Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

OT: Guitars, Robots, etc.

Posts

OT: Guitars, Robots, etc.

#1

OT: Guitars, Robots, etc.

Luke Herzberg

>Some months back while flipping through the channels, I paused at PBS which was showing a multinecked stringed instrument apparently played by robotic control. Both the artwork, craftsmanship and control were amazing. I later tried to search for more info on what this was, who made it, how, why, and everything else, but couldn't find any info on the web. Searches for "robotic guitar" and the like bring up machines that are functional yet crude compared to what I saw.

Anybody have any idea what it was? Even if it was the creation of clever computer animation, it was the best I've seen. Surely the collective knowledge of WC can come through here! : )

Thanks,

Luke

Re: OT: Guitars, Robots, etc.

#2

Re: OT: Guitars, Robots, etc. *LINK*

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Luke,

This it??

Ron in Iowa


Gismodo

Re: OT: Guitars, Robots, etc.

#3

Re: OT: Guitars, Robots, etc. *LINK*

Todd from San Jose

>Luke,

You may be talking about "Resonant Chamber," a remarkable animation on one of the Animusic DVDs. I have both disks, and my 3 young kids can't get enough of them. They watch them more than cartoons, if you can believe that.

I'm a woodworker hobbyist and a mechanical engineer that designs robots, so this really hit home for me. I absolutely recommend that you buy the disk.

Todd


Animusic

Re: OT: Guitars, Robots, etc.

#4

Re: OT: Guitars, Robots, etc.

charlie belden

>It's a good thing that AniMusic wasn't around in the 60s because some of us would be still sitting on the couch with a bowl of Screaming Yellow Zonkers muttering "That's FAAAAAAR Out.". Just to come up with the instruments and the mechanisms to play them is pretty amazing. Coming up with original music and then building a complex, synchronized animation for it is astounding.

charlie b

Re: OT: Guitars, Robots, etc.

#5

I could kiss you

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Todd, a few years ago I was at Electronic's store and this DVD was playing on the TVs. It was awesome. I loved it. I asked a couple of the salespeople about it and they had no clue. They didn't know the name, couldn't find it (guess it was too hard for them to figure out which DVD player to open up and check), and they swore it was a special demo DVD only available to the store and not for sale. Frustrated, I went to another store who had no idea what I was talkign about. I searched the internet and came up empty handed, so I just forgot about it.

I'm so HAPPY now to see this. Thanks for reminding me and thanks for the link. My kids will thank you too, but only at Christmas ;)

Now what did I do with my credit card?

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT: Guitars, Robots, etc.

#6

Re: OT: Guitars, Robots, etc.

Luke Herzberg

>Wow thanks, Todd! That's it! When I first saw the clip on TV, I thought for sure that somebody had built this amazing music machine. Finding out that it is animated is actually just about as amazing, as I'm always a critic of CGI. Even in big budget movies, the computer imagery has advanced textures, lighting and billions of polygons, but they can never seem to get the simplest of physics correct, particulary simulating mass. What sold me when I saw the Animusic was the amazingly realistic physics of motion, particulary the vibration of the strings.

I checked out the website and didn't leave before ordering a DVD. Thanks again for solving this mystery for me.

- Luke

Re: OT: Guitars, Robots, etc.

#7

Re: OT: Guitars, Robots, etc.

Bob Lemon - Sacramento CA

>Luke,

For the Animated version, which is very well done, search for Animusic, and Anamusic 2. They have a web site with clips and there are some postings on YouTube.com. For the real thing, search for Wurlitzer Automatic Harp, the Encore Banjo, Hupfeld Phonoliszt, and Ragtime Automatic Music.

If you would like to know about people who collect this stuff, check out AMICA (Automatic Musical Instrument Association)and MBSI (Music Box Society International). Also, a search on YouTube for Automatic music.

Re: OT: Guitars, Robots, etc.

#8

Animusic

JohnKJordan in East TN

>But do you have the tee shirt? :)

I once had a long conversation with the guy who does Animusic and he is a remarkably creative person. (Animation was my field for years) He created the music first, then created a software engine that "wired" the triggers of various components in the animations to midi.

The first one I saw was at one of the annual SIGGRAPH computer graphics conventions in LA in the Electronic Theater. The audience of several thousand people went wild, and these are people not easily impressed.

We got one big laugh from this - a few years ago a big lie circulated around the internet describing how a complicated machine had been built to make music:

http://www.snopes.com/photos/arts/musicmachine.asp

I've shown these pieces on DVD to many, many people and have not yet found someone who didn't enjoy them. Anyone who hasn't seen them will definitely not find them a waste of time or money. They make excellent and inexpensive Christmas presents.

JKJ

Re: OT: Guitars, Robots, etc.

#9

physics

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>but they can never seem to get the simplest of physics correct...

The reason some cg animations look so bad is the due to the animator. Animating motion manually using traditional keyframe techinques relies entirely on the skill of the artist. Unfortunately, much of the wave of animators came to the field through the computer geek route and have trouble with both art and motion. I listed to a talk by a person responsible for staffing one of the major cg film companies and she said they don't even consider the computer skills of applicants: "We can teach you how to operate a computer but we can't teach you how to create art."

Today, animators are assisted by software engines that incorporate real physics into cg to take things like gravity, mass, surface tension, friction, and elasticity into account. When originally introduced, these routines worked well for inanimate things but not for characters but that is changing. These days, even the individual hairs on characters (e.g., look at Monsters, Inc.) react to programed forces of gravity and wind. But even the best tools don't make a good animator, just as the best saw won't make me a fine furniture maker.

The Animusic people are the first I know of who applied physics to cg for use with music. They wrote custom software to use real-world physics calculations for everything. For example in my favorite, Pipe Dream, the software triggers exactly the right time ahead of the note to fire a ball on a trajectory calculated to land on a surface exactly in sync with the sound. The ball obeys the laws of gravity and the motion of the object struck takes inertia, mass, elasticity, and other factors into consideration.

Physics software used to be quite expensive (I've spent thousands for it) but basic routines are now built into the commercial 3d sofware systems such as the one I use, 3D Studio Max. It's great fun to set up a scene, tell it to go, then watch things fall, bounce, slide, flip, and squish. But don't let anyone kid you, it's an incredibly intense and tedious effort to define things so they do exactly what you had in mind! Add to that the work that goes into colors, textures, and lighting and you can understand why it takes teams of people many thousands of hours to create some of the animated things we see today.

JKJ

Re: OT: Guitars, Robots, etc.

#10

Re: physics

Luke Herzberg

>Art vs. programming. That's a good explanation of it. All the old Disney or Looney Toons (or even stop-frame Harryhausen films) always had correct physics, but they didn't have computers figuring it out for them. They were simply artists (very good ones) that drew what looked correct.

In that same vein, it seems much of the new CG increasingly uses the motion capture to animate characters. I think even this technique gives inaccurate results (i.e. looks bad) because unless the motion capture is used to animate a person of the same height, weight and build, the physics are still wrong. With radical differences in bodies, like human motion capture applied to a penguin, or applied to a 30 foot tall incredible hulk, the motion capture just gives wrong info.

I dunno...it just seems like somebody screening a film pre-release woud say, "Hey, we just spent $250 million and our CG looks like crap!"

- Luke