Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Time for a new cordless drill

Posts

Time for a new cordless drill

#1

Time for a new cordless drill

jared

>I need some advice, I had decided to get a new cordless drill, most likely a Dewalt 14.4 volt outfit, with two batteries and a charger. It can be had for I think $159 with free shipping from Amazon. I know these drills are a good product, having used a friends for a while. Tonight I got an email from Woodcraft for their new line of Makita tools with the lithium ion batteries. All are supposed to be half price, which puts the makita drill at $189 with free shipping. Has anyone used one of these new drills, any pros or cons on the lithium ion batteries? I know that the brand of tools mostly boils down to personal choice but are there any huge disadvantages or advantages of the makita over the dewalt or vice versa? I know I am probably opening a can of worms with this post but Iwould like a little input. Thanks in advance Jared

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

#2

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>I have had two DeWalt 14 v drills. One of them has a chuck problem, need to replace the chuck. I also have a Makita 14 v with NiMH battery. I like the Makita better than the DeWalt but that is personal preference. I hear very good things about the LiIon batteries and have a Milwaukee cordless circular saw with one but I haven't had it long enough to judge the battery yet.

Howard

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

#3

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

Dan Mitchell

>I also have the Makita NiMH. Used it for about a year so far. Love it.

Dan

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

#4

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

Hamish

>I had a similar problem to face last year. The batteries of my trusted Metabo 12v cordless packed up on me after five years service. But to replace them was to be as expensive as buying a new drill. So I ended up buying a Makita 18v BHP 451RFE with lithium ion batteries. I went for lithium ion batteries as they say that they will last nearly three times as long as the older type. To date, the Makita has been faultless although a bit heavier than the old one which was only a drill driver. The Makita has three speed and a hammer action which has been very useful at times when I have had to drill holes in masonry away from the house or when I can't be bothered getting out the extension lead.

Although it cost more than I had originally wanted to pay, I look on it as an investment. It works very well and I recommend it.

Hamish.

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

#5

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

Jim

>I bought the Li-ion Makita over a year ago and love it! It's way more powerful than other cordless drills I've used, the charge lasts and lasts and if you don't use it for a while it keeps its charge.

Go for it!

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

#6

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Think about an impact driver. I've had the Milwaukee 14.4 for several years, and it has replaced my old Dewalt straight drill/driver for just about use. The impact only kicks in when needed and I prefer the chuckless hex drive.

Clint

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

#7

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

Joseph Mulherin

>Jared, try going to your local ACE Hardware store and you will find an 18V. drill w/bits and drills and charger for only $29.00. I bought one and it is doing everything I have ever wanted to do with a battery-operated drill/screwdriver.

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

#8

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

Barry Irby

>I have three Makita Drills and an Impact driver. There was a mix of batteries between NiCad and Nmh. I have had some of them ten years and the tools have been faultless. If I had to give up ALL my tools, the Makita drills would be the last to go. The little impact driver is great, in a class by itself. Its the batteries that need serious improvement. The older ones are good for about five hundred cycles. The Nickel Metal Hydride ones lose charge sitting. They sort of leak down. Not a good feature in my hobby shop because I might use them everyday for a while and then not again for a month. I have no experience with the Lion batteries so I can't advise.

If had to start at square one, I would buy Makita again without hesitation and I would get an impact driver in the kit. I would buy 12 or 14.4 volts. This is a place where there is a trade off between weight and power and litter weight is a real advantage.

My second choice would be to look at Bosch and Rigid. I believe Bosch has a 3 year unconditional guarantee on their tools. Buy one and at the end of 2 years and 11 months take the batteries back and get a fresh set. And Rigid has a lifetime warranty, but be sure to register and make CERTAIN the batteries are covered.

The tail may be wagging the dog here. The batteries are more important than the drills. They will almost give you the drill to induce you to buy the batteries. (That's how I got the third drill. Somebody stole the batteries from HD and they sold me the drill for $20)

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

#9

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

Jim Dillon

>Jared,

Can't speak wrt the Li-ion batteries, but you might also look at the Panasonic line of drills. I've had two Bosch drills. The first lasted 8+ years then died (I nearly cried as it had been a real workhorse). The second lasted two years then something went wrong with the chuck, but I might be able to fix it. Then I couldn't resist a sale on the Panasonic from Amazon for $50. It is a couple of years old and still going strong and it fits my hand very well. FWIW, I've always heard good things about the Makita line and their impact drivers are getting good reviews. Too many choices, too many choices...! Good luck.

Jim

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

#10

Go To The Store

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>and try out the various drills for balance. Makita and DeWalt are both good brands, but you do want to be sure you'er comparing the same fruit. Each brand makes different "models" within the same line which will have varying amounts of torque and speed. Then pick the one that will suit your use and hand (and wallet) the best.

f/i you may want higher rpm and less torque if this used for drilling holes to say 5/8" and the occasional screw, but if you're planning on running 1-1/4 spade or forstner bits, a bit less speed to get lots more torque may be your best choice. Of course, the "tool-of-year" is the impact driver and has relegated drills to making holes in things.

I have a 14v DeWalt and a 12v Rigid. The DeWalt gets very little use except for screw driving "sessions" (decks / rock) or putting large holes in joists. I do, however, have an Hitachi 18v impact driver on the Christmas list, which will just about put the DeWalt on Craig's List.

Have fun at the Toy Store! |;-}}}}

mm

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

#11

Re: Lifetime battery replacement was the clincher

Larry Clinton

>for me. I have a 12V cordless Dewalt drill that is still working but with reduced battery life. I also have one Bosch with dead batteries and just gave away a Craftsman Industrial with dead batteries. I did a lot of research - ended up with a Ridgid 12V cordless drill and 14.4 Volt Ridgid impact driver. I bought and registered these in my son's name as he will inherit my shop and tools. These are registered for the lifetime service agreement so tools and batteries will be repaired / replaced for his lifetime. As this is the fifth or sixth time I have replaced cordless drills with new ones due to worn out batteries, I really value the lifetime service agreement. I do like the Ridgid tools, as least as well as the Dewalt, Makita, and Bosch I have used and owned. I personally like the 12V for shop use, they are lighter and easier to to use IMHO. They have plenty of power for 95% of the tasks I do in the shop. On the few occasions when I need more power or am going to use the drill for extended time (over 1/2 hour of continuous running), I use my Drill press or tailed Porter cable and Makita drills. It is a pain and takes several months to register the Ridgid tools for the lifetime deal, I am glad I went this route. I made inquiries at the Ridgid web site and was told the extra batteries (extended life) I purchased would not be covered with the life replacement, only those that came with the tool. But when the online registration (ebox) was completed - they listed all the batteries and tools.

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

#12

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

Robin Corell, in Atascadero CA

>in almost every review I have read the Panasonic continues to be rated at or near the top. this is no small feat as the 15.6v drill is usually thrown in with the 18v drills in most reviews. I have large hands and was resistant to the idea of a 'T' handle drill. The Panasonic is odd in that it fits my hand very well vet it is one of the smallest drills in its class when measured from chuck to the end. This is greatly appriciated whn working in cramped area. The 15.6v Panasonic also comes with a 1/2" chuck and enough power to drive any screws I have needed as well as drill any hole I have asked it to. As others have said the achillies heel is always the batteries. Panasonic makes some of the best bateries on the market in NiMH, don't know how their LiIon bateries rate but would look into it if I were in the market fr a new drill.

Robin

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

#13

I have the Makita Li-ion

Garrett in Victoria

>18 volt drill. I purchased the combo with the hex impact driver several months ago. I also recently bought a new Ridgid 18v Ni-cad "compact" drill, and already have a Makita 12v and 14.4v. The power and battery life of the Makita Li-ion are multiples of the older Ni-cad technology. However, both the Makita and Ridgid 18v drills are big and heavy, and not so convenient to use as the smaller Makitas.

I believe Makita now has a lighter-duty, less expensive Li-ion line on the market, identifiable by its black and white colours. It would probably be an excellent choice, and I'm a big fan of Makita tools.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

#14

I'm done with Nickel

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I'm done with Nickel batteries. I have 4 drills ranging from 9.6-12V. (2 DeWalt, 1 Makita and 1 Panasonic) I have 11 batteries, all NiCd and NiMH. NONE of them can keep a charge worth a darn. They did when they were new, but after a couple of years they didn't. I brought new drills because it was cheaper than buying batteries alone. Those new batteries lasted even less time.

I even tried the deep freeze trick, which DID work, for about a month. Now they can't hold a charge for a few minutes.

So I'm DONE with these stupid money pit batteries. I haven't used a Lithium battery drill yet, but I know that my cell phone came with NiMH battery and used to last 12-14 hours, and I bought Lithium battery and the same phone can last up to 72 hours.

So my next drill will definitely be a Lithum-Ion powered tool.

Can't be any worse that I've got now.

All 4 drills were fantastic, however... just the battery issue.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

#15

Black & White

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I held that new black & white Makita at HD two days ago. IT's very nice. My Makita is an older 9.6V but small lightweight and very usable. THis new one is a bit heavier but it still reminds me of the small Makita I have.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

#16

Rant, Rant, Rant ........

Barry Irby

>I did the same thing, bought new drills to get new batteries. One had NiCad and he other NMh. They work for a while but not long enough.

Had them rebuilt and now I am suspicious that some of them are crapping out again and they don't have fifty cycles on them. (I need to label them and make notes, they look suspiciously alike, and its hard to keep from getting them mixed up.)

Bought a cell phone with a Lion battery. Turns out it was 11 months old on the shelf. Six weeks later, the battery crapped and they said, "Oh, Your battery is over a year old and it only had a one year warranty." Duefass just looked at me for a couple of minutes and gave me the battery they used in the store and had the factory send me a new one. I think he probably did not want to die at work that day. The battery they sent me appears identical to the one I had but the phone won't accept it. (Some message to that effect on the screen, Great, now it has "issues".)

I talked to the people selling a hybrid car. ME "Doesn't replacing the batteries cost more than all the gasoline saved?" THEM "This is not about saving money, it's about saving gasoline."

Yesterday on the Today Show they had an all electric car that was the second fastest production car in the world. 0 to 60 in three seconds. $200,000 Fantastic. Let me see it do it when a few of those cells start to crap out. They commented the cost of electricity to charge it was equivalent to about $2.00-2.50 a gallon of gas. Did not comment on the cost of a new battery pack.

We REALLY need some better batteries.

Rant off. But you won't be seeing me in a hybrid car soon.

Re: Time for a new cordless drill

#17

Re: Rant, Rant, Rant ........

Jim Dillon

>Barry,

Although my wife and I sometimes think about getting a Prius, and some of my friends have them and like them a lot, here is the problem for me to get around. We always keep ours cars 200K+ miles. I think I read somewhere that the batteries on the Prius are good for 150K miles, which is pretty amazing in itself, but I digress. So, if the replacement costs of a drill battery roughly equal the cost of a new drill, does the same thing hold for a Prius? Maybe someone can give me a real number on the battery life/replacement cost in these hybrid cars to think about. If what I remember reading is true, then there are going to a lot of hybrid car battries to safely dispose of in the coming years. I don't follow car stuff very much so maybe there is a solution to the problem. Yeah, I know, trade the car in before the battery goes belly-up 8-).

Jim