Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Shellac

Posts

Shellac

#1

Shellac

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>What does it seal, and why does it need sealing?

Clint

Re: Shellac

#2

Re: Shellac

Bill Howatt

>Shellac is more than just a sealer and is a fine finish although it its water resistance is poor.

For sealing the shellac is usually mixed thinner - alchohol is used as a thinner and is also what the shellac flakes are dissolved in. It will soak into wild grain or end-grain so it doesn't absorb as much stain resulting in a more even color. It is also used to seal the resinous knots in boards like pine before painting or applying an opaque stain. This eliminates or strongly reduces the bleed-through.

Bill

Re: Shellac

#3

Re: Shellac

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>One more point, shellac is the best moisture barrier of all finishes. The poor water resistance applies to waxed shellac, shellac that has been dewaxed has actually pretty good water resistance.

DC

Re: Shellac

#4

Re: Shellac

Larry Clinton

>Clint, I'm not an expert or pro but have used a lot of shellac, actually it is not as prone to water damage as everyone seems to believe. As far as a "sealer" - shellac will adhere very well to almost anything (I think you could seal a grease ball), and most other finishes will adhere to shellac. It provides an excellent barrier to stains on painted surfaces, preventing bleed through. It also provides a barrier coat for stains and dyes preventing bleed into subsequent coats of finish. It is the primary component in many "primers". It will also deter or prevent pine sap from bleeding through finishes. IMHO it is also a pretty darn good general purpose finish. Although not as durable as Alkyloid (sic) varnishes or Urethane / Polyurethane coatings, it is extremely easy to touch up or restore. Many of the older (pre WW 2) homes had shellac coatings on all the woodwork and many hardwood floors. Seems to have held up pretty well. My son remodeled an old house, we replaced all the woodwork with white oak - window, door baseboard and ceiling trim - we finished it all with amber shellac. Much has been in service over a year now. In one Kitchen window over the sink many wet glasses etc have been set on the window sill - so far no staining or problems anywhere. (They have three active dogs and a couple grandchildren working on proving the durability of the finish).

Re: Shellac

#5

Thanks for the responses

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>The question was a bit tongue in cheek. Shellac has valid uses as a finish itself or bleed blocker or to even out a stain, but I challenge its use as a barrier between different finishes or as a "sanding sealer". I can't think of any combination of finishes that need to be separated to prevent interaction as long as the base finish is well cured. I think its use as a "sanding sealer" is totally irrelevant. Any top coat finish can be its own "sealer" and shellac only complicates the process and could cause other problems.

Clint

Re: Shellac

#6

Re: Shellac

Barry Irby

>I have just "discovered" shellac. I am amazed at how good it is and how little I know about it. I am trying to sort out the part that seems to be "ancient alchemy" from the useful part, but I have used it on several pieces and like it.

One thing not mentioned by the others is that it is excellent for finishing the interior of furniture. Inside drawers and other interior spaces, It is low and pleasant in odor and dries very quickly and what little odor is there goes away. I just did a chest of drawers that I finished the inside with lacquer, after months it still stinks of lacquer. Another piece I did since then, I did the interior with shellac and it is essentially odorless.) This is good on older pieces that stink from age and mold or whatever for sealing in the odor as well.

Re: Shellac

#7

Re: Shellac

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I think water borne poly floor finish like Varathane is a better choice for drawer interiors. Its fast, water white, tough, and non-reactive. In fact, the only use that I can think of for which said poly can't replace shellac is in French polish.

Clint

Re: Shellac

#8

Re: Some of us

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>have had nothing but pain in trying to use waterborne poly, particularly Varathane. We may be few, and it may be self-inflicted, but I've had challenges with the last two quarts I've tried.

Shellac, on the other hand, seems to be, for a hobbyist like me, resistant to total failures, and accepting of my own flaws. Cleaning up coats that didn't flow out well, or drips that appeared, or places where the color wasn't right - I can do all of that with shellac. Varathane thumbs it's nose at me.

Maybe it's the stack of kitchen doors in the shop right now that need to be sanded out. The rough finish of the last coat of Varathane has been a total disappointment. Shellac never did that. But I don't expect that shellac would have held up against my grandkids, either.

Re: Shellac

#9

Re: Some of us

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>All valid points. I've had issues with Varathane as well, especially with bubbling and drying rough because of that. My impression is that it behaves better under cool and humid conditions so that drying is retarded. I also try to tip it off before it really begins to set.

Re: shellac; it's a proven great finish for all the reasons you mention, but it's often used for unnecessary purposes.

Clint

Re: Shellac

#10

Re: Thanks for the responses

Larry Clinton

>Have to agree with you Clint, regarding its use as a "sanding sealer". However, I like the appearance of an amber or clear shellac better than the water borne poly finish (personal preference). I have used a lot of oil based (Minwax) poly as a wipe on finish (thinned greatly with various solvents). I personally like a thin finish where it is applicable - most of the items I make don't require the protection that require Formica or Poly finishes :~). Besides that, you sure can't repair or re-coat damaged poly like you can Shellac. I also still like the Qualalacq nitrocellulose lacquer and spray it quite a bit.

Re: Shellac

#11

Ok, since you asked (long)

Michael Dresdner

>Clint said: "I challenge its use as a barrier between different finishes or as a "sanding sealer". I can't think of any combination of finishes that need to be separated to prevent interaction as long as the base finish is well cured."

You are confusing two things, Clint; barrier coats and tie coats. Shellac is great for both, but they are very different.

One use as a barrier coat is to prevent bleeding of dyes, stains, oils, silicone, waxes, pitch and other contaminents. Shellac does well at that.

Another barrier coat usage is to prevent one finish from reacting with something below it. Acid catalyed finishes, for example, can alter the color of even dried alkaline dyes. Fortunately, most wood dyes are acidic, but not all, and I have been called in for troubleshooting on this problem on more than one ocassion. Another example is that some polyurethanes will react poorly when put over a finish that contains stearates, a very common additive in finishes for a variety of reasons. Again, shellac will separate the two. Another is as a shock absorber. For example, in some cases, fast drying finishes like lacquers (both solvent and waterbased) can cause cracking over old and brittle oil based coatings. A coat of dewaxed shellac will prevent that. These are a few, but I assure you there are other cases where a barrier coat does indeed prevent reactions between various finishing materials.

As a tie coat shellac is often used between disparate finishes, such as between oil based stains and waterbased topcoats. A tie coat is one that will adhere well to one surface and allow the other to adhere to it. While many modern waterbased formulations will adhere to many modern oil based stains or coatings, not all will. Shellac as tie coat will make any work with any other.

Another use for a tie coat is to adhere so a substrate that your finish of choice will not normally adhere to well. Shellac will stick to melamine, many plastics and vinyls, and even glass. All of these materials in one form or another are used as coatings, so they fall squarely into the realm of a barrier between finishes.

As for shellac as a sanding sealer, I don't personally find that it sands any easier than any other finish, and harder than some, so I happen to agree with you on that one. Personally, I have never in any of my writings called dewaxed shellac a sanding sealer, and I objected rather strenuously when Zinsser informed me that they intended to call SealCoat, their version of dewaxed shellac, a sanding sealer, though I did give my blessings to the term universal used on the label.