Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

New friends on my drying stack

Posts

New friends on my drying stack

#1

New friends on my drying stack

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>Over that last weekend I got two smallish walnut logs from a friend who took down a small tree. We rolled them up ramps onto the truck bed, dropped them at the sawyers and 2 days later I had about 75 bd ft of black walnut. Now I just have to wait a year or so. Nothing was over about 6" wide, and I had everything sawed at 4/4. I have some 9' boards and some 6' boards. Nice looking stuff. I kept the sap wood to increase the yield, and I like the contrast of the light/dark between sapwood and heartwood in walnut. Makes for some interesting patterns.

Lets see, the logs were free, I just had to muscle them around. Sawing cost about $150. Going rate around here for black walnut is about $5/bd ft. If I got 75 bd ft, that would have been $375. So, not a bad savings. I also found out I could get cheaper by being around to help out the sawyer. If I take the boards right off the mill and put them on the truck, I save time and I'm charged by the hour. I'll arrange that next time.

Now I'm hunting for a place to store lumber. I'm thinking of getting one of those portable garages - basically a metal frame with a tarp. Put some form of shelving in it and I can start stacking dried lumber. I don't have room indoors to store as much as I have or would like to get. Something that allows to me to keep it all dry and accessable (i.e. don't have to move 30 boards to get the one on the bottom).

Re: New friends on my drying stack

#2

Re: New friends on my drying stack

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Stephen,

You can use my back porch to store the black walnut, and I'd keep real close watch on your inventory. As it dried, I'd bring it down into the shop and test it on some furniture designs I have in mind. :<).

George

Re: New friends on my drying stack

#3

Re: New friends on my drying stack

Dick Coers

>Ahhhh, the wood storage problem. After I filled every spot in my basement that doesn't have a tool(including small, high figured stuff between the floor joists, all the corners and sides of my two car garage, my garage attic, a new 8'x24' lean-to on the back of the garage, half my Mom's garage, now pen blanks in the house attic, etc......... I had to sell my sawmill and stop taking free logs. IT'S EVERYWHERE!!!!! My favorite part, besides all that wood, was that I sold the sawmill for $300 more than I paid for it. So much wood, so little time. I wonder how much of my neighborhood will be destroyed if I had a house fire? It would look like the great Chicago fire all over again!!!!!!

Congrats on your free wood.

Re: New friends on my drying stack

#4

Re: New friends on my drying stack

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I like knowing that I'm giving perfectly good wood a better life than being turned into firewood or chip mulch. It's a shame to see nice straight wood hauled off into a green fill.

I don't even mind blade costs when encountering metal too much. Generally, the wood is so cheap that killing a few blades isn't all that bad. The blade makers need to find a way to either make a blade which can handle hitting some nails, or maybe add some kind of break, ala saw stop.

Re: New friends on my drying stack

#5

JL

Re: Well if you lived closer...

JL

>I'd trade you some green metal roofing for some of that lumber :).

How about making an A-frame at about a 60 degree angle. You could then get some galvanized siding and run it up the sides. Connect the two sides together and stack the lumber on the connecting pieces. Put a roof cap on so it would be self venting. I had plenty of left over roofing from my roof. Contact a local roofer for their left over pieces.

Re: New friends on my drying stack

#6

flawed economic analysis

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>There are many reasons to have one's own logs sawed but if an economic reason is the main justification than one should do the analysis correctly to determine whether value was gained or not.

Raw data: saw bill $150, 75 bdft yield green lumber of unknown grade, retail price for FAS walnut in your area about $5/bdft.

Any mill sawing walnut should be happy to sell green walnut for the same price they get after hauling it to market, which was, as of mid July, $2180 for FAS, $1300 for #1 common and $940 for #2 common (price per 1000 bdft). The retail price of KD FAS walnut is irrelevant to the economic analysis unless that is the only alternative for buying walnut.

A fine walnut log will yield a third or more #2common lumber and small logs may yield considerably more. Small logs will also yield a large fraction of sap wood and it would be typical that any FAS lumber from a small log will be mostly sap wood. A mill should be satisfied to let one pick logs and saw them for about $2/bdft sawed lumber.

Again, the decision to have logs sawed my not be mostly driven by economics. But if it is, then buying lumber already sawed will usually result in a savings.

Re: New friends on my drying stack

#7

Re: New friends on my drying stack

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>The blade makers need to...

A good metal detector helps.

JKJ

Re: New friends on my drying stack

#8

Re: We had a speaker at the woodworkers' club

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>who got started building only with wood that he and his mentor milled. Wood that had to come down for development, roads, dead tree removal, etc. When he got to having a surplus of over 60k bd ft, he decided he'd have to sell some of it. He stays about even now, at 60k bd ft.

It can get to be a problem for some folks. Me, I don't have a barn, and I'm not going to take out the garden to build another storage shed. The garage shop is bursting with tools and wood, such that it's hard to work in there. And there's maybe 150 bd ft at my dad's, in his basement, that needs to be retrieved.

Time to give some away, I guess.

Re: New friends on my drying stack

#9

Re: flawed economic analysis

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Yes, price is only one of my factors in determining what logs to get and saw up. I also get woods I don't have, stuff that might have nice figure, or when I'm looking to get sizes not readily available. Sentimentality also factors into things, if the tree comes from a relative or friend, or if several friends helped me with the logs.

I consider price to know when it may not be worthwhile. In such cases where the bd ft price on the yield is below the cost of sawing it probably doesn't make sense to do it. It's generally a rough estimate I keep in my head when deciding.

Oddly enough, I find myself not as concerned with lumber grades when doing my own cutting and drying. FAS and #2 Common are both just as useful in my shop (FAS when I need lots of clear wood, #2 common when I want to make sticks). I also find myself looking for imperfections to work into a project. I don't know the grading scale, so when I mark my boards I usually just record the # of defects or anything else majorly wrong with the board.

Oh, and sawing, at least on a personal level, is just fun. Even waiting for lumber to dry is kinda fun. Kinda like making wine. You wonder how it will turn out.

Re: New friends on my drying stack

#10

Re: Well if you lived closer...

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I've been looking around at the portable garages, which are basically tubular steel and a heavy tarp. I've seen some of them standing for years, so they obviously hold up. Heck, I could probably get two of them and use one for drying. I'd just need a way to be able to roll the tarp up the sides.

I'm looking for something easy to remove as I don't plan to stay on this property for too much longer.

I'll need a guard dog, though. I think I'm pretty close to many other people on this board.

Re: New friends on my drying stack

#11

Re: We had a speaker at the woodworkers' club

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Guess I'm still at the point where too much is never enough. I'm probably at about 800-900 bd ft total, between dryed and drying wood.

I know about too much wood in the shop, I need to get a structure build and get some out. Give myself some more room. I'll probably have to learn some self regulating at some time.

I'd like to start some timbers drying in the hopes of doing some bigger construction many years down the road.

If I do get my own mill, I better plan on building a barn for it and the lumber.

Re: New friends on my drying stack

#12

Re: New friends on my drying stack

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I'll keep you in mind if I run out of space. I'd want design rights on the furniture, though :-) Teehee.

Re: New friends on my drying stack

#13

Re: flawed economic analysis

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Stephen,

Did you actually pay $2/bf for your sawing? My Woodmizer guy charges me $.20/bf for full-size logs and $40/hour for short pieces. Over time, it actually balances out either way to about the same money.

I knew things were inflated north of the Mason-Dixon line, but I'm really surprised it cost you so much.

Gary

Re: New friends on my drying stack

#14

Re: Boards from the same tree are worth more!

Peter Gregory

>One great thing about this, is now you have a stack of boards from the same tree. They match and if you plan right, it can bring a great look to your project. This is always my goal when buying wood.

I would aways get 5/4 or 6/4, if I was getting custom boards. Something to think about for next time.

Have fun.

Re: New friends on my drying stack

#15

Re: flawed economic analysis

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>Yeah, it is higher around here. Some people are more, some are less. I know another who will bring the mill out, but I believe he charges $65/hr and starts charging when he leaves his place. I'm about 40 mins away, too. Probably wouldn't be terribly economical for me to bring the logs there.

Re: New friends on my drying stack

#16

Re: Boards from the same tree are worth more!

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>Yeah, I didn't do 5/4 or 6/4 on these since the logs were small. When I did my oak a year ago, I did mostly 4/4 and then a couple of 5/4 and 6/4.