Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Dust Collection

Posts

Dust Collection

#1

Dust Collection

JerryB617

>Help! Would somebody please save me? I'm so sick and tired of dust, dust, dust, and more dust, plus my wife giving me nine kinds of hell for having such a dirty shop. I have an air filtration unit (which I turn on when entering the shop)and 3 shop vacs. My biggest dust makers are my table saw and thickness planer. I'm a small time weekend woodworker/hobbyist that doesn't want to invest an arm and a leg for an expensive system. My questions are:

1. Given the above info, what can I do?

2. Would a super huge exhaust fan work, and if so, what kind of diameter and motor specs are we talking about?

3. I bought the flexible arm and hood assembly from Rockler but my shop vac doesn't have enough oomph to suck the dust. I think my unit is 6.25 peak HP.

4. Is the cyclone lid adapter from Oneida really worth the money?

5. What about the lid adapters that Rockler and other woodworking suppliers have in their catalogs?

6. What about the dust hood advertised for the Rigdid TP1300 planer? Is it worth it? My planer didn't some with one already on it.

Like I said, I'd rather buy a good set of golf clubs than buy an expensive dust collection system but I don't want to throw good money after bad money either. I'll be eagerly watching for your replies. Seriously I need some really good low cost ideas. Thanks in advance, Jerry from Lou-ah-vull.

Re: Dust Collection

#2

Re: Dust Collection

Chuck in ND

>Jerry, probably your best low cost solution would be to find a used dust collector that has low micron bags or a canister filter, and a good dust mask. The thing is if you don't take care of your lungs, you won't be useing those golf clubs much.

Re: Dust Collection

#3

Re: Dust Collection

Ray Binnicker

>Hey Jerry

While a shop-vac may be good for a lot of chores, and I have two in my shop for certain tasks, you can't beat a decent 1 to 2 hp dust collectors for those tools like your table saw, planer, etc. Shop vacs just won't cut it trying to collect from a table saw/planer. If you have an open bottom table saw then a good dust collector will still leave some stuff behind. Do you do a lot of sanding? That seems to be one of my biggest contributors. Bottom line though, I don't think there is any "cure all" for dust in a woodworking shop. The "New Yankee Workshop" looks clean because they have full time staff to keep it that way. A truly clean shop is an idle shop.

Ray Binnicker

Re: Dust Collection

#4

All you need . . .

SteveM

>is a medium sized shop-vac and about fifty bucks worth of medium size PVC and fittings. You can EASILY shop-make chutes for all your machines. The blast gates are the worst part. My Craftsman ( hold it down back there ) gates were only about ten bucks each. If your main worry is domestic bliss and " gross " dust collection it CAN be achieved for cheaper than you think. I've been where you are. PS : Blowing it out does'nt work. I tried that too ! Good luck !

Re: Dust Collection

#5

Re: Dust Collection

Hamish

>Jerry, what about positioning your shop vac or vacs outside your shop and run a pipe back into your shop to connect to your various machines. That way if any fine dust leeks out from the vac bags of filter, it will not be leaking back into the shop. If your table saw makes the most dust, have you thought about fitting a vac tube to the blade guard?

Let us know what you decide, Hamish.

Re: Dust Collection

#6

Re: Dust Collection

Mark Rakestraw

>Hi Jerry,

For the dust that falls to the floor the guys are right in that a dust collector is the best choice. For the fine dust that floats about in the air and settles out later, your idea of an exhaust fan is a good one. I use an old squirrel cage fan I got from a heating and cooling contractor free of charge. Made a platform for it with a plywood plenum and vent louvers(sp?) out the side of the building. Next to no cost and moves two or three times the air of an expensive air cleaner which probably doesn't filter out nearly as much stuff as they claim. Of course my shop is unheated, so I'm not sending all my "conditioned" air outdoors. If you live in a mild climate, or don't spend a lot of time in the shop, the cost of heating or cooling the makeup air probably wouldn't be significant anyway. Whatever you do do something. Wood dust isn't good for you and oxigen tanks are heavy to carry around. I'm an official "dust weenie". I've almost always got my exhaust fan running pulling in fresh air, in addition to running a dust collector at all the tools, a shop vac hooked to sanders and whatever other hand tools I can, and I top it all off by wearing hepa rated "Airmate" helmet. And with all that I still have a messy shop, but my lungs are clean.

Mark

Re: Dust Collection

#7

Re: Dust Collection

Mark Rakestraw

>I should have mentioned that if you do use an exhaust fan you need to make sure you have allowed for adequate make-up air to replace what you're blowing out. Otherwise you risk pulling flue gasses back down through flue pipes etc. If your shop is in your house, an open window or two in the living portion of house keeps the air moving from the living space, into the shop, then out the exhaust. With this kind of air flow, no dust will be able to fight its way "upstream" into the living space.

Re: Dust Collection

#8

JL

Re: Dust Collection

JL

>I had a 1.5 hp double bag system (Shopfox) which worked quite nicely for when I had it hooked up to my first system. I had about $400 in it between the hoses, hose clamps and PVC piping. It worked reasonably well with my planer, my table saw, my router table and lathe. I sold it to a friend after I got my new system. He uses it with his 15" planer and for his other tools.

Any dust collection system, even a small portable, will make some difference in the amount of ambient dust. If you don't want to invest in a big system, get a smaller roll around.