Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Smoke detector for my shop?

Posts

Smoke detector for my shop?

#1

JL

Smoke detector for my shop?

JL

>Pros and cons on a dual sensor (photoelectric and ionization) smoke detector for my shop? I have a smoke detector mounted in the room next to my shop, but I would like to have one in the shop itself. Should I get a dual sensor or just a single sensor? If I get a single sensor, which sensor should I get?

Naturally because it is my shop, I do generate some dust! I don't want to vacuum out the detector that often.

Re: Smoke detector for my shop?

#2

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Smoke detector for my shop?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I'm pretty sure that the photoelectric type would nuisance alarm any time you generated airborne dust.

Jason

Re: Smoke detector for my shop?

#3

Re: Smoke detector for my shop?

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I've has an ionization type in my shop for years. The only time it goes off is if I braze something or if I happen to get some wood that burns against the blade.

I saw some radio linked ones the other day at Home Depot that would also alarm in the house if the one in the shop goes off.

Lee

Re: Smoke detector for my shop?

#4

Re: Smoke detector for my shop?

Paul Mayer

>I put a heat detector in my shop, of the same brand as the smoke/CO detectors in the house. That way, it doesn't trip from dust, and when it does trip, the detectors in the house sound as well.

Re: Smoke detector for my shop?

#5

Re: Smoke detector for my shop?

David G. Sparks

>I don't remember dust setting my smoke detector off, but the kerosene heater I used in my old shop would. I like the idea suggested in one of the other posts about using a heat detector.

Re: Smoke detector for my shop?

#6

Re: Smoke detector for my shop?

Yonak

>Paul, some while back I was looking for various types of alarms and tried to find heat detectors by searching the web but could only find commercial types that were very expensive. Where did you find yours ?

Re: Smoke detector for my shop?

#7

Re: Smoke detector for my shop?

Yonak

>There are varying opinions on sympathetic alarms where one sets all alarms off. You have to look around for the fire and I've been told that opening the wrong door at the wrong time can be disastrous. The recommendation I got was to not use sympathetic alarms but get ones that are loud enough that it will wake you up even from the most distant alarm location.

Re: Smoke detector for my shop?

#8

Re: Smoke detector for my shop?

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>My shop is the other end of the house from the bedroom and there are typically two doors and more than 50 feet between me and it when I'm sleeping. It would need to be a pretty loud alarm to hear it from that distance.

Also, instead of just opening doors when checking for a fire, you should always place the back of your hand on the door and feel for heat before opening any door. The reason for using the back of the hand is that it is more sensitive and if you should burn it you can still use the palm pain free to open another door to get out.

Lee

Re: Smoke detector for my shop?

#9

Re: Smoke detector for my shop?

DizD

>As an added benefit the smoke detector will let you know when your tablesaw blade needs sharpening :)