a similar finish and is as forgiving to use?

Roger

Re: Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative

#2

Re: Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative *LINK*

David Hammond, in Powder Springs GA

>Target Coatings Products have been fantastic for me - check out the thread on the turning board for "Long time in the Making", or my website, and see what I just finished with Jeff Weiss' products - no association other than being a very satisfied customer! Jeff and his team are working very hard to produce waterborne products that meet or exceed the traditional nitro, oil-based, etc. type of finishes.

David Hammond


My Dad & Me, Inc.

Re: Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative

#3

conversion varnish

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have been using it for several years and find it a good alternative. Going to Nevada is also a good alternative and lacquer keeps forever. I just returned from Canada with some alkyd varnish because CA arranged to have it banned from everywhere.

Re: Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative

#4

Re: Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative

Bill Kay

>I decided that being required to drive to Nevada to buy a can of paint was the last straw. California is oppressive.

I'm currently a California resident on a "road trip" to find a new home. Looked at Nevada, New Mexico, Arizona and Texas so far. We are continuing east tomorrow. Looks like we'll have this dialed in by early winter.

Regards,

Re: Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative

#5

Re: Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative

Barry Irby

>Bill, get the prorities in the right order. You should find a shop with a house on the property.

Re: Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative

#6

Try TN

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It is a small government state. No income tax helps to keep it that way. With luck the people that demand a government solution to all problems will not find us.

Re: Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative

#7

I'll second that

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>I don't live in Tennessee but if I could afford to pull up stakes and leave I would be a Tennessee resident in short order.

My preference would be in the northeastern part near Hampton or maybe Erwin. Small town living with a just big enough city (Johnson City) close by.

Re: Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative

#8

Re: Try TN

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>Don't look back or she may get you in 2008

Re: Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative

#9

Re: Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative

Joe Dusel (Vista,CA)

>I have only used the nasty NC stuff once or twice. How can you stand to use it? The fumes are hazardous to not only the environment, but it's also not great to breathe. The stuff then outgasses for quite a while.

I have been using WB finishes including the Target and the ApolloCoat products successfully in my business for the past 6 years. I'm now looking into the M.L.Campbell Aqualente finish which I tested a few weeks back with great results. The WB finishes I use spray well, lay out nice, don't stink (even while drying), don't muck up the environment and clean up easily. I can spray the water based stuff in my small shop without knocking out other people working on the other side of the room and I don't have to worry about a spark blowing up my shop. By the way, not all waterbased finishes are the same.

I'm glad I live in a place like California which generally leads the nation when it comes to protecting it's population.

Joe

Re: Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative

#10

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Please read the label on the can......

Jesper, Denmark

>Waterborne finshes sounds like utopia - but they are not. To make the hydrocarbon based resins work with water, a co-solvent is used. Typically this is a glycol. Same family of compounds as the anitfreeze in your car - toxic - or the PGMEA which caused birth defects in women in the semiconductor industry.

The co-solvents are also bad for the environment - they are VOC's just like the solvents that smell bad and are flammable.

If you get an MSDS sheet for the waterborne paint, you will find that there are VOC's in the can, maybe a little less than traditional coatings, but there nevertheless. As an additional risk factor, the actual danger of these different solvents will not be really determined till they have been used for man� years and the various ill effects show up in the population.

I am afraid that this is a situation, where you are exchanging a well know hazard with an unknown one which could end up being much worse.

Re: Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative

#11

Re: Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative *LINK*

David C. Lykins - guitardude - Dallas GA

>I've used some lacquer from Target Coatings, I got good results with it considering I didn't know what I was doing at the time. I've learned quite a bit since then so can wait to use the remainder of my lacquer on a project. Here's whaat their lacquer has in it and I've stuck in a link to their site.

Solids, % by weight: 30%

Weight Per gallon: 8.66 lbs

pH: 8.0-8.5

Regulatory VOC Content: 177.0 Grams/Litre

Actual VOC Content: 62.0 Grams/Litre

HAPS Content: 0.0

Viscosity: 30-40 sec., Zahns #2

Sheen Degree of Gloss: 1000 Clear Gloss = 85-90�

1200 Clear Semi-Gloss = 65-70�

1500 Clear Satin =40-45�

1700 Clear Flat = 10-15�


Target Coatings

Re: Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative

#12

Re: Target

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Had used their original PSL because of its advertised 100% burn-in to eliminate withness lines. Had good initial results, but got some cold checking over time because of the underlying shellac layer. Then it was reformulated. I got another qt. and tried it after about 6 months on the shelf. Got big-time fish eyes even though I was meticulous in making sure the piece was clean and silicone free. When I called, I was told the product might be old. Note here to check and rotate your finish stock.

I've since learned that the product may not have quite the 100% burn-in that I was told, but I have used it with exceptional clarity and no witness lines on good flat surfaces. Have since migrated to Fuhr 355 and Enduro finishes, and have been getting great results with off-the-gun surfaces that rival what I first got with rubbing out hand-applied finishes. Just completed an octagonal side table in cherry with Fuhr 355 that rubbed out to a wet-look top such that SWMBO is reluctant to put anything on it for fear of ruining the finish!

mm

Re: Nitrocellulose lacquer alternative

#13

Legal solvent based lacquer

Michael Dresdner

>California has not banned NC lacquer -- just the high VOC solvents currently used in it. However, in response to that, several companies have formulated lacquers with exempt solvents. While most are only sold to the industry at present, they will trickle down and you may be able to find them, depending on your suppliers or size.

In case any readers were wondering what I mean by exempt solvents, here's a short explanation of what is banned, why, and why the exempt solvents are not part of the problem.

VOC's are chemicals that create ozone in the presence of sunlight. Most, but not all, hydrocarbons do that. The ones that do not are being added to the exempt list, little by little. They are not part of the problem so should not be banned.

Both acetone and Oxol 100, two solvents that work as lacquer thinners, have been approved for the exempt list, allowing formulators to make legal solvent based lacquer using only those two solvents. Many of us feel alcohol should also be added, though so far it has not been.