Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Anyone get woodworking mags?

Posts

Anyone get woodworking mags?

#1

Anyone get woodworking mags?

Dan Mitchell

>I've been thinking about subscribing to one of the woodworking magazines. I know there are several, American Woodworker, Fine Woodworking, Popular Woodworking, ShopNotes, Wood, Woodcraft, and Woodworking, to name a few. I'm wondering if one or a couple really stand out. What do people here read?

TIA

Dan

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

#2

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I subscribe to Pop. Wood, buy FWW and Woodwork (should subscribe too, would be less expensive). I stopped looking at AWW a few years ago, and I buy Wood on an issue-by issue basis, usually their tool reviews are good. If there's something of interest to me in ShopNotes I'll buy the issue.

As for Woodworking, it doesn't stir my juices for some reason.

DC

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

#3

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

Thomas S Stockton

>I like Woodwork, Woodshop news and Fww. I think you should buy copies of each or browse them at your local book store and see what fits you.

Some are more project oriented than others and some tend to be more arty.

I like woodwork because their feature areticle is always on a different craftsperson every month. Woodshop news is the same way it is nice to see the people behind the furniture,

Fww is pretty consitantly good and has projects that are a cut above, what I don't like is that they tend to repeat articles every 5 years or so. They used to be the go to magazine but I think they have been in cruise control for the last decade.

Can't really help if you're looking for project oreinted magazines, it's just not something I'm interested in.

Tom

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

#4

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

john lucas

>Dan I get them all so it depends on what you are looking for. Woodwork tends to have the really deep philosophical type articles with high end reproduction work and really great how to articles on techniques or they might discuss the history of Queen Ann furniture. Fine Woodworking has a little of the same but probably not as much philosophy and Art. These two are for the serious woodworker, furniture maker sort of personality. Someone who feels comfortable with a handplane or table saw.

American Woodworker probably falls between these two categories in that they usually have some great projects but also might have an indepth article on a professional woodworker, or tool factory.

Wood magazine, Popular woodworking, workbench and Woodsmith tend to be more project oriented and probaby fit your average woodworker better. These are probably more for the Norm �brams kind of woodworking.

Shopnotes is just a nice thing to get if you like building gadgetry and fixing up your shop. They have a lot of good projects some of which are quite imaginative.

Each one of these is likely to have a very good article on comparing miter gauges, or table saws or trueing a hand plane. My favorites tend to be Wood magazine and Fine Woodworking.

Now if your into woodturning There are American Woodturner, Woodturning Design, More Woodturning and I also get Wooturner out of England. American Woodturner is sort of the Fine woodworking of turning. Woodturning design is excellent but probably more like Wood magazine. More Woodturning is a newspaper type of magazine and the articles vary a lot.

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

#5

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>I've cut way down on subscript's. Popular Woodworking continues to improve (they just need to quit with the multi-page centerfold ads that end up destroying the magazine when they're taken out) and I find that in general their content grows whereas that of other magazines tends to stays the same or in some cases, actually seems to "immature". FWW is falling into this last category - they have some good projects, but more and more they seem to be a "me too" magazine with projects that are "been there done that".

Two of my other favorite mags are Fine Homebuilding (another Taunton publication) and Wooden Boat Magazine. Both of these are more "applied woodworking", but you tend to get "how-to" articles written by folks who are fed up with other "how to" articles. As such, they tend to be a bit rougher, but more "real life" and relevant.

As for the rest, they all have the odd good article and many of them make it to my coffee table, but I browse the newsstand for them now - it's better that way.

Rob

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

#6

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Dan,

I agree with what has been said above. At one time or another, I've subscribed to most of them. Currently I am with Pop Woodworking and Shop Notes. I'd buy others from time to time at HD if they had something of interest beyond my experience level. The older AWW and FWW, published in the black and white days are superior in content. If you can ever get hold of back issues in the '80's, do so. They are superior.

George

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

#7

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>FWW, Pop Wood, and Woodsmith. I agree with what the others said. I prefer PopWood to FWW, just because.

If you don't have a lot of WWing experience and would like ideas for projects, basic skills and measurements, it's hard to beat Woodsmith.

Bruce

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

#8

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for the replies. I've looked at Woodsmith, Shopnotes, Popular Woodworking, Fine Woodworking & American Woodworker, quite a few full text pdf's of which can be found on the binary newsgroup alt.e-book.technical (along with literally thousands of other books, journals, magazines etc. on woodworking & every other topic imaginable) and last week when I was at Rockler, they had some back issues of Woodworker's Journal for a buck each. As everyone has said, they all seem to have their good points. Being fairly new at this, the project/instruction/shop oriented ones seem most appropriate right now.

Dan

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

#9

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>I get the most read time from Pop WW and Fine WW these days. I also subscribe to Wood, which has good tool reviews, but the rest of the content can be a little to beginner-ish for me anymore. I really enjoyed it a few years ago along with ShopNotes. ShopNotes can be pretty cool, but it can also be ridiculous. Some of the jigs they make are waaaay too complicated for the task they are used for. Others are very good and you can get some interesting ideas.

Jay

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

#10

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

Jim Dillon

>Dan,

You're going through what lots of us did. There is no right answer, but a lot depends on your skill level at the time you are reading these mags. When I started out 12 years ago, the projects in FWW were only a dream that I never thought I would be capable of. At that time, I was more a ShopNotes kind of guy and loved making those shop jigs/furniture (which have proven VERY useful). AWW and Wood were read from cover to cover, but no more. Woodsmith offers some very well-crafted functional pieces to learn skills on and produce a nice piece of furniture for your home that you can be proud of; I wish I had subscribed to it earlier. Now, I subscribe to Popular Woodworking and FWW. Sometime, I pick up an issue of Woodwork, but its pictures are getting too small for my eyes and it is pretty artsy; its interviews are nice though. Despite its ups and downs, I think FWW still covers a broad base and I find myself going back over old issues for new ideas as my skills improve. I like its new "Master Class" feature as it gives me something to strive for. In summary, read all you can, subscribe to what you can afford, and freely change direction as your skills grow.

Jim

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

#11

I just let Popww expire

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>I'll keep FWW for now but may let that one expire too. After a few years subscription they all start to repeat themselves it seems.

FWW has, in my opinion, the best website out there. If you join (pay) there is a TON of information there. Old articles, videos, and so on.

FWW's website is a great resource (in addition to WC of course...).

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

#12

Re: Anyone get woodworking mags?

Bill Howatt

>Which magazines are good, better or best is very personal. Depends on your skill level and what you are interested in. I consider FWW to be one of the best and their articles are quite educational and more than superficial.

I actually have dumped virtually all of my magazine subscriptions because I now have more interest in turning (I do get Turning Design). I never build anything from plans as I preferred to make my own plans and I never got real deep into fine furniture. After you've read them a while you get the feeling of same old, same old.

I consider the internet to be a far better resource than any magazine and generally easier to find something. IMO, nothing more useless than a big pile of magazines and thinking that somewhere in the big pile there is an article you remember about something. Easier to Google the topic.

Bill