Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Electrical Question

Posts

Electrical Question

#1

Electrical Question

Rod Rentz

>When recently adding a 20 amp circuit to my 200 amp service panel, I came across two of the following:

A 30 amp, 220 volt circuit breaker with each side servicing a separate 110 volt circuit. The black wires (hot) went into the breaker with the whites went into the neutral bar. To top it off the wiring was 12 gauge which is not the recommended size (I think it should be 10 gauge). How will the breaker be tripped? It sounds unsafe to me. I have two 20 amp, 110 volt breakers which will fit in the same slot and I plan to wire the circuits individually.

Has anyone ever seen this? I�m not overreacting am I?

Re: Electrical Question

#2

Re: Electrical Question

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Have you verified that whatever is being powered by this circuit is in fact running on 110?

From your description it sounds like someone tried to avoid buying two breakers. I would suggest that you replace the double breaker with two single 20 Amp breakers.

Lee

Re: Electrical Question

#3

Re: Electrical Question

Sawdust B Gone!

>Having to use a double breaker for 2 individual circuits is not so much the problem. It's the 12G wiring that is matched with 30A CB! The CD is supposed to protect the wiring downstream, not much of a protection if the CD is rated higher for current than the wire!

On the other hand, if the double pole CB was rated for 20A, it won't really matter much unless you are tripping circuits often because when either one of the two pole trips, the other will also trip together. Safety feature for 240V circuits.

Butr since you are goning to have th replace the CB anyway, I'd replace it with 2 individual 20A breakers (cost will be few cents difference between one double 20a and two singlw 20A). And then add on your 20A which you wanted to add in the first place.

Re: Electrical Question

#4

WAIT!

Rick Christopherson

>First off, yes, if this is 12 gauge wire, then you do need to change the breaker. However, you cannot just automatically make this two single-pole breakers without first determining if there is a 2-pole load, or a common neutral on the circuit.

You did say plural "whites", so it sounds like this is not a "multiwire branch circuit" per se. If it was a single neutral wire serviced with two hot wires, then you would have to keep the 2-pole breaker, but make it 20-amps.

What you do not know yet, without further investigation, is that a previous owner might have taken two separate 120 volt circuits and joined them for a 240 volt load somewhere. If this is the case, then you also need to keep the 2-pole breaker, unless you can remove the 240-volt device.

If in doubt, the safe approach is to replace the 30-amp, 2-pole breaker with a 20-amp, 2-pole breaker. There is nothing wrong with having a 2-pole breaker, even if the two circuits are unrelated. It isn't necessarily good, but if you can't figure out why there was a 2-pole breaker, it would be the conservative approach.

If you know for certain that the two circuits are separate, then yes, you can remove the breaker and replace it with the two single breakers that you have on hand.

Re: Electrical Question

#5

Re: Electrical Question

Barry Irby

>There is a condition where you can wire two 120 volt circuits from a double circuit breaker normally used for 220 Volts. Lets say you wanted two 20 amp circuits in your shop or kitchen of where ever. You can save a few pennies by using a double breaker and running a 12/4 with ground to the first outlet box. You use the black, white and green in the normal fashion, In the nest bow you use the Red White and Green. You can split the wiring at the first box and branch into to separate runs. The reason you use a double breaker instead of two single ones is that the initial run contains 240 until it splits off into two circuits. You would want both circuits to trip simultaneously to be sure there are no live wires in any of the boxes. As a Home Inspector I occasionally see this in kitchens where two 20 amp circuits are required. Its not a popular technique, I suspect because it is somewhat confusing to homeowners and others not familiar with it and its inconvenient to have both circuits go out when on trips.

Re: Electrical Question

#6

Partially correct.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> There is a condition where you can wire two 120 volt circuits from a double circuit breaker normally used for 220 Volts.

Yes. This is a “multi-wire branch circuit.”

> Lets say you wanted two 20 amp circuits in your shop or kitchen of where ever.

Probably a more common application (and the one which was used in two separate instances in my house—wired in 1973) is two bedrooms or a bedroom and a bath (back when there wasn't a 20A requirement for the bath). I don't like them, though, because, as you said, they can be confusing to homeowners.

> You can save a few pennies by using a double breaker and running a 12/4 with ground to the first outlet box.

I hope that was a typo. To my knowledge there is no such thing as 12/4. In any event, 12/3 is all that's needed. Although back when I worked in a hardware store it was possible to buy non-metallic cable without a ground, I'd be surprised if you could find it anywhere today, thus the with ground is implied when talking about NMC, and it isn't included in the wire count (jacketed cord is a different story, but we're talking about house wiring, and cord isn't).

> You use the black, white and green in the normal fashion, In the nest bow you use the Red White and Green.

I hope that's a typo, too—I'm guessing next box. I'm not trying to ping on your spelling or typing, but as you well know, these electrical threads are tricky and there are a lot of ignorant (lacking knowledge—not stupid) folks reading these posts for information.

It looks like you're describing a system in which the xx/3 is run through several sequential boxes, with every other box being fed by a different circuit (of the two). I definitely don't care for that technique. Even though code doesn't preclude it (and doesn't require the two pole breaker unless both circuits are connected to a common yoke—such as the two halves of a duplex receptacle with the jumper broken off), I have never liked the idea of there being two circuits worth of electricity in one box (excepting the load center or an obvious 240V circuit).

(Barry, ignore the following—it's for people who might not be aware of the concept behind the multi-wire branch circuit)

What makes the multi-wire branch circuit work is the fact that the two hots (taken from opposite poles of the load center, and the principal reason why a two pole breaker is a good idea) share the neutral. Since the hots are 180° out of phase, the currents in each are additive, but opposite in sign (because of the phase relationship). That essentially means that whatever current appears on one wire is subtracted from the current on the other to determine (the absolute value of) the total current in the neutral. Consequently, the maximum current that can appear on the neutral is whatever the highest value is in any one leg.

Rod

Re: Electrical Question

#7

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

One you missed, Rod.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>NMC (w/ground) usually doesn't have a green wire, but a bare copper one.

Aren't the electrical questions here always so much fun?

Jason

Re: Electrical Question

#8

Thanks—I think._______

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>

Re: Electrical Question

#9

Re: Partially correct.

Barry Irby

>My apologies for my typing. It's gotten terrible. I use a spell checker and usually proofread, but tonight I was in a hurry.

You are correct. I was trying to cut corners or keystrokes. I meant 12/3 with ground. I was thinking of NM Cable with a red, black, white, and green or ground. (I have not bought any lately, do they still make NM with a bare ground?}

And I think you are correct about the common yoke thing also. This comes in when people separate the two outlets on a duplex receptacle and wire one to the black and the other to the red, thus having two circuits not only in the same box but on the same "yoke".

Re: Electrical Question

#10

Thanks

Rod Rentz

>I really appreciate all of the help.

I have traced the circuits totally and they are both totally independent of each other all the way, just two separate lines. Also, in the panel there are two hots and two neutrals so I think I will be doing the right thing to go with the two 20 amp breakers.

My biggest concern is that a licensed electrician would use a 30 amp breaker for 12 gauge wire (if a novice like me smelled a rat, he should have known better).

Although it's not really an acceptable technique, it appears that the two lines off of the 220 volt breaker would work OK if the proper gauge wire is used (but I'm not going to do it).

Thanks again, it was an interesting discussion.

Re: Electrical Question

#11

Another reason not to like the method....

John in NM

>The local inspector tells me that the two (opposed) hots sharing a common can confuse GFCI circuitry. No personal experience with this as I never ran one this way. Not being a pro, I find it cheaper and more efficient to cut down on the number of different things I have to buy - like one roll of 12/3 when I'm already using lots of 12/2.

Re: Electrical Question

#12

Re: Another reason not to like the method....

Kent in Emmaus, PA

>"The local inspector tells me that the two (opposed) hots sharing a common can confuse GFCI circuitry."

More specifically, you can put a GFCI on a shared-neutral circuit, BUT you can't run additional receptacles from the GFCI's load terminals, UNLESS you run a separate neutral conductor from the GFCI.

Personally, I (experienced amateur) don't do multiwire branch circuits. The principle is elegant from an engineering perspective, but there are just too many things that can go wrong later on down the road:

- Failed neutral results in an overvoltage condition.

- Someone moves the breakers and puts both hots on the same leg, resulting in an overloaded neutral.

- Incorrectly installed GFCIs trip constantly.

Did I miss any?