I design
JohnKJordan in East TN
>MikeS. wrote:
>I design these to be completely non functional items of art.
>A robot can make a functional spoon (literally),
>I try to stay away from things that can be made by robots.
This is angling off the "functional aspect" topic, but a comment on things made by machine...
An object nearly indistinguishable from Mike's non-functional spoon could be easily made by a robot, especially if we consider the simplest definition of �made� to be constructing the precise 3D shape and finish from some physical material.
I think it is important to remember that the "spoon" shown is not just the physical shape of the object, but our unique experience as we perceive that object as a whole with our senses: the form, tactile texture, grain/figure and color, chatoyance, smell, weight, balance, and perhaps others such as the sounds it makes when tapped in various places.
While the form could be duplicated precisely by the robot, the whole required Mike's creative and discerning mind combined with a certain amount of what might be called "fortune", e.g., how hidden wood figure is revealed during the crafting and how that revealing might have guided the process. The use of clever technology might even duplicate some or all of the other aspects of the original such that it might be difficult to tell the copy from the original. Either way, the machine-made result might still be considered "Mike�s spoon", regardless of art or function, and whether he authorized the copy or not.
I�d also like to comment on aspects of functional vs non-functional and the age-old questions of art/craft and ownership of variations of the original, either machine or hand-made, but I don�t have time at the moment - I have to go see a man about a horse (literally :)
JKJ