Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Curly maple spoon

Posts

Curly maple spoon

#1

Curly maple spoon 

Mik eSchwing from Maryland

>This is the first work I've done in about 2 years due to too many things to tell! Actually this is the first work I'm willing to post as it took a few tries to get my groove back.

This is a curly maple spoon, about 15" long, hand carved with a variety of tools. Sprayed with an alcohol based dye, then lacquered and finally hand rubbed to a pleasing sheen. For display only! It does, by design, stand on its own in the orientation displayed in the photo.

Comments welcomed.


img

Re: Curly maple spoon

#2

Ellis Walentine

Functionality

Ellis Walentine

>Mike, that is one gorgeous spoon! I'd like to prime the pump here, though, and question you about functionality as a component of design. I love sculpture (and your spoon certainly qualifies handsomely in that department) but, to me, the notion of a spoon has a functional aspect as well.

I have the same compunctions when I view some of the art furniture that is so compelling visually but also non-functional. Can we open this question to debate here?

Ellis

Re: Curly maple spoon

#3

Re: Functionality

Joe Burke

>I can't see stirring the hash browns with that. It's just too pretty a piece of work. Of course, I'm betting someone would stir the hash browns with it ....

.... not that there's anything wrong with that.

I suppose that's the point.

Re: Curly maple spoon

#4

Re: Functionality / debate

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Of course Ellis, and thanks for the compliment. I design these to be completely non functional items of art. A robot can make a functional spoon (literally), I try to stay away from things that can be made by robots. When I started selling these before my woodworking "break", I found an inverse relationship between degree of functionality and price fetched. In other words, the less utility it had, the higher the sale price. A fellow carver I speak to over the internet who has been doing this for 20 years has had to alter his business because there's now a spoon guy making very nice functional/almost decorative spoons on his CNC machine, and he's EVERYWHERE. There is no way to compete with his prices, so my friend has abandoned his functional spoon making almost completely.

It appears that at least locally, there is no one else doing anything even remotely close to this. Whenever I take them to an appropriate gallery or high end crafts shop, they want my demo units immediately. You well know that a secret to success is having something unique, done well. I've got one part down.

My wife has a kitchen full of my "practice runs". She has the fanciest utility spoon collection in town.

I guess I just don't want to create things that won't fetch at least a few hundred dollars a piece. Should folks create spoons with no utility? I dunno, but if they buy them, I don't much care!

Re: Curly maple spoon

#5

Steven Antonucci

As another occasional spoonmaker...

steve antonucci

>I understand your question and kind of agree...

I've made some pretty spoons, but I always think that at a certain level, there a point of no return when something stops being a spoon and becomes something else. My functional bowls only get sanded to 220G, same for cutting boards- because I want to encourage use.

I've seen some woodturners that make very pretty spinning tops, almost too pretty to play with. Something about my practical side that doesn't allow me to make "impractical" practical objects. If I owned this spoon, I couldn't place it in the kitchen, for fear that someone might accidentally mistake it for a "user".

Good question.

Steven

P.S. Nice to have you back in the "schwing" of things, Mike...

Re: Curly maple spoon

#6

Re: Functionality

Barry Irby

>This is an interesting conversation. I agree with Mike that it appears people will pay more for art than utility. I also agree with Steve that at least in my case, my engineering brain insists on some sort of utility. Part of me does not care if they are "foolish enough" to pay $200 for a beautiful but non functional spoon but part of me want the spoon to have some utility. I guess I am still seeking that sort of crossover item that is too beautiful to use, but you could. This could also explain my lack of success in local galleries.

Several years ago I had a bunch of bowl blanks that were mostly cores out of larger bowles. I finished about thirty of them and gave them to Realtors to promote my Home Inspection service. One of them got a 6" by 2" one of spalted maple. Later he asked if I had another like it, so I gave him a similar one. That one made him angry. Turns out he was letting his kids eat their cereal out of them every morning and they had been arguing over who got the neat bowl. So the second bowl was supposed to reduce family discord. Turns out (no pun intended) the second bowl came out of a wormy blank and it leaked. Could have knocked me over with a feather. They were EATING out of MY ART? Whodathunkit? Not only that, the second bowl with the holes offended him so badly, I have not heard from him since.

Re: Curly maple spoon

#7

Can't bring myself to make something

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>that isn't functional. Forty years of being on the wrong side of the fence, tooling (functional) vs product (eye appeal) and all my outside influences have demanded function only. I've made a couple of pieces that were requested to be sort of attractive but still they had to have some function. I have some non functional designs floating through my head but they will never be built, just can't get excited about them. I can design and visualize them but I don't want to build them. I have two sisters who are very artsy, one a painter and the other a quilter. I'll keep to making quilt racks and picture frames.

Ray

Re: Curly maple spoon

#8

Re: Functionality

Frank House

>Perhaps we are taking too restricted a view of "function".

Giving pleasure by looking good is a valid function. Reminding viewers of an activity can enhance that.

Consider armour (armor) and weapons displayed in a domestic setting -- wouldn't want the guests to start using an old sword if the cook forgot to bring a carving knife to the table! (Or worse, an old flintlock if the steak was burned).

Frank.

Re: Curly maple spoon

#9

I design

JohnKJordan in East TN

>MikeS. wrote:

>I design these to be completely non functional items of art.

>A robot can make a functional spoon (literally),

>I try to stay away from things that can be made by robots.


This is angling off the "functional aspect" topic, but a comment on things made by machine...

An object nearly indistinguishable from Mike's non-functional spoon could be easily made by a robot, especially if we consider the simplest definition of �made� to be constructing the precise 3D shape and finish from some physical material.

I think it is important to remember that the "spoon" shown is not just the physical shape of the object, but our unique experience as we perceive that object as a whole with our senses: the form, tactile texture, grain/figure and color, chatoyance, smell, weight, balance, and perhaps others such as the sounds it makes when tapped in various places.

While the form could be duplicated precisely by the robot, the whole required Mike's creative and discerning mind combined with a certain amount of what might be called "fortune", e.g., how hidden wood figure is revealed during the crafting and how that revealing might have guided the process. The use of clever technology might even duplicate some or all of the other aspects of the original such that it might be difficult to tell the copy from the original. Either way, the machine-made result might still be considered "Mike�s spoon", regardless of art or function, and whether he authorized the copy or not.

I�d also like to comment on aspects of functional vs non-functional and the age-old questions of art/craft and ownership of variations of the original, either machine or hand-made, but I don�t have time at the moment - I have to go see a man about a horse (literally :)

JKJ