Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Air Compressor tank leaks

Posts

Air Compressor tank leaks

#1

Air Compressor tank leaks

Andy Lincoln,In Dearborn MI

>Hi All,

My CH 20 gal cast iron compressor tank has developed a rust-through pin hole leak in the bottom of the tank.I'll bet the guy who was supposed to drain the tank after each use didn't live up to the maintenance agreement:-)!! I power down the compressor after each session and the air slowly leaks out of the bottom. I am wondering if there is a fix for this like drilling a rubber washered screw into the pin hole?brazing the hole in the tank?JB weld the tank?Replace the tank?Reline the tank?Buy a nice upright that takes up less sq ft?

Thanks in Advance ,

Andy

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#2

I have done that

Dustmaker Mike

>I fixed it with JB Weld. I dried it really well drilled a little bigger hole and cleaned the area around the inside and out side with a small file then used JB weld to plug the hole. The nail compressor tank I did it to still hold air and I have not had any problems since I did this 8 or 9 years ago. True I do not use it much right now but I did once.

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#3

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

Bill Howatt

>If it were mine, I would replace the tank if possible. A pinhole in the tank means that it most likely has rusted considerably and this would make me think that it is possibly unsafe.

Bill

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#4

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

Ronald

>a good welder could fix you right up.

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#5

Second that - Replace that tank!

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>One pinhole means that the tank has weakened, and you don't know where else it is weak. If that thing blows up, you don't want to be around...

A few hundred dollars are nothing, especially when spread over many years.

Don't take chances...

DC

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#6

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

Howard Norman

>As Dustmaker Mike has said you can probable make a temporary repair with JB weld. However, it may last a day or it may last five years. If it was me I would probable try a temporary fix and start looking for a replacement tank. Just my 2 cents worth.

Howard

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#7

Re: Second that - Replace that tank!

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Andy,

I have to side with Denis! If it's weak in one spot due to rust, it's got to be weak in many others unforeseen. Look at a rusted out car or pickup. Is it rusting in just one spot? Maybe, but I'd bet a dollar to a donut that under the paint somewhere else it's rusty, too! Case in point- I spent a wad of money last year getting my pickup repainted. I told the bodyshop to leave no stone unturned looking for rust and fixing it. This spring we found several places that are starting to rust, even after they painstakingly went to extremes to prevent it. This is not a fly-by-night body shop, either!

PLEASE, replace the tank, buy a new compressor, whatever! Don't take the chance that it could explode!

Ron in Iowa

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#8

Forget The "Fix" *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>The pinhole is just the first of many. Either buy a new tank (ASME Rated ONLY) or can the whole rig for new. A good 20gal "rated" tank will run you about $230 [see Grainger.com for examples].

Whether you replace the tank or the whole thing, I strongly recommend you put an auto-drain valve on it. They are simple air-operated fittings that vent the condensate when a change of more than 10psi occures. Cost about $50 at McMaster-Car - Part #4919K13, and replace the existing petcock. See the link.

mm

PS: Your tank's not going to explode. The leaks will just get worse and your pump will have to work harder.


McMaster

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#9

What not to do

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>It's really tempting to look at that pinhole leek and think... a sheet metal screw will go right in there....

Don't, when it comes out it's like a bullet.

Bill who will swear on a stack of flapjacks that he never did this.

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#10

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

Jerry Nicholson

>About 30 years ago my father-in-law fixed the leak in his compressor tank with a self tapping screw. Fortunately, he wasn't in the garage when when the tank blew up a few weeks later. Replace it - I don't know what the tank will cost but a coffin and funeral service would probably exceed $8000.

Jerry

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#11

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

Stuart Hough

>I like his last option...take this as an excuse to buy a new compressor. No wife in the land will be able to refuse his attempt to enhance safety in the shop!

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#12

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

JohnKJordan in East TN

>I strongly agree with those who recommend replacing the tank. At one time I worked where we tested pressurized vessels. Tanks tested with compressed air or gas were first placed in a sunken bunker with heavy steel plates over the top. The explosive rupture of a tank filled with pressurized gas can be hazordous or deadly, even at 100 psi, and the bigger the tank the more energy involved. A pinhole leak is an indication of wider corrosion that may go at any time.

I don't know what other's do about draining, but for my air compressor mounted in a remote (quieter) location, I left the drain valve cranked open a tiny bit. It would drain every time I used it at the disadvantage of having to repressurize before use each morning.

JKJ

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#13

Re: Drain

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>John,

See my post above with the link. You're wasting bunches of energy repressurizing that receiver all the time. The mechanical auto-drain I mentioned works very vell. I've had mine installed for 4 years and I'm sure it has paid for itself several times over in electricity savings, not to mention my time to go out and manually drain the condensate every 3-4 days.

mm

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#14

Re: Drain

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Thanks, I'll look into the auto drain when I set up my new shop.

JKJ

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#15

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

Pete in Holland, MI

>No good welder with a good reputation will ever weld on a pressure vessel due to the risk his repair coming back to haunt him if/when the tank does eventually let loose.

This is stored energy that must be contained. It is very dangerous and must be treated with respect. If the rope that the large safe that is hovering over your head started to fray, would you wrap some duct tape on the rope, or replace it? You can see the energy in the safe. It isn't easy for most people to envision the energy in an air tank unless they've witnessed the aftermath of an explosion.

Replace it.

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#16

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

yuchol

>I have a Husky 80 gallon 2 state compressor that started leaking (found a pinhole) about 2 years into service. It is located at a welded joint on the upper half of the tank. I keep telling myself I will weld it but it's been that way for 2 years now. Maybe I should fix it now.....

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#17

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

Jerry Klug

>Air tanks with a "pin hole" can and DO EXPLODE. I am a National Board, Boiler and Pressure Vessel Inspector. I check boilers and air tanks 40 hours a week. I have seen whole sides of commercial buildings blown off by a ruptured air tank. One pin hole is not dangerous. A seried of thin spots near each other and indicated by a pin hole, can "zipper" and the rupture can be fatle to anyone within a pretty good radius. That kennetic energy is amazing. Here in Oregon and many states that have adopted the National Board Inspection Code, it is illegal for any old welder to strike an arc on a pressure vessel. Only trained and licensed welders can do that. The welder that does repair a pressure vessel without proper certifications and inspections is not only liable for any future accident caused by incorrect welding methods but he will also get a fine from the state of $10,000 and may be barred from practicing his trade for 3 years. Tough penalyies because loss of life is the possibility of the welders error.

If you have a worn tank, check if there is a State of Municipal inspection program. I have checked many tanks at the request of their owners. It only takes a few minutes to use an ultrasonic thickness meter to verify the condition of the tank. Oregon requires all pressure vessels designed to exceed 150 psi and used in a commercial setting to be permitted. We inspect literally thousands each year.

As far as an automatic drain is concerned, they are great but, if you dont feel youcan afford one, simply change out the petcock for a street ell, a short pipe nipple and a ball valve. The nipple should be long enough to position the valve outside the skirt of the vessel (if it is a vertical tank). Ease of access to the drain simplifies frequent draining the condensed water. In a dry climate (I live in the high desert of OR) the tank should be drained weekly. Costal or humid locations may require draining daily or with each use. I have one tank I periodically inspect that was build in 1908 and it is still in great shape. The shop it is in has been in the same family for 4 generations and they drain it each day.

Please do your self and your neighbors and replace that leaky tank if you cannot verify that the pin hole is an isolated flaw. Life is too valuable to risk for a couple hundred dollars worth of steel.

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#18

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>God Morning Jerry,

Since you seem to be responding to my post re a potential explosion, I'll thank you for the information, as I'm always happy when those with superior knowledge and experience correct my comments. My post was based upon conversations I've had with several knowledgeable people, in person and on this and other forums, to the effect that rust-through on low pressure air vessels (up to 160psi) is not a cause for catastrophic failure because the metal fatigues gradually and usually over a broad surface area. I was also told that such receivers can rupture explosively, but that it takes either a combination of weld-seam failure and impact, or overpressurization (requiring failure or intentional defeating of the unloader and safeties) to cause it.

My auto-drain keeps my receiver dry although I do check the weld lines once or twice a year. I keep my system at working pressure (175psi ASME-rated tank at 145psi max), and change the compressor oil once a year. Is there anything else I should be doing?

Thanks

mm

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#19

Oops

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>That would be "GOOD" morning. We can leave Him out of this. |;-}}}

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#20

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

Jerry Klug

>Hello Mark,

There are a couple of things that are good safety practices with any air tank that the owner can do besides making sure that the accumulated condensed water is frequently drained. One is to manually lift the relief valve once a year to assure its stem is free and operable. The ASME recommends that manual testing of a relieving device be done when the pressure on the safety valve is 70% of the set pressure. Most air tanks are either 150 psi or 200 psi designed vessels. The set pressure is stamped into the body os the relief valve. TO meet the ASME recommendations, the tank should be at 105 psi or higher for testing a 150 psi valve or 140 psi for the 200 psi valve. The reason for this recommendation is that the valve is intended to "pop" open and fully clear the seat of any scale or grit. A partial lift can and often does trap particles when the valve reseats and this damages the seal at the valve seat. You will know if this happens as you can hear the sound of air leaking through the valve. The next activity is to replace the valve.

One additional thing that can greatly lengthen the life of an air tank is to have some flexability in the hook up to the tank. If a tank is hard piped to an air system of a manifold, the vibration of the pump is magnified at the weld of the tank outlet. For a shop system that uses a typical air hose for the only air source, this is no problem. If, however you have hard piped a system to allow convenient air hook ups at various tools or across a work bench, this piping may be rigid enough to cause stress at the tank's outlet weld that could lead to a weld crack. The easy fix is to have a short flexible hose between the tank and the manifold hard piping. For larger commercial shop settings, I often see a braided stainless steel hose about 12 to 18 inches long. These typically come from truck or heavy equipment repair suppliers.

If moisture is a problem in the delivered air as is often a problem when painting, there is an inexpensive alternative to costly dryers. Run a galvanized pipe to the celing and zig-zag back down the wall using elbows and nearly horizontal piping. The pitch only has to allow the condensated water to drain to a low point vertical leg with a drain valve. Above the dead leg drain you tee off to a filter/regulator and on to your normal system. The length of piping cools the compressed air and allows the moisture to condense and flow to the dead leg.

Most woodworkers don't live and breath thoughts on air compressors but keeping one dry, having a properly working safety valve and watching out for unwanted stresses will keep the tank working longer than we are.

Re: Air Compressor tank leaks

#21

Thanks

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>My system is hard-piped in type L copper with siver-bearing solder with a 3' jumper hose between the tank and piping system.

My air stations are all piped on a loop with a drain as shown, and those drains are vented regularly. My line air is reasonably dry and clean.

Thanks for the tip on the safety valve check; confess I never did it, but will this evening. Simple enough to test and check. I would assume that a little spray of soapy water after the test to satisfy to check for a proper reseal of the valve?

mm


img