Disposable Planer Knfe System
Tom Norton
>Anyone use this system? The company is Esta.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Disposable Planer Knfe System
Tom Norton
>Anyone use this system? The company is Esta.
Re: Disposable Planer Knfe System
Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa
>Hi, Tom,
Did you check the message archives? Seems there was a lengthy thread about this some time ago, maybe a year?
Ron in Iowa
Re: Disposable Planer Knfe System
Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio
>Yeah, I use them on both my jointer and my 15" planer.
They're a bit costly up front, but once you've been through about six blade changes (which take about five minutes each!), the cost amortizes out and it actually becomes cheaper than conventional blades and a sharpening service.
I really like mine.
Re: Disposable Planer Knfe System
Bart Goldberg
>I purchased their system for my Delta DJ-20 jointer. For me, they didn't work out. The reason was, the system relies on the accuracy of the milling of the bottom of the pocket in the cylinder head. You drop the magnets into the pockets and they serve to align the blades. If the pockets aren't absolutely flat and parallel to the jointer bed, the blades will not align properly. This was my problem. I sent them back to Esta and was given a full refund. I decided that for the cost of their disposable system, I could spend just another hundred dollars and purchase a spiral cutterhead from Byrd. In my opinion, money better spent.
Regards
Bart
Re: Disposable Planer Knfe System
Ford Beardsley
>Tom,
I put them on my 8in Bridgewood jointer and I couldn't be happier.
Ford
Re: Disposable Planer Knfe System
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>I have used it for at least over 10 years. It is a wonderful way to change knives. I never have been sorry we made the change.
Re: Disposable Planer Knfe System
Larry Clinton
>Take a look at changing to the Byrd head. I have this type head on both my 8" jointer and 20" planer. Once you use a spiral type segmented carbide head you will never look back at the straight knife systems. The cut is fabulous, even on gnarly wood with reversing grain (I have actually fed some wood at 90 degree to the grain with about as good a surface finish as I used to get from my old straight blade cutters). The cutter cost is quite low considering the inserts are long lasting carbide and you have four cutter changes per set of inserts. If you hit a nail etc., the damage is limited to only the cutters that hit the object - and you just rotate the damaged inserts. The height is fixed so no setup is ever required. To change or rotate an insert, one screw is removed, the insert removed, pocket cleaned and insert rotated 90 degrees re-installed (or replaced with a new insert) & the screw tightened. (I do have to remove a top cover plate on my planer to access the cutterhead). I have had mine for over a year, can't give an estimate of time required a I have not had to rotate or change any yet- still sharp and cutting very cleanly.
Re: Disposable Planer Knfe System
Scott Whiting - Glendale, AZ
>I have a set in my jointer and they work fine. Because my Craftsman jointer does not have an adjustable outfeed I couldn't use the Posi-set and had to set them like regular knives but now the screws are set it should be a quick change out. For 6 and 8" jointers they now have a system for setting that catches the edge of the groove that the knife sits in.
I am not completely unbiased as I am also a dealer for them.
Re: Disposable Planer Knfe System
Mac in Indy
>I've used them in my DJ-20 for about 5-6 years. I love the ease of blade change though I don't go through that many sets, maybe one set/year. I really like the new design that catches the lip of the blade pocket eliminatiing the unequal pocket depth problem mentioned earlier. It's an elegant solution!
I have not used a segmented carbide head like the byrd/shelix. I have heard great things and if the the cost difference was not too great I'd compare the two go with the one I liked in the end. Changing the head is more mechanically challenging than changing to the Esta system so factor that in the equation.
Good luck
Mac
Re: Hey Mac, if you want to try my Bryrd
Larry Clinton
>Head planer and or the Grizzly carbide head on the jointer, just come over - bring some problem wood - I'm only about 40 - 50 mile from Indy. Email me if you ever want to see one working.