Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Quartersawn White Oak - Grain Direction

Posts

Quartersawn White Oak - Grain Direction

#1

Quartersawn White Oak - Grain Direction

Chuck Steger

>I know qtrsawn WO grain direction runs 90 degress to the face. I've got a WO board that has the grain direction running about 80-85 degress to the face. Is this still qtrsawn? Will the rays be as prominent? Most are proably thinking "just look at the face of the board". The problem is the board is at the bottom of a large stack and I need qtrsawn so rather than dig through all that and be dissappointed (and exhausted!), I thought I'd ask.

Re: Quartersawn White Oak - Grain Direction

#2

Re: Quartersawn White Oak - Grain Direction

JohnKJordan in East TN

>In my reading, I've encountered various definitions of quartersawn. R. Bruce Hoadley says the definition is flexible and may be applied to pieces with grain from 45 to 90 degrees with the surface.

Consider the way logs are sawn. For all boards to have 90 deg grain would create log/cant handling problems and a huge amount of waste so a broader definition makes commercial sense. I have heard of some purists who have custom cut entire logs radially for maximum figure. I think many simply saw first and separate out the quartersawn boards later. If you visit the sawmill forums you can read much about this topic.

I don't think the figure on any particular board can be predicted sight unseen but the angle of the growth rings to the face should indicate the relative width of the ray figure. Due to the way the rays are oriented in white oak, the rays will appear narrower the further the angle is away from 90 deg.

JKJ

Re: Quartersawn White Oak - Grain Direction

#3

dig it out

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>Your board will show ray flecks. They just will not be as long as a perfectly QS piece. As John said, the definition of QS varies, but for me the only one that makes sense is "can you see ray fleck?", and in your case the answer will be yes.

With a helper, you might be able to lever up the pile and remove your board and stick in a similar spacer; I've done it.

Re: Quartersawn White Oak - Grain Direction

#4

Re: Quartersawn White Oak - Grain Direction *LINK*

Bob Lang

>The generally accepted standard these days is quartered has the grain running 60-90 degrees, rift 30-60 degrees, and plain sliced 0-30 degrees. The link below leads to Frank Miller Lumber, the main sawyer in the country of QSWO, and a PDF brochure of their standards.

I can just about guarantee that the board in question will be absolutely beautiful, based on nothing more than its location in the pile.

Bob Lang


FML QSWO Brochure

Re: Quartersawn White Oak - Grain Direction

#5

What he said.............

R. Lance in GR, Michigan

>

Re: Quartersawn White Oak - Grain Direction

#6

A bit different defination....

John Cotten

>I worked for several years with barrel and stavel mills here in KY that make bourbon barrels and wine barrels. They are very specific on what is quatersawn, rift sawn, and flat sawn.

90 to 75 Quartersawn.

75 to 45 Riftsawn.

45 to 0 Flatsawn.

The reasons are defined by the strenght and expansion and contraction rates for white oak. If you were to use white oak with grain in the 65 deg. area, it would not expand and contract equally with wood in the 90 deg. area, resulting in leaks.

90 to 80 is the preferred cut. All of the barrel mills in our area have their own saw mills or contract with specific stave mills that cut only barrel staves.

Depending on what furniture you are building and the species of wood, you can get away with mixing quarter and riftsawn lumber.

As for white oak, the guidelines I gave you are very specific.