Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Over engineered marking gauge ?

Posts

Over engineered marking gauge ?

#1

Over engineered marking gauge ?

SteveM

>In order to mark a perpendicular end on dowels I've always eye-balled them or tried to hold a combination square " just right ". Time I had something a bit more sophisticated. I think this would do what I'm asking of it. Just an amature engineer though. Is it over-engineered ? Critiques ?


img

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

#2

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

john lucas

>The main problem I see is the wear on the pencil point. If you use the screw to hold the pencil in place you might not get a line all the way around the dowel before the pencil point wears down and doesn't touch the line. (don't ask how I know this) I belong to over engineering anonymous

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

#3

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

Eric Kuehne

>Steve,

I can tell you're not an engineer because this is way too simple.

With that in mind I do have a couple of suggestions:

1. Make the hole thing out of Teflon or at least polyethylene to minimize friction.

2. The ways for the pencil holder should be dovetailed so that you can add a locking screw that would engage the ways and could be oriented vertically. The bottom of the dovetail should, of course, be hardened steel to avoid the screw marring the bottom of the dovetail.

3. Replace the pencil with a laser. That way you will avoid the lead wearing issue.

Now THAT'S overengineering! Take is from a professional.

Seriously, the design looks pretty good. Actually, it occurs to me that you are pretty close to having dedicated cut off fixture. You could make the grove to hold the dowel deeper and add a slot for the saw. Just use a clamped block to determine the length for repeat cuts and you're good to go.

Or you could just build it the way you conceived it.

Good luck,

Eric in rainy Los Gatos

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

#4

TOUCHE ! Good one !

SteveM

>Maybe just a scriber point ?

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

#5

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

Don in Central Illinois

>What's wrong with a stop on the chop saw, TS, BS, etc? That way they're all the same length, or did I miss something?

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

#6

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

Charles Sharp

>For cutting dowels on the band saw I have a wood v-block with a slot cut into for the blade. I just make a mark on the v-block for the end of the dowel and push it into the blade.

If you just have to mark them, whats wrong with using a compass? Keep the pencil a little short and rest the end of the dowel on the pointy end.

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

#7

Chop saw ? 

SteveM

>


img

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

#8

Old pipefitter's trick

Charles Wiggins

>If you're doing production work, I think your jig has a lot of promise, and there's been some great suggestions for improvements. However, if this is only an occasional problem for you, you may want to consider a low-tech solution.

If your cylinder (dowel) is straight and true, you can take a flexible straight edge (the edge of an index card, for example) and wrap it around the cylinder so it laps back over itself, aligning the straight edge perfectly to itself, and you will have a perfectly perpendicular line, that goes all the way around, to scribe against. I used to use a piece of 1/16" spring steel to mark large diameter pipe.


img

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

#9

Re: Chop saw ?

Charles Wiggins

>Maybe instead of a marking jig you should construct a miter box?


img

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

#10

Revision . . .

SteveM

>Maybe this change with the lead adapter from one of my old drafting compasses instead of an entire pencil ?


img

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

#11

I'm curious.....

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>Why do you need to have a line marked all the way around the dowel? I'm probably missing something here (not an uncommon state of affairs for me). When I need to cut a dowel I put a pencil mark on it and chop it off. I IS a nice looking tool however.

glc

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

#12

Dare I suggest?

Forrest Addy

>Why not all a couple of screws to the wood base and attach it to your table saw sled or shop saw stage. The you can simply cut. You wont have to mark, then transfer to the saw and etc..

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

#13

Not always cutting though . . .

SteveM

>Actualy, most of the time I'm marking out the " splice bands " and " joints " on the surface of missile bodies that will remain one piece. I mark the joints / seams then groove them with dovetail saw and finnish with triangle needle file and sandpaper. Marking them out prior gives the chance to " evaluate " the look and location before cutting or grooving. Thanks much though ! Sounds like a good idea for larger work. I'll keep it " on file " !

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

#14

No, no, I don't explain things well ! . . .

SteveM

>Still the GI in me. As I said above, its not always cut. A lot is giving the illusion of seperate stages on a rocket or missile. A double groove running around the out side. But when I try to eyeball it they tend to stray and I have to stray back to meet the start of the groove on the other side. Just looks sloppy. Tried the bandsaw with meiter gauge but can still wander and by then its already cut and no going back.

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

#15

Ahhh, Now I get it

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>I got a thought here, did you ever try a tubing or pipe cutter, it cuts a nice tight groove with controllable depth, although it might raise the edges too much.

glc

Re: Over engineered marking gauge ?

#16

Yes, raised edges and . . .

SteveM

>tended to crush rather than cut the fibers to make the groove. I know cut then file then sand sounds like a lot for a wee groove but it looks cleaner. Of course SWMBO does'nt understand all this detail but . . . its what folks pay for.