Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

OT - Video cable

Posts

OT - Video cable

#1

OT - Video cable

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Scene: Just bought SWMBO a new 1080p TV that is hooked into the stereo system, and a HD-DVD player.

Object: To connect these items.

Problem: I need a lousy 3' HDMI-HDMI cable for the player to TV connection (no HDMI connection through the AV system), but go shopping and I find prices that range from $9 to over $150!

FOR A 3 FOOT CABLE?!!!!

Naturally, I want the best performance from this new stuff, but GGAM, is 12ga. gold pressed platinum wire REQUIRED here?

I have a strong sense that I'm getting my "cable pulled."

Anyone who can explain/recommend [without putting a test meter in the circuit |;-}} ] can jump in here.

Thanks

mm

[drop the "2" for e-mail and ignore the SpamBlocker]

Re: OT - Video cable

#2

Re: OT - Video cable *LINK*

pecker

>I would go to monoprice.com and order their middle-of-the-road quality cable. For short distance in a home environment, there should be no need for extreme build qualiy or extra heavy gauge conductors.


http://www.monoprice.com/products/subdepartment.as

Re: OT - Video cable

#3

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: OT - Video cable

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Mark,

You absolutely DON'T need the $150 cable. If someone tries to sell you one, tell them they are full of it. The $9 cable should work just fine. After all, it's a digital signal--it either gets it or it doesn't. Granted, the cable has to be a little better than one that would carry a much lower-frequency analog signal (hence the $3/ft. minimum price), but it doesn't have to be jewel-encrusted. I would get a 6' cable, just for flexibility in future rearrangements of the system.

Here's where I've bought cables before:

www.monoprice.com

Decent cables at good prices.

Jason

Re: OT - Video cable

#4

Re: OT - Video cable

John McGaw

>I'm really surprised that the equipment didn't come with at least a set of component cables _and_ an HDMI cable. It seems that every piece of upscale video equipment I've purchased for a while has come with both. You can be pretty sure that none of the cables I've received have been of the $150 variety but strangely enough every one of them has worked perfectly. And the equipment vendors certainly wouldn't intentionally send out cables that make their equipment operate poorly.

My advice is to buy the low-cost cable or, if there will be some physical stress on it, buy a slightly better one with improved strain relief. But whatever you do don't fall for the "Monster Cable" hype that the local Best Buy or Circuit City sales types will give you. I find that the 1.5m cables that my local electronics wholesaler sells for $11 are excellent in both physically and electronically.

Re: OT - Video cable

#5

Thanks Guys

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I figured the bull$ was getting stuffed in the blister pacs!!

Ordered a cable for $15 which should be just fine.

John, the stuff did come with "component video" 5-cable sets, but the HDMI is required for many HD-DVD (& Blu-ray) discs to work; something about copy protection features on the discs that won't run otherwise.

Thanks again guys. WC comes through again!

mm

Re: OT - Video cable

#6

What model did you get?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>TV that is, nto the cable.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT - Video cable

#7

Re: What model did you get?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>She decided on an LNT5271F (samsung). Blew everything else in the store away!

Yeah, she's worth it. . .

Re: OT - Video cable

#8

Re: OT - Video cable

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>Mark,

Funny you mention this, I was watching a consumer advocacy show last evening and there was a complete segment on these cables. They had "Monster" cables upwards of 200.00 and much other, much cheaper 10.00 cables. The scientific conclusion with complete testing by a independant laboratory was that they provide the same signal within 2-3% quality.

Their overwhelming conclusion was to buy the cheaper cable.

As far as the big box stores,, they mentioned that selling these cables was like the popcorn concession in a movie theate. This is how the movie theatres make money nowadays :)

Norman

Re: OT - Video cable

#9

Much Like

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>That TV Blond with the slight British accent in the lame dress telling us that "There has never been a better time for you to invest in gold." After all, how else are they going to find new suckers to buy the stuff to keep the price up.

Popcorn, indeed.

|;-}}

Re: OT - Video cable

#10

monster cables

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Cable manufacturers have been by playing on the gullibility and ego of uneducated consumers in both the audio and video world for as long as I can remember. The problem is compounded by misguided sales people and greedy vendors.

What matters in a cable are the conductivity (size and material of the wire), shielding, capacitance, quality of insulation, and a few other factors. The heavy wire conductors touted by some makers are ridiculous for the frequency and current of video signals (witness the extremely tiny conductors in even the highest quality s-video cables). Far more important than the cable itself in my book is the contact area in the connectors at the ends. While gold plated contacts will resist corrosion, they are seldom needed as other materials work as well. In all of my years doing video work for a living, I have had a problem with the conductivity of connector exactly once.

To see what really works, go to the video professionals. They buy good quality but reasonably priced cables, never the crazy monster cables, and use them effectively for decades. If you are worried that your environment will quickly corrode the contact points of the connector, use a little electrical contact grease to exclude air and moisture. Silicone grease works well.

JKJ

Re: OT - Video cable

#11

monoprice.com

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I am one of those crazy audiophiles who gets into things like cables. Yet I cannot find a cable better built than those available at monoprice.com . Look at their video cables - their premium HDMI cables for example are 10 TIMES LESS EXPENSIVE than those found in the big box stores. Same with their audio cables, interconnects, etc..

I buy cables from them constantly and would challenge anyone to do a side by side, blind comparison between the ridiculously inexpensive monoprice.com cables and the most expensive, ludicrously overpriced monster cables and their ilk. Same with video quality. One cannot see a difference.

You can buy 300 feet of 12 gauge speaker wire for the same price you can buy about 50 feet of monster cable. Yet you can't tell a difference.

Believe me, I'd like to convince myself that $1000 speaker cables, elevated off the ground by ceramic insulators sound better than dumb old monoprice wire, but I know better.

Re: OT - Video cable

#12

Re: OT - Video cable *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>Mark - I bought a 50 foot hdmi cable from this guy on ebay to connect my plasma to the pc for $30. Works perfectly. He has a 3' one for 7 bucks, with shipping.

Dan


HDMI cable

Re: OT - Video cable

#13

Re: monoprice.com

Dan Mitchell

>I was into the whole esoteric audiophile thing a little bit in the 1980's. Subscribed to "Audio Amateur" & "The Absolute Sound". Having an electrical engineering background I was pretty skeptical, but I liked building & modifying equipment. When one of them had a serious, straight-faced discussion of whether or not a stereo powered by nuclear generated electricity had a broader sound stage than the same set running on coal-fired AC, I let my subscriptions lapse.

Dan

Re: OT - Video cable

#14

What about Stereophile?

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Some of those people are from the same sanitarium. Remember the green magic marker on the edges of CDs? Or the Radio Shack clock radio?

I once wrote a tongue in cheek article touting the value of aligning speaker cables with the isogonic lines of the earth for best sound and passed it around to some friends for laughs. I should have submitted it for publication. It wasn't far off some of the other nutty concepts that have been published in the name of ultimate sound.

Rod

Re: OT - Video cable

#15

Re: What about Stereophile?

Dan Mitchell

>Definitely remember the pens! The guy who came up with that scam probably hasn't had to work since. There were also colored rings you'd apply to the edge of a CD for the same effect - or lack thereof. Naturally, none of this nonsense ever stood up to double blind A-B testing, which the faithful (very much like a religion, this business) would invariably chalk up to some sort of Hawthorne effect, where the mere process of measuring affected the outcome. Plus let's face it, if you'd just shelled out 300 bucks for some interconnects, you're going to be mighty motivated to HEAR a difference, a highly subjective proposition further confounded by the fact it took you 15 minutes to remove the old ones & install the new ones, during which time your impression of what your demo recording sounded like initially has pretty much dissipated into the ether ;-)

Dan

Re: OT - Video cable

#16

Re: monoprice.com

Jim Dillon

>Dan,

LOL regarding nuclear/coal powerplant generated electricity and the impact on the "breadth" of the sound stage. Had not heard that one. I was sorta into the high-end stereo stuff during the '70s, but gave it up when crazy stuff like you mentioned started to get press. Then one of the mags finally convinced a panel of "golden-ears" to listen to a randomized double-blind test of a $10,000 amp vs a $100 JC Penny amp. Guess what, no difference (when played at normal listening levels) that couldn't be accounted for through random guessing. I gave it all up then and now just try to keep my ancient equipment running. Thanks for the memories.

Jim

And a BIG thanks to Pecker, Jason, and Mike for the link to monoprice.com. I had the same reaction as Mark did and am glad to have a source for inexpensive cables of all sorts.

Re: OT - Video cable

#17

Re: monoprice.com

Dan Mitchell

>"Golden Ears". Yeah I remember that condescending term. "WHAT??? You can't SEE the Emperor's new clothes??? BAH! You OBVIOUSLY don't have GOLDEN EYES like I do!!!"

Dan

Re: OT - Video cable

#18

Re: What about Stereophile?

wilbur

>I'm a bit of an audio freak myself. I remember one time I was out shopping for a new CD player, and the salesman showed me (I'll never forget this) the Bedini CD Clarifier. It used an electromagetic beam on your CD to make it sound clearer. He demoed it for me, and I gave it a good listen. I told him that I did hear a difference, but that I thought that the treated CD sounded worse than it did before treatment. (I actually did think this, even though it may have been a reverse placebo effect.) The expression on the salesman's face was highly entertaining, if nothing else.

Having said that, I do think that there are changes you can make to a stereo system that will change the sound that most people find silly, just in case you think that I am too sane. :@)

Re: OT - Video cable

#19

Try to cut audio freaks a little slack

wilbur

>For the record, the inexpensive amp was a $200 Pioneer receiver, and Pioneer has always made good amplifier circuits. Even hardcore audio freaks have consistently picked inexpensive Pioneer amps as good budget buys over the years.

However, consider this: part of what you pay for in the high end audio world is the attention to detail in terms of the quality of construction of the audio component. Is it worthwhile? Depends on the person.

Just keep in mind that we here on WoodCentral get all up in arms when non-woodworking people make similar comments about furniture. Imagine your post, substituting "handmade chest with dovetailed drawers" for "$10,000 amplifier", and "this other chest I saw at Ikea" for "cheap receiver".

Re: OT - Video cable

#21

Re: What about Stereophile?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>"Having said that, I do think that there are changes you can make to a stereo system that will change the sound that most people find silly, just in case you think that I am too sane. :@)"

Years ago, I was in that business. MANY years ago. One of the changes I found being made was being done by my 4 year old. He loved to push in the domes of the tweeters.

Thanks goodness we all survived. He's 34 this year.