Rewire Delta Contractor Saw for 220?
Jim O'Neal
>OK, I'll embarass myself - is it feasable to rewire the 1.5 HP motor in my Delta Contractor saw for 220v? A buddy told me that I would get more "power" and better performance with 220 vs 110.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Rewire Delta Contractor Saw for 220?
Jim O'Neal
>OK, I'll embarass myself - is it feasable to rewire the 1.5 HP motor in my Delta Contractor saw for 220v? A buddy told me that I would get more "power" and better performance with 220 vs 110.
Check the discussion a few threads down
Bob in Philly
>http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/messages.pl?noframes;read=336633
Yes—caveat…
Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach
>> …is it feasable to rewire…
Yes, but there won't be any more power. If your 120V circuit is heavily loaded with other current draws, and/or it's quite a way away from the load center, you may see some improved performance. If you do, however, the improvement is related directly to the ability of the circuit to deliver the necessary amps (i.e. dedicated circuit, adequately sized), not that it is 240V. In fact, so far as the motor is concerned, the windings don't know one way or the other what voltage is being fed to the motor (that doesn't mean you don't have to change the jumpers).
Rod
Re: Rewire Delta Contractor Saw for 220? *LINK*
Rick Christopherson
>Sorry, but your buddy is wrong. Yes, it is a very common misconception, but it is nevertheless incorrect. The people that tell you that their tools are suddenly performing miraculously well, forget to tell you what their original circuit was like--such as extension cords, power strips, additional loads on the same circuit, yada-yada-yada.
Had these same people corrected their existing wiring with the same fervor that they rewired all of their other tools, they would have come up with the same results. In most cases, they replaced a substandard, 15-amp circuit with a brand new 20-amp circuit, but mistakenly attributed the correction to the voltage change.
Yes, a motor will snap to speed a little quicker, but this is because the Locked-rotor amperage of a starting motor exceeds the capacity of either circuit. The problem with people drawing a conclusion from this is that you DO NOT operate a motor in the Locked-Rotor condition--unless of course you like letting the blue smoke out of the wires.
No. There was not a mythical Delta motor that produced 2 hp when rewired to 240 volts. Even though I had been arguing this topic for years, I finally had the opportunity to confirm this with a Delta project manager a couple of years ago at the AWFS show.
============================
By the way, for all of you that are linking to "Electricity in the Woodshop" or any of my other articles, I finally broke down and purchased a proper web domain. The new domain is up and running, and eventually the old domain will disappear. If you are bookmarking or linking to the old website, you will want to change the domain over to www.waterfront-woods.com
Oh, also note the email changes too.
http://www.waterfront-woods.com/
Is there no gain from the opposing wave peaks.
Keith Newton
>I am not doubting your knowledge, but it seems like there could be something gained from 60 Hz. Does it not become 120 Hz at 240 V?
I have delta 3 ph. in my shop, and most of the stationary equipment is wired for it. Sometimes I pick up used motors which are wired for 460 V. What is the point of going to higher volts, if 130 is just as good?
Re: Is there no gain from the opposing wave peaks.
Bill Howatt
>The frequency is still 60Hz, if it were 120Hz, induction motors would run twice the rated speed.
The advantage of the higher voltage motors is to reduce the load current. If you have a several HP motor that draws 20A at 460V it will require wire, breakers and related equipment to supply 80A at 115V. Since power loss due to resistive heating is I*I*R, the losses are 16X those at the higher voltage. Large wire is also much more difficult to work with.
You might say that now you have to work with high-voltage. The voltage is higher and you have to ensure that the components are rated for the voltage but even 460V is a long way from true high-voltage where you have to be concerned about arc-over and corona discharge. A single layer of black electrical tape will easily insulate over a 1000V.
In the home shop table-saw case, it was pointed out that there is no difference within the motor and no difference if the wire feeding the motor is adequately sized. Running on 240V means that a smaller wire will be adequate than for the 120V case (within the code requirements of course). I run my saw on 240V because I like making lower current connections and I would have to use heavier wire.
Bill
Question
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>You said:
"No. There was not a mythical Delta motor that produced 2 hp when rewired to 240 volts. Even though I had been arguing this topic for years, I finally had the opportunity to confirm this with a Delta project manager a couple of years ago at the AWFS show."
I was under the impression that this particular motor had an extra winding that got used only when wired for 240V, but was not used under 120V mode, in order to keep the amp draw under 15 amps. I'd like to know what you were told specifically about this, not as a challenge, but in the quest for knowledge...
I'm not an electrical motor specialist, yet the "rationale" given at the time kind of made sense to my almost uneducated (about that topic) mind. Could you give us the details about this?
Thnx,
DC
Re: NO - Rick is absolutely correct
Larry Clinton
>The Hertz (cycles per second) does not change with 230 Volt. What is actually happening is that each "hot" line coming into your entrance box has the voltage rising to 115 volt above neutral (ground potential) then falling to 115 volt below neutral. The two "hot" lines are 180 degree out of phase so that when line "A" is 115 volt above neutral, line "B" is 115 volt below neutral - thus there is 230 volt between them. This is a simplified explanation as the voltage is actually higher in all cases but the RMS (As I recall Root Mean Square), which is the voltage measurement used by everyone is a calculated voltage and is what you will read on a normal AC voltage meter. In a normal 115 / 230 volt motor there are actually 2 separate windings. When the motor is wired for 115 V. the windings are hooked up in parallel, in the 230 V mode the windings are hooked up in series. The Watts used by the motor is the same. A 115 volt motor may pull 10 amp, wired for 230 the same motor will pull 5 amp. As the wire will carry only so many amps without causing excess voltage drop and heat due to the wire resistance the wire size can be reduced for the same motor power (Watts) expended. -- This is the reason the lines carrying the power from the generating stations are extremely high voltage (100s of thousands of volts). For safety and to allow putting the wires closer together and on lower poles the normal city lines are around 13,800 volts. When the line drops to your home a transformer is installed dropping the voltage to 230 / 115. If the 13.8K line is capable of carrying 30 amp, it will feed 3000 amp at 138 volt. However this is just playing with the ratio's, The amount of power (watts) is exactly the same whether you have 30 amp at 13.8K volt or 3000 amp at 138 volt.
Re: Is there no gain from the opposing wave peaks.
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>Bill, can you talk about the voltage drop phenomenon, and how it affects not only the motor start, but also its behavior under heavy load?
Trying to understand more of this electrical stuff,
DC
Re: Question
Rick Christopherson
>The rationale made sense because people on the internet invented it to explain something that otherwise did not make sense. There were actually a lot of explanations proffered over the years that this story existed, but they were all shot down except for the separate winding idea. Without tearing the motor apart, even I could not dismiss this idea completely, that is until I had the chance to speak with the project engineer. I forgot the exact reason for the error, but suffice it to say that the nameplate on the motor was incorrect. It has since been corrected.
Re: Is there no gain from the opposing wave peaks.
Rick Christopherson
>The issue about voltage drop is frequently overstated in some areas, but then understated in others. Most people that rewire their motor started out with 14 gauge wire, which has a much higher resistance per foot than 12 gauge wire. More importantly, the jump, or difference, between 14 gauge and 12 gauge is unusually high when compared with other comparable gauge differences.
The resistance per 1000 feet of wire is shown below for several wire gauges. Note how the difference between each of the larger gauges is about 1/2 ohm per 1000 ft, but for 14 gauge, it jumps by nearly 1 ohm per 1000 ft.
14 ga = 2.526 ohms/1k
12 ga = 1.588 ohms/1k
10 ga = 0.999 ohms/1k
8 ga = 0.628 ohms/1k
What this means is that if you are loading a 15 amp circuit near its capacity, you will get a significantly larger voltage drop than you would when loading a 20 amp circuit to its capacity. Using a 50 foot long circuit (100 ft total for two wires), I am listing the voltage drop for full capacity of each wire gauge. (Ohm�s Law: V = I * R)
14 ga, 15 amp = 3.789 Volts
12 ga, 20 amp = 3.176 Volts
10 ga, 30 amps = 2.997 volts
8 ga, 40 amps = 2.512 Volts
Going back to my original statement, people seem to overlook the fact that the voltage drop on a 15 amp circuit is very high, but when they put in a new 240 volt circuit, they also upgrade to 12 gauge wire. They not only reduce the current in the wire, but also reduce the resistance of the wire too. Simply upgrading from a 15 amp to a 20 amp circuit for the same load/tool would nearly cut the voltage drop in half without needing to rewire for higher voltage.
14 ga, 15 amp, 120 volt = 3.789 Volts
12 ga, 15 amp, 120 volt = 2.382 Volts
14 ga, 7.5 amp, 240 volt = 1.895 volts
Where this gets grossly overstated is when people talk about installing 10 gauge wire to reduce voltage drop on a 15 amp tool. The difference between 12 gauge and 10 gauge voltage drop amounts to about 1 volt difference. This is trivial considering that the power grid voltage can fluctuate more than this throughout the day.
12 ga, 15 amp, 120 volt = 2.382 => 237.6 Volts
10 ga, 15 amp, 120 volt = 1.499 => 238.5 Volts
By the way, Bill mentioned Power loss, not voltage drop. Even though he worded his statement correctly, it was a little misleading because he was otherwise discussing voltage, not power.
How this impacts motor starting is that the high currents during startup cause a significant voltage drop for a split second. This slows down the motor starting, but becomes much less of an issue when the motor is idling or even under full load.
Re: Question
Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach
>> I forgot the exact reason for the error,…
I have a recollection of you saying at one time that it was a derating that Delta had to do to get UL listing to market the saw for use on a 15A circuit @ 120V. The recollection is so strong that I alluded to it in a post a few days ago in the 34-444 thread. That sounded perfectly plausible to me as derating is something that is done in other areas.
Of course if you're trying to be circumspect, then I'm not helping much, am I?
Rod