Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

dust colletion or air filters

Posts

dust colletion or air filters

#1

dust colletion or air filters

Rick Snyder

>Hello,

I will be building a new workshop next spring. It will be the size of a two car garage. I'm not sure whether to use a air filtration or dust collection system. I more interested in getting and keeping the finer dust off everything on a consistent basis. I'm not worried as much about table saw, planner,or router shavings that hit the floor. It's more about the finer dust. Any recommendations on either tool for the size of the shop.

Thanks in advance,

Rick

Re: dust colletion or air filters

#2

Yes and Yes *LINK*

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>They do two different things. The DC picks up chips and dust at the machines but the fine dust will go through most DC filters.

The air cleaner picks up dust from the air, the stuff that can get into your lungs. If the air cleaner has a good set of filters it collects much finer particles than the DC.

You should have both.

Check out Bill Pentz's site at the link. It has more than most want to get into about the subject.


Bill Pentz's dusty site.

Re: dust colletion or air filters

#3

You're going to need both

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>A dust collector will catch the wood chips and a percentage of the dust. There is a precentage of dust that is either too fine, or won't be sucked in to begin with and and air cleaner will help with that.

A good DC without an air cleaner will do a much better job than an air cleaner without a DC. So if you can't get both, get the DC first and the air cleaner later.

I would say a 1.5-2HP system rated at 1200-1500CFM would be about right. Not sure how those figures would be if you're talking about a cyclone. Because it sounds like you'll just going to be using 1 machine at a time, a 1200 would be fine. I think of a larger system in terms of being able to handle a less than perfect ducting layout, rather than multiple machines requiring DC at the same time.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: dust colletion or air filters

#4

I agree: yes and yes.

Forrest Addy

>You need dust collection for convenience of removing chips and dust as it's made and air filtration to remove the inevitable dust once its airborne.

New shop? From scratch? I suggest you consider higher than conventional ceilings for your shop. Anyone manipulating sheet goods and lumber does so with it's center of gravity at or above his own. An 8 ft ceiling is far too low; you'll be scraping it, marking up the sheet rock, and banging against the lights. I reccommend at least a 10 ft ceiling and I strongly suggest one that's 12 ft if you can get the structure height past the building department.

Your back will thank you meaning chiropractor will have to look for other sheep to shear to make payments on his Hummer.

Re: dust colletion or air filters

#5

Re: dust colletion or air filters

Tony - Memphis

>I use both in my small shop. I have a JDS 750 air cleaner and a Delta 850 dust collector. Before that, I used a ShopVac and a box fan with a filter over it! The new system works better! Even though I use a dust collector, my air cleaner picks up plenty. I added some fancy bags to the dust collector (Higland Hardware). Congrats on the new shop! Enjoy!

Tony

Re: dust colletion or air filters

#6

Re: dust colletion or air filters

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Rick,

I use both. In addition I have an exhaust fan to augment the JDS air filtration. When I get to making sawdust, the volume generated overwhelms the capability of my shop to instantly cleanse the air. Blowing some of it outdoors helps quite a bit.

George

Re: dust colletion or air filters

#7

Re: dust colletion or air filters

Rick Snyder

>A big thanks to all who responded to my post about dust collection. It has been a big help! I will buy both systems.

Thanks again, Rick