Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

Posts

OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#1

OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Hi, Guys,

Hope you can possibly put my mind to rest on this.

For over two months now I've been experiencing shoulder pain that the Workmans Comp quack thinks might be a torn rotator cuff. I'm waiting for Workers Comp's ok for an MRI to determine if surgery will be required to repair it. I've also gone through two months of physical therapy with no gain, only pain!

I've gone under the knife a few times before- back surgery about ten years ago and knee surgery about eight years ago, both with good success. But I keep hearing (word of mouth) that shoulder surgery should be avoided if at all possible. At the same time, after doing extensive reading here on the internet, I've read that if surgery is not performed relatively soon, that loss of the use of the shoulder is imminent! I've already experienced less range of movement, but I thought it was through my daily activities, I've just been over doing it. Now I'm not so sure.

I was wondering if any of you guys have undergone shoulder surgery, and what was the outcome of it. Do you have the full range of movement as before, or still experience pain even after xxx years? How long can I expect recovery to take if I follow through with exercises and my doctors orders?

Will I be able to wave at the crowd if I ever ride in a parade?

Thank,

Ron in Iowa (Wondering how I got this old this fast!)

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#2

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>So last week I went to see the doctor at the (really well respected) HMO hospital here, because I had a shoulder problem, and couldn't raise my left arm very high without pain, and certainly couldn't swim properly, using a standard crawl stroke.

My doc indicated that there was inflamation, and took xrays, and gave me (mild) drugs and exercise, but said, unless I wanted to pitch left handed again, we would not look to do surgery. And that I would likely need to adjust to the future without a 320 yd drive down the middle of the fairway. Life is hard when you're 56 yrs old. ;-)

Shoulders are complex. Sometimes, they can do things easily. Other times, not so much. Mine feels a lot better. I'm swimming backstroke and breastroke now. Just more slowly.

I never could pitch left handed anyway.

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#3

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

frank shic

>have you tried a cortisone shot yet? for cases of bursitis, a cortisone shot will usually restore your function in less than a week.

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#4

Yup, tried that, too-not good results!

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#5

JL

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

JL

>Ron,

My wife had a severe tear to her rotator cuff a number of years ago. She went through the surgery. Immediately after the surgery, the doctor's office had the therapeutic machine people at our home, delivering a Continuous Passive Motion (CPM) Machine. She was "in the chair" for about two weeks for about 10 hours a day. She watched a lot of DVDs and read a bit. Physical therapy started the third week, and lasted for about three months. She was given a set of exercises which she does to this day.

It has been a couple of years. Since then, we've painted our new house and remodeled our basement area ourselves and moved into the new house, courtesy of a rental truck. Her range of motion is as good or better than it was before. The exercises have increased her strength.

The down side - she occasionally has "twinges" when sleeping on that shoulder.

I was diagnosed with a slight tear to my rotator cuff. The doctor prescribed an intensive set of physical therapy and the PT people gave me a long series of exercises. I was able to dodge surgery, but I only had a minor tear.

Bottom line - if you have a major tear, it evidently becomes difficult to reattach everything as they leave company from each other. If you need surgery, get it soon. You will be thankful for your decision.

Good Luck! BTW - how would you have moved the saw if I had shipped it to you? It was not light!

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#6

Good question-Dollor to a donut i'd find a way!

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#7

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

Phileas

>Hi Ron,

About 18 years ago - at age 23 - I had the Bankhart (sp?) prodedure done on my left shoulder. A rock climbing injury led to six dislocations over less than four years; I knew it was time for surgery when I popped my shoulder out sitting at my desk and stretching!

Bankhart is lots more invasive than arthroscopic. Basically, the doctor cuts the front muscles of the shoulder joint apart and then sews them back together so that they overlap. Because I'd also torn the rotator cuff loose from the bone, the doctor also pinned the cuff back into place with three screws.

I lost a couple of degrees of external rotation - not much range of motion at all. Six weeks of immobilization followed by a couple of months of physical therapy and I was cured. I took a year off of climbing, but am now free to do anything I ever wanted. In fact, I just got back from a week-long climbing vacation, where I definitely provide I now climb stronger than I ever did back then.

I do have a touch of arthritis when it rains; that's been with me for at least a decade. But it's way better than not being able to lift anything over my head!

Bottom line: surgery worked fine for me.

Cheers,

Phileas

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#8

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

Kneale Brownson in sunny N. MI

>I've not had a rotator cuff repair, only a reopening of the space the tendons slide through because of bone spurs resulting from a congenital narrowing of that space, but it was shoulder surgery. I used a surgeon who specialized in shoulders and I've had relief from pain, loss of range of motion and grinding noises that were there before the surgery a year ago. The surgeon told me she didn't expect to find rotator cuff damage, but would repair it if there was any, which there wasn't. This is a shoulder on which I had a fracture/dislocation 20 years before.

I have a friend who's had both rotator cuffs torn and repaired and has had good results.

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#9

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Thanks, Every one!

Just waiting now for them to give the go ahead for the MRI, but the quack says surgery will be the only repair. I'm not afraid of the surgery itself, but rather the outcome!

Ron in Iowa

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#10

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

jared

>HEllo: I am on the way to see the surgeon this morning to get the sam sort of procedure, scraping away bone to allow more room for the tendon to slide through, lined up. I plan to get it done right before thanksgiving as it seems like there is so much going on over the holidays that no much work gets done and I just as well be in the recovery mode. I have had injections, physical therapy, etc with no lasting relief. How long was your recovery from this procedure. The surgeon makes it sound like it wont take long but hten again, he is the cutter and not the recipient of this stuff. Please let me know on this. Thanks Jared

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#11

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

Brian Caldwell

>Hi Ron,

I'm one of the lucky ones that has had both shoulders done. The first time was about eight years ago when they performed the Bankart procedure and also worked on the rotator cuff. When they were all done, they put several staples in my shoulder and I had about nine months of therapy after that.

Two years ago, the same procedures were done on my other shoulder. However, it was arthroscopic and I have three little scars where they went in. No staples and the rehab was about six months.

If you go ahead with the surgery, you must be committeed to the rehab or simply don't have it done. Without the therapy, you won't be able to lift a 5-lb. weight and you'll be wasting your time.

Feel free to e-mail me if you want to talk.

Good luck.

Brian

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#12

Re: OT- Rotatory Cuff Surgery Question

Diane Anderson

>My husband reads this forum regularly and thought maybe I could give you my thoughts on rotatory cuff surgery. I fell and went headfirst into some bushes. I didn't go to a doctor for several days. I had two sets of physical therapy before they finally did a MRI. I had the surgery 7 years ago. Again I had two different types of physical therapy after and finally I had full range of motion and I don't have pain with it. The only thing I have to watch is sleeping with that arm stretched out. I don't know if I was just lucky or had an excellent surgeon, but I am blessed to have a good outcome!! One of the therapists told me that having a whole shoulder replaced was really very painful and difficult. So I guess that wouldn't be something I would want to have to do! Gordie & Diane Anderson

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#13

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

Brian Altman

>About 2 years ago I had the shoulder problem. Try to reach into the back seat without crying!!!I told my wife I wanted surgery because I could not stand the pain any more. She said she wanted me to try massage first. "Yeah I said some one rubbing me is going to cure this!" Did the massage once a week. Within a month or so I was almost completely healed! I never in the world though this would work. But it did. Worth a try before being cut.

Brian

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#14

MRI

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Ron,

I thought I had the same rotator cuff problem until my doctor called up an MRI for the orthopedic guy. We looked at the image and saw a significant bone spur which irritated the super spinalis muscle. Surgery is the last option as other health issues have to be considered. PT is one option which I can "live with". I think I;ll get a cortisone injection(s). It has really crimped my "stile". Good luck---but do get that MRI and have it read by somebody who isn't a quack.

George

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#15

Did the rotator cuff thing

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Ron,

After several years of decreasing range of motion with increasing pain, multiple treatments including injections, and many months of therapy, I had the rotator cuff surgery in late '99. The surgeon used the minimally invasive scope method to remove excess bone but ended up having to make an incision and insert two stainless steel screws to anchor tendons. He said the things had worn through and were "hanging by a thread". No amount of treatment or physical therapy would have fixed the problem.

Physical therapy following the surgery was difficult and if I remember correctly took about four or five months. I took a lot of pain pills during that time.

The good news is I have complete range of motion. The bad news is the continued pain, both at rest and while lifting things. The surgeon at first told me the pain would subside after a few months, then he said 6 months, then he said a year. Seven years later it still hurts every day! However, I'd far rather have the range of motion with the pain than not be able to scratch my ear. (Before the surgery, I had to use my left hand to assist my right - if I had not had the surgery I likely would have almost no use of my right arm today.) I do have some remaining strength limitations, especially when working overhead, and definitely have endurance limitations.

Oh, I forgot to mention how I injured my shoulder - believe it or not it was from sitting at a computer cranking at a mouse 12-20 hours a day and often 7 days a week. I was a type-A computer graphics and animation maniac and one-man production shop at work and cg guru/tech support/hobbiest at night. Added to this was poor posture: slouching and leaning on my elbow. The pain developed so gradually over many months that I didn't stop ignoring it until too late. In that respect, the later you wait the worse it may get. (Trading the computer for goats and chickens in retirement did me a world of good - I just have to carry two buckets 1/2 full instead of one full 5-gal bucket of water.)

ONE BIG THING TO REMEMBER: you can get reports from 25 different people and read things on the internet until your eyes fall out but your case will still probably be different. I know people who have had NO lingering pain; I've heard of others who failed to follow through with the physical therapy (because it was too hard?) and ended up with extremely limited range of motion. Best thing is to get the MRI results which should indicate treatment or repair.

JKJ

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#16

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

Jerry Roberts

>Hi Ron. Several years ago I had the exact problem. I had the cortizone shot and it worked for a year or so. Then I went to a different doctor. He had been in practice for a very long time. He gave me the cortizone shot that did no good at all. I then went to an orthopedic clinic here in Orlando. I got the MRI and the new doc gave me another cortizone shot. It worked like a charm. I havent had any problems for over 4 years and Im 68. That shot in the shoulder has to be placed exactly in the right place or it does no good at all by a doctor that knows what hes doing. Before you get the surgery Id consider another opinion. Good luck.

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#17

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Brian,

Was surprised to see you post on WC. You did a short article on my "Chimes of Normandy" Clock about a year ago in "The Woodshop News".

Good to hear from you!

Ron in Iowa

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#18

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

JerryB617

>Well here's my two cents worth. I tore my rotator cuff back in '98 and didn't have surgery until '00. At the time I hurt myself I was playing golf 3 - 4 days a week, building a deck, woodworking, and my regular job as a computer/telephone cable installer. Ouch, I was really working my shoulder to death. I've had surgery, PT, and shots. I finally found a comfortable medium by lifting small weights. I curl 12 lbers, 8-9 reps, 2-3 sets about every other day (I just push myself to the point of a little stress)and press a couple of 30 lbers 5-6 reps about 2 sets a day. I learned to use my body weight to hit the golf ball instead of my arms. I power plane or scrape wood as much as I can instead of sanding. I use screws with a power screwdriver instead of swinging a hammer. All of this combined has helped to stay relatively pain free. I'm 58 and our age it's very hard to find just one cure for a physical ailment. Life is full of trial and error.

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

#19

Re: OT- Rotator Cuff Surgery Question

Jim Dillon

>Hi Ron,

So far, except for a month long episode a year ago, I've avoided any real shoulder problems (knock-on-wood). As someone else mentioned, try to find an orthopedic surgeon who specializes in shoulder surgery. I know this is harder than it sounds, but might be worth it. A shoulder specialist will have a lot more experience treating well... shoulders, than say an orthopedic surgeon who specializes in hip surgery. Most major hospitals, and certainly teaching hospitals, have staff dedicated to the various specialities. Might be worth a try. Oh yes, my wife is a big believer in accupuncture (for other ailments). Hey, that might be worth a try as well 8-). Good luck.

Jim