Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

New Yankee workshop down load site??

Posts

New Yankee workshop down load site??

#1

New Yankee workshop down load site??

wayne

>I know that last night I found a link to a site that had old shows now I have lost it. I don't think I got that much older in one night.

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#2

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site?? *LINK*

Chuck Steger

>Are you referring to Nahm's web site or something else?


New Yankee Web Site

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#3

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Wayne,

I saw it this morning, but I think it was a website that was illegally pirating NYW shows, so was deleted by the "officers" of WC. Good for them! Let's keep WC clean!

Ron in Iowa

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#4

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Wayne,

Did you see the news about the gal sued for illegal music downloads? She'll be paying off the judgment for the rest of her natural life (if her heirs are lucky).

You HAVE to know it's a pirate deal. What you may not know is that if the feds pop that site, they get lead straight to your address and computer as a "customer."

I like NYW as much as others, but I sure wouldn't pay to watch it, expecially the kind of numbers that that woman got tagged for; $10,000 a POP!

mm

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#5

Thanks for the heads up

Wayne

>Back to recording on Saturday again, o-well

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#6

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

Dean Lapinel

>I agree, I love the higher standard of ethics of this forum and I thank them for deleting that thread.

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#7

How is it unethical?

Eric from Little Rhody

>Isn't NYW available over the airwaves, on PBS? Can't I legally record it with TIVO, VCR, etc.? If so, what's so unethical about recording a show and making the recording available to others, as long as you're not making any money off of it? Is it illegal or unethical for me to record the show off PBS onto a DVD and and let a friend borrow the DVD? What abvout if I charged them for the blank DVD?

Guess I don't get it. If it was an HBO show or a movie on DVD or something that required you to pay to view it, I could see the problem. I can't in this case. I won't even get into who owns the broadcast frequencies or who pays for PBS.

I'm not quite ready to give away all my rights to the entertainment industry.

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#8

Re: Quite Simple

Brian in Brighton

>You have the right to make a video tape of the show. You do not have the right to distribute that tape to anyone. Legally, no one will bother you if you loan it to your buddy. You can't show it or distribute it though. PBS pays for these shows, they are not free since the supporters of local PBS help pay for the shows.

For me it's all about mass market. Napster, etc have been ruled to be in violation of copyright laws for allowing a distribution path for copies of files to be downloaded without compensation to the copyright owners. You might think you can copy anything you want, you can't. Nobody will bother you for making a copy for yourself, or even your brother. Once you start mass distribution the game is over.

If NYW was smart they would offer streaming videos for a monthly fee or pay as you go. I would gladly spend a buck to view an old episode.

Brian in Brighton

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#9

Re: How is it unethical?

Dan Donaldson

>I am not a lawyer, nor do I play one on TV, but from what I understand, you can record something off the air to watch for yourself, but cannot give it away, sell it, or share it legally. At church, if we have a kids party, we are not allowed to take a DVD that we have at home (commercial, legally purchased) to the church and show it to a group of kids because that violates the copyright, even though it is non-profit and no one is paying anything for the viewing. That is official policy, not just something that someone pulled out of a hat.

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#10

OT - % Chance the RIA Collects the $

CP

>I wonder what the chances are that the RIA is actually able to collect from the woman in Brainard MN. I think the issue she will be appealing is whether the RIA must show she actually distributed the songs (vs. just making them available). Query what are the damages to the owners of the music if nobody actually downloaded what she made available. E.g. - If I tell my neighbor that he can copy my cds but he never does...is that a copyright violation? For that matter I can borrow cds from the local library. They are making them available and I could if I want make a copy of those cds???? I never have but should the library be punished?

If the RIA ultimately prevails on appeal what are the chances they can actually collect? A 200K judgement is worthless if the person doesn't have the money. A bankruptcy filing might be the next step.

Even if the woman doesn't declare bankruptcy the RIA might have trouble. I believe the person in question is native American. I'm not sure whether she lives on a reservation but if she does it might be difficult to enforce the judgement. I'm no expert in Indian law but from what I've heard its no sure thing that a local tribe will grant comity to a foreign judgment.

BTW - I doubt the RIA really cares about any of the above. I think they just wanted a favorable trial court finding so that they could display it to the press.

My personal opinion is that the industry has completely blown a wonderful opportunity to make money. Since itunes came out I have gladly ponied up the dollar to download a song. I think its a fair price. I would never have bought any of these songs if I had to buy the whole CD in order to get the song I wanted. The industry has made a few hundred dollars from me that they never would have seen. They should have embraced digital music from the start.

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#11

Re: OT - % Chance the RIA Collects the $

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Having not followed the the "facts" established in the case, it's important to understand that the facts as determined by the jury cannot be appealed. The only appeal in on the legal concepts involved and applied through the trial Court's instructions to the jury at the close of the case.

As far as collection of the judgment goes, they will be able to garnish up to 25% of the woman's pay for as long as she works until the judgment and the interest that will accru at the rate of about 5% a year on the unpaid balance, and her status or presence on a "res" will provide no shield to that liability. For example, she would have to make $40,000 a year just to keep up with the yearly interest on the judgment debt.

Bankruptcy may not help her either, depending on the basis of the facts. Damages which flow from intentional wrongdoing or debts exempted from discharge by other laws, may not be effected by a bankruptcy so all she would be doing is paying more legal fees for nothing.

The lady is in very deep do-do, and she is only the first of many who may follow.

It amazes me that so many people insist on believing in free lunches.

mm

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#12

Re: Quite Simple

Eric from Little Rhody

>What about if I invite a few friends over to watch the show live on TV? How is that different than giving them a copy of the tape? Still not seeing how this is unethical, and it's different than Napster, as far as I'm concerned. With Napster, people could download something free that they would normally have to pay money to hear. I would agree that's unethical. But with NYW, they're broadcasting the stupid show over the air. Freely. Anyone can watch it.

It may be illegal (although I wonder if a smart group of laywers funded as well as RIAA, et al, could make an argument otherwise), but I just don't see how it's unethical, which was my original point. I guess my ethics are just different, and I'll leave it at that.

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#13

Not Ethics - Long

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Eric,

It's not your ethics that are involved, it's your definitions of roles as applied under what we call The Law that are flawed. You view is result and intent oriented which doesn't always work when applied to others.

You are correct that the show is "broad"cast free. When you have your NYW party, say for people who have lousy TV reception and don't get NYW in their area, you are still acting only as a "receiver" of the show. Same would be true if you have 150 NYW-deprived folks over to watch and had to put extra TVs in your windows and impose restrictions on tailgate parties in your yard (so long as you didn't charge admission or take contributions). You could also invite those Norm-starved minions to park their RV's in your yard with their own TVs and VCRs and watch/tape the show for themselves (so long as they weren't using your cable service connection - called "theft of cable"). But once you record that show and send it out to others, you're acting as a "Rebroadcaster" of the content. That's prohibited by the laws, and also infringes upon Norm's rights to sell his tapes of the show to those same people.

"But," you say, "I'm not making any money when I loan the tapes! In fact, I have to BUY the tapes, and PAY damn the postage. Norm should be PAYING ME for getting him a wider audience!!!!" True, but irrelevant, even though the effect is exactly the same.

Your confusion (if there is any) is between the legal rules that get applied in courts and the moral ethical rules most of us try to live by without others with questionable or crass commercial motives telling us to do so. Once in a while those two sets of rules intersect, but as a very good lawyer once tried to explan to me, the number of such intercestions are rare indeed, and it's usually a collision where somebody gets hurt.

You look at sending those tapes to 6 friends as no big deal, and you're right. Now lets say you have 60 friends who send you blank tapes with 2-way prepaid postage and you record the show, make the 60 copies, and send them back. Any difference here? Probably, but maybe not.

How about 6,000? or 60,000?

You, ethical guy that you are, say "Well, 6 is okay, but 60,000 is too much. And besides, Mandell, you're unfairly taking my example and twisting it all out of proportion to what I said." Okay, very true, so where along those 59,940 copies did you (or I) cross that ethical line we're trying to establish? What's going to be your rule (a Law, if you will) that others should follow and a judge and jury can objectively apply evenly to everybody that comes before them? If you're making a law that will have to be enforced in a uniform way, you're probably going to have to set the bar pretty low. In fact, that's what's been done. Make one copy for yourself, you're OK. Make more, you'll have a problem; the more you make the bigger the problem. It's a simple and easy rule to apply without "exceptions" and legalistic arguments by sharpie lawyers diluting it to the point of uselessness.

What's the difference, then, if you simply record that free show and let anyone who wants to just come by your house, at any time, and simply watch it? No tapes, no mail, and no "Broad"casting because they have to come to your house to see "Eric's Copy" of it. Right? Gridlock and air traffic control problems aside, you're not doing anything more than inviting friends over to watch the show, right? Right. But now comes the internet and, instead of a VCR and your family room TV, you have your copy of the show on your computer and those same millions of guests can just log onto Eric'ssite.org watch YOUR COPY of the show. Hey, saves huge amounts of gas, prevents gridlock, and prevents your yard from getting torn up every time PBS puts the show on. The folks who make Doritos and salsa may be a bit disappointed, but what's not to like about this idea?

You can see the problem, right?

It's not your ethics, Eric, it's when and how to apply a rule dictated by your ethics to other peoples' conduct where the problems arise.

Hold onto your ethics; you're fine.

mm

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#14

Re: Not Ethics - Long

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>VERY, VERY, well put, Mr. Mandell! Kudos to you!

Ron in Iowa

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#15

Mark, are you a lawyer who works wood, ..........

Art Silva

>or a woodworker who reads law? Outstanding analysis! Thanks. Art

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#16

Option

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>#1.

I've also slept at a Holiday Inn a few times. |;-}}}}

I don't (can't) give legal advice (or actually answer legal questions) here or anywhere else over the internet, but hopefully I can help people to generally understand how "issues" arise. This hobby of ours brings up things like this that are particularly difficult to explain because the very foundation of how all of us get started in it is by copying other peoples' work. There is a culture of replication that gives the misleading appearance of having no limits. From plans in the favorite mag, to Norm's "measured drawings", people get a false sense of how these issues will be handled when somebody objects in the Courts.

I wouldn't be surprised if that woman who was hammered in the music case thought that what she was doing, merely sharing music with others for free, was perfectly fine. I'm sure there are lots of people just like her, and our friend Eric, here, who would not have second thoughts about that sharing because they don't know the rules and laws that apply to their conduct, but then get terribly hurt when the proverbial ton of bricks falls on them out of a clear sky.

I'm glad if it helped people here to understand a bit of the "why" that underlies what may seem like arbitrary and illogical rules.

mm

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#17

Don't know about that specific one....

John in NM

>But I did hear an article on the radio last week where the case was starting to turn against the RIA. They're not as pearly white as they may seem - to a lot of outside observers, like me, one side of the dispute is as bad as the other, but at least the illegal downloaders are not coming after innocent people, forcing them to liquidate their entire life savings to prove their innocence, and then attempting to weasle out of coughing up to pay for their error. The case I'm refering to the error was apparently pretty easy to spot when they actually looked for it - the downloader was another individual on the same ISP. There's all flavors of lawyers in the world, but I don't think the RIA has any of the ethical ones.

Just another point of view.

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#18

Wish I Could Watch New Yankee Workshop

Brian in SLO

>In my area we don't get NYW. Not on PBS, not on DIY, nothing.

I wish there was a website that had the videocasts of the shows so I could watch them. It's a bit expensive for me to order all of the episodes on video.

Can someone send me the link so I can at least watch? I promise not to try to sell them!

Anyone?

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#19

Re: Not Ethics - Long

Matt Prusik

>Mark:

As a practicing IP lawyer myself, the only criticism of your comments that I can offer is that your discourse completley ignores any application of the "defense" of "fair use" of a copyrighted work.

Moreover, I think it best for us as attorneys to consciously not use our superior knowledge of the law to "chill" anyone's ability to communicate or otherwise inhibit their right to communicate as set forth in the First Amendment.

While I too have opinions on "copying" things for educational purposes and distributing them via the Web or through intimate, purpose focused, small groups in furthernace of such educational purposes, I prefer to keep my own counsel on such matters.

I never want anyone to construe that I am giving legal advice on any matter that I write about. Except perhaps that hand chisled dovetails must be done tails first ;-)

Finally I say loud and clear that no one here or anywhere that reads this has a right to rely on whatever I say as a legal opinion or legal advice in the context of an attorney/client setting.

Matthew J. Prusik, Jr., Esq.

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#20

Re: OT - % Chance the RIA Collects the $

Matt Prusik

>Mark:

As I understand the RIAA MN case, the award is premsied upon statutory damages for wilful infringment of copyrighted works.

And as an attorney who has been involved in appeals of trial court decisions on IP cases in the past, I would not want to take your money by even proposing that SOMEONE SOMEWHERE will NOT be likley to appeal that judgement or another similar RIAA judgment. Or that the RIAA will substantilly reduce the judgment quickly so as to put a check in the "win column" for this enforcement war. Seeing that the operative elements of a judgment (in this case -- Defendant paying money to the Plaintiff) under appeal in the Federal court system are necessarily stayed pending appeal, it's unlikley that any money will be changing hands soon if the judgement amount stays where it is.

I think that the Plaintiff is entitled to fees and costs under the statute once wilful infringment has been proved. If that is true and the RIAA makes applciationt to the Court for the award of fees and costs, that process alone will likely take months if not years to be completed.

Let's just say that the RIAA is way over reaching in that and the other infringement cases based upon Internet downloading. And it's just a matter of time until someone, somewhere stands up to the bully and these cases make their way up through the courts.

However, becuase the law is murky insofar as the Internet implications are concerned, it's likely that these cases will have to be appealed to the US Supreme Court -- which will necessarily take years. Or that it will take an act of Congress to amend the Copyright and other relevant statutes to clarify the legal issues.

Thus it's likley that it will be years before that woman ends up paying the RIAA anything at all. Which in the first place will be far less than the RIAA spent for legal fees on this case alone.

In this heavy handed enforcement action, the RIAA is likley to lose more for recording artists and revenues than it is ever going to gain by setting these "examples". It's a poor enforcement tactic --to be so heavy handed that it ignores the collateral damage issues. Based upon trial experience alone, I am certain that it's no mistake all of the "Defendants" we hear about in these cases are single mothers with children who downloaded music. In the end, it just shows how truly desperate the RIAA is in view of its upcoming loss on its ability to economically exploit recorded media.

Matt Prusik

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#21

Re: Ethics or Law

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Good Morning Matt,

I appreciate your response, but if you�ll reread my little tome poem, I hope you�ll see that it was not a course in copyright law (which I'm not qualified to teach), but rather an attempt to explain for Eric and other readers the conflict between their personal values or views on ethical behavior and public legislatively established rules that limit our behavior in so many ways. Since I�m sure millions of pages have been written on the subject, and hundreds of millions spent in litigations over many generations, it would be quite silly of me to attempt to set forth anything purporting to be a �discourse� on the subject here; especially since I don�t practice �IP� whatsoever, and would never attempt to give legal advice on the subject even if I were consulted directly.

The questions that repeatedly come up in this and other woodworking forums seem always to center on issues like

�Why can�t I use that tape that I made and which is now my personal property, any way I choose? It�s my tape, why am I likely to get in trouble if I make copies of it and simply give them away on the street corner because I think the show is so great that everyone should have a copy of it?

�Why, if I take that measured drawing or magazine plan that I PAID for, am I going to have some lawyer trying to take my house and life savings if I make copies of what are now my own documents to share with friends?

�Who are you, Mr. Hot Shot Demonstrator, whose living is made on the fees you get from me and others to watch you turn a particular piece, to tell me I�m not allowed to make as many of that shape or style as I want after you specifically get paid to reveal your secret on how to do it?�

I was not giving legal advise, Matt, and hence did not need to put in a disclaimer. Nor was I advocating a particular view of how things �should� be interpreted or applied. I�ll gladly leave it to you �IP guys� to do all of that. That I missed, in your view, two exceptions or limits on the general rule tells me that I got the basic jurisprudence right which is all I was trying to do. Better, in my view, if people know the issues are out there, and then go consult with someone like you to find out if they can safely do �this or that.�

And I use a Leigh [insert circle C] jig so I avoid all those pin/tail primacy issues. |;-}

mm

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#22

Re: $$$

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Since I haven't heard of a "defense fund" being set up for her or the ACLU getting involved, I'm doubting the lady will be able to come up with the $40,000 in appellate fees and costs that an appeal will cost.

"They" put a real crimp in The Oldest Profession when they started prosecuting the johns along with the hookers. I'm just cynical enough to discount, if not dismiss the woman's reported "I didn't know" defense.

Want free music? Listen to the radio. At one time (60's) I spent much time taping WNEW ("Scottso here") in NYC for tunes; they even published their play lists and times in advance. But even I knew then that I wasn't copying the stuff to "share" or rebroadcast. I made up my own collectons of songs that I could then play when I chose. In retrospect, the hours and hours I spent doing it "cost" more than the $$ it would have taken to just buy the records, but hey, it's free tunes, Man!!

mm

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#23

Extremely OT, nevertheless useful info.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> …I use a Leigh [insert circle C] jig…

Perhaps you posted that line that way for dramatic effect (and it was effective), however if you did it because you didn't know how to display the copyright symbol, I can help you. There are things in HTML called entities, which you can insert in the text you post which will display all sorts of useful typographical, er, entities.

For example, there are three of the most common fractions: ¼, ½, and ¾, which look so much better than 1/4, 1/2, and 3/4 which the unaware are forced to type. Also, things such as ellipses (…), em dashes (—), and proper quotes (which don't display properly in this particular typeface and font size) are available. Also, foreign language characters, such as the é in Denis Chénard of Orléans, Ont.'s name can be displayed (type é).

All begin with the amperand symbol, &, followed by several characters, and ending with a semicolon. The ampersand itself can be displayed (as in the preceding sentence) by typing &. That's it. To the point, however, should you wish to display the copyright symbol, simply type © and you'll get a nice © right where you want it.

The preceding furnished by the WebButcher, a newly minted semi-pro web author, who's been dinking with this stuff for years. Hardly a post in WC by me fails to have some sort of HTML enhancement typed in at the time of composition. Here's a handy site with most or all of them for your reference and bookmarking pleasure: webmonkey.com.

Rod

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#24

Thanks, Rod

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>As I'm sure you've noted, I have more than my share of trouble just hitting the right keys to make letters appear in groups that people can identify as English rather that some sort of secret code. I actually had a sheet of HTML code put somewhere, I think from a Pond or long-ago WC post. Naturally, once put away, it, like the Ark in "Raiders," shall never be found again. |;-}}

ps: The "insert" was for a chuckle, not drama. Matt and I are not (I hope) waxing dramatic.

mm

Re: New Yankee workshop down load site??

#25

Re: Ethics or Law

Matt Prusik

>Mark:

If you're going to use a LEIGH jig for anything and you want to properly credit the intellectual property rights involved when writing about it, then you need to use the Federal trademark registration symbol (R inside a circle -- presuming it's Federally registered as a US Trademark) or a TM if it isn't. But in normal IP correspondence, just putting a word in all caps indicates a reservation of trademark rights.

Copyright is something entirely different.

And while you may not have been giving advise [sic], my simple point is that anyone speaking with an air of authority tending to tell someone not to do something is an infringement of his right to "free expression" inherent in the First Amendment.

As to ethics and the law, the best guide (and an effective defense in many cases) is to do or not do what you might or might not want someone to do or not do to you.

Regarding the MN RIAA case, while I have not looked at the docket sheet in that case, it's worth keeping in mind that appellate period can run up to 120 days by way of various extensions under the Federal Rules of Civil and Appellate Procedure. So if anything, it's utterly premature to draw any conclusions as to whether the case will be appealed. Or more likely, that RIAA quietly backs down and collects a nominal amount for the "infringements" so as to avoid any collateral challenge to their track record of positive enforcement judgments.

Speaking for myself and having been on both side of enforcing IP rights over the last 20 years, and moreso speaking totally in the abstract, the latter is just about what I would tend to do in that situation.

I prefer the FESTOOL Domino system myself for making floating tenons instead of full mortise and tenon joints. IMO, it takes less time and gives results just as good.

Matt Prusik - who reads 1-2 times a week when working in Court