Sycamore Table
Stokes
>Finished sycamore table.
I am not certain I would repeat the base the same way; nevertheless, I think it works.
Please tell me what you think.
Stokes
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Sycamore Table
Stokes
>Finished sycamore table.
I am not certain I would repeat the base the same way; nevertheless, I think it works.
Please tell me what you think.
Stokes
Re: Sycamore Table 2
Stokes
>
Re: Sycamore Table 3
Stokes
>
Re: Sycamore Table 4
Stokes
>
Fantastic work!
Brian in Sandusky, OH
>
Re: Sycamore Table
steve - Denver
>I like how the top is "suspended" above the base. Your glue line on the top needs a little work, actually that adds an interesting touch. Very Nice!!
Re: Sycamore Table
steve - Denver
>Forgot to mention, GO ROCKIES!!!!
Re: I very much like it!
Glenn Madsen near San Francisco
>Especially the floating top, with the live edges facing each other. I saw some similar work in an older article recently, focusing on handling wood movement, and sort of resolved to try this myself. There is some nice walnut waiting for a similar treatment.
Did you give any thought to perhaps designing in some sort of softer curvature in the base? Maybe it would tone down the starkness a bit. But load it up with Sunday dinner plates and glasses, and it will be superb the way it is.
Is this for your home, or elsewhere?
Re: Sycamore Table
Jim Dillon
>Stokes,
Gorgeous top and the gap between the two boards really adds interest. Yeah, I would have made the leg structure less wide - they seem to stick out a bit. And somehow I wuld have carried the chamfer on the tabletop edge to the legs in some way. But that is nitpicking; it is a really nice table that I would be proud to sit at. Thanks for posting.
Jim
Re: Sycamore Table
Jesper, Denmark
>I really like the idea and design, but there seems to be a disconnect between the crossmembers supporting the top and the legs. The legs also seem to be too heavy - maybe a taper or slightly smaller dimensions would make the table more elegant.
Love it!
John McGaw
>So when are you starting on the chairs? ;-)
Re: Sycamore Table
Barry Irby
>I really like it.
Don't worry about that crack down the middle, if your supper falls through it more that once or twice, you can always caulk it :).
My first thought on seeing it was that I would have champhered the ends of the cross members under the top with the same profile as the edge of the top. Just to make them hide under the edge a little more. (my knee cringed).
The engineering part of my brain wonders if it sways easily left to right?
My son and I are working on a table with a similar crack down the center. we have a frame and bread board ends. Our boards were too thin to take your approach or we would have been right there.
Great looking table, great use of the wood.
Re: Sycamore Table
Bill Schreiber, Litchfield, NH
>I like it! The base gives it an airy sort of Scandinavian maybe Japanese look to it. Very cool design. I am not sure the utility of the gap in the middle; my wife wouldn't go for that. Who cares though it looks great.
Regards,
Bill
Re: Sycamore Table
Rob Stokes in North Vancouver
>Love the top, but I agree - I think the base needs something, or perhaps needs to lose something. Couple of things that caught my eye and remember - this is constructive critisism!
1) The dimensions of the legs and stretchers (or maybe the proportions?) seem way too close to dimensional lumber.
2) the actual length of the stretchers should be shorter. The idea behind a floating top is to hide the support(s). If the ends of those stretchers were a couple of inches shorter (or if the taper was more pronounced and went to zero at the ends), the effect would be much greater.
3) I'd be afraid to skid the table across the floor - it just doesn't look "solid".
BUT - good on ya for taking it on and like I said, the top's awesome. If you were to do it again, what would you change?
Rob
Sycamore Table - Nice work !
Ray Carson, Lawrenceville NJ
>Hello Stokes,
Simple with a touch of elegance. Nice! I too thought of the knee banging into the 2x4 looking cross members. I guess you would get used to it.
The crack down the middle is a tough one to call. I personally like it because it's different. From a pratical stand point, there could be some commnets from SWMBO. Course, it's not my table. :-)
Love the wood, love the finish, like the overall design.
My 2 cents worth,
Ray
Re: Sycamore Table
Stokes
>Thank you all for your comments!
Funny thing is my 8 yo son said that if his 10 yo sister spills her drink he does not have to worry about it getting on his side of the table!
I am very aware of the sway factor that Barry and Rob brought up. It does sway more than I wish it did. That being said, the table is a balancing act between competing interests. I tried to maximize the top size without overwhelming the space. Part of that was a compromise from a trestle base to allow the person at the end of the table to put their legs between the base legs.
Barry, the design is based on a table that had breadboard ends with the sides affixed and the middle floating. It prevents the edge of the table from being unflush half the year.
Jim and Jesper, as for the cross members, I agree I should have chamfered the supports as well as worked more curvature into the legs to tie them to the top. Do you have a recommendation as to how to incorporate the curvature in the legs?
Rob, I was concerned with shortening the cross members too much since they are laid on their side, providing minimal vertical support. I will look tonight to see if I can shorten them and maintain the appropriate level of vertical support.
John, the chairs are in the design phase. Any suggestions on best style to match table?
If you have read this far, I really appreciate the candid feedback. That is exactly what I was looking for.
Regards,
Stokes
Re: Sycamore Table
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Reminds me of some Nakashima designs. The center NE adds some organic drama to a strongly geometric design, but I think it would be more effective if the gap were a touch wider. Then too, the table supports are too visable through the gap. I would have suggested lowering and darkening that support surface to reduce its visability through the gap. Might also go so far as to bridge the gap with contracting stitches like Nakashima did with his butterflies.
Have an issue with the placement of the outside table supports. They seem at odds with the leg sets so that visually I feel the "need" to either move them further away from the legs or shorten and center them over the leg stretchers.
Nice table. Now the chairs in the same style . . . |;-}}}
mm
Re: Sycamore Table
Jim Dillon
>Stokes,
I was afraid you were going to ask that question 8-). I guess I would carry the chamfer through to the outside edge of the legs, plus bring the legs back in a bit. But, hey, that is just me. Again, a gorgeous table and we look forward to seeing those chairs around Xmas time or so!!
Jim