Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

More RAS saw blade questions

Posts

More RAS saw blade questions

#1

More RAS saw blade questions

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi all,

Still looking around for the best deal on an RAS blade to use for cutting thick green wood. I already answered one of my own questions. The triple chip grind blades for plastics do not saw wood well at all. I thought the problem was alignment when the 12" blade that came with the saw didn't cut very well and burned the heck out of whatever wood I tried to cut.

I spent a couple of hours the other day adjusting the saw and I know that alignment is not the problem. My second thought was that the blade was just dirty and maybe a little dull so I spent an interesting couple of hours stoning the teeth with a diamond card sharpener, all 60 of them. It's clean as a whistle now and pretty darned sharp, but it still doesn't cut wood worth a hoot.

So, one of the blades I'm looking at is a Delta General Purpose blade #35-673 on ebay. It is 72 teeth, ATB grind but appears to have a positive hook angle. The catalogs that I have don't list that particular blade so I don't know what the hook angle actually is.

Any other blade suggestions would be appreciated. As mentioned, I'll be cross-cutting primarily green wood in 3" and 4" thicknesses and I want a blade that I won't have to fight with all the time. Also, the cut quality is not that important as long as the wood isn't burnt. Given the state of finances at the moment, closer to $100 is better than closer to $150. And I promise as soon as I can afford it, I'll buy a rip blade to use if I have to rip a cracked blank.

Thanks,

Gary

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

#2

Re: More RAS saw blade questions *LINK*

Keith Newton

>OK Gary, I can't believe I am sticking my toe back into these waters. The last time I tried to answer a question for you I feel like I was bludgeoned with a heavy blunt object, but here goes.

First, there is an equation which I am afraid I don't remember between hp / blade size/ and number of teeth in the cut for a given thickness. More teeth, on a larger diameter blade, in thicker wood obviously needs a lot more power. And it should be obvious that greater thickness would call for fewer teeth, with a deeper gullet to carry more chip load out.

One mistake that many overly-cautious sawyers make is sawing too slowly, and not utilizing whatever power is available to them. lots of newbies started with under-powered tools, and trained themselves to cut slowly, so-as to not overload their saws, so they waste power by feeding too slow.

The problem with this is that the blade is designed to take a chip of a respectable size so that the heat is carried away in the chip.

When you cheat the blade of this part, there will be more friction between the remaining wood and the teeth, which will essentially boil the moisture/ resins, which will condensate on the sides of the teeth, causing even more friction / heat, which will lead to quicker dulling than feeding faster would cause. Of course feeding faster means that you have to have the power to maintain blade speed, and proper chip size.

Part of the climbing problem is due to bogging down the motor, which means that by the time the operator realizes he needs to slow down, the blade is now taking a bigger chip than it can remove, and is starting to get more traction, and inclined to run to the end of its track. Maybe by deflexion or loose parts, but it seems less likely when there is plenty of power, than on smaller less powerful machines.

I am thinking fewer teeth might be better, but I just looked and found this

http://www.amazon.com/Delta-35-7659-General-Purpose-Circular/dp/B000O7YJ2O

for under $30, which I think should be a good place to start. If you feel like you need more power, then look for one with fewer teeth.

As for your ripping needs, I will leave that up to others to guide you there. Sorry I could not be more specific. It has been a long time since I studied some of what I was trying to briefly share with you above, and if I was off the mark with any of it, I hope there will be someone who will be willing to correct me.


http://www.amazon.com/Delta-35-7659-General-Purpose-Circular/dp/B000O7YJ2O

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

#3

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Thanks Keith,

I hadn't thought about amazon. I may give that one a try. I was looking at the same blade in Woodworker's Supply for about $90. I wasn't willing to experiment with a positive hook for that kind of money. For $30 it is pretty much a no brainer.

Thanks again. I didn't chime in, but I also thought you were handled less than politely in the other thread.

Gary

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

#4

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

JohnKJordan in East TN

>I was also thinking fewer teeth might be better for thick green wood, but have no experience with this. However, for cutting such wood with a bandsaw, 1.5 or 2 tpi is better than 4 so could the same logic apply to a circular blade? Some people grind off every other tooth on a bandsaw blade.

JKJ

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

#5

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

jmohnike

>Something Diff.

Try pushing the blade instead of pulling it. I have been told and read in several publications this is the correct way to use the RAS. I have had the same problems you mention and found that 90% was due to the pulling action of the blade and most of them corrected when I pushed the blade especially on thick or wet material.

Joe

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

#6

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

Charles M

>To Keith's point, the formula for determining the number of teeth is 3 to 5 teeth working when ripping and 5 to 7 for crosscuts. Let me know the thickness of the stock you are cutting and I'll try to match you to a blade.

Charles M

Freud America, Inc.

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

#7

I'm gonna disagree here..... *LINK*

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>I've also heard of pushing the RAS blade through the workpiece like they do in a SCMS. I can't see the logic in that. I've been using the same RAS since I bought it new in 77 and would never do that. Doesn't mean I'm right, just means I would not be comfortable with that approach.

The link below has some insight.


Woodweb article

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

#8

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I've had a RAS, Sears or Delta, since the mid-60's, using the push technique on heavy stock. It's much more controllable than trying to manage a climbing cut that wants to bog the motor and needs to be physically restrained. The disadvantage is loading new work when multiple cuts need to be made. Also, no special blade is needed.

I also have a Makita 10" and a Hitachi 12" SCMS, both of which want to bind and burn wide stock on a full depth push cut, which I attribute to the blade slightly forcing the piece into the wide gap in the fence during the last stage of the cut. I get much better cuts by starting with a push cut that only goes through about 2/3d's of the thickness, followed by a pull cut to finish.

Clint

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

#9

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Thanks, Charles,

I'm primarily crosscutting 3" and 4" thick green wood, though I may need to trim the occasional piece of 6". It would also be nice to have a dedicated rip blade too.

I don't need a surface suitable for glue up, but a lack of saw marks would be a good thing.

Gary

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

#10

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>I hadn't heard of that Joe, but I have done it on a SCMS, so it makes sense. As soon as I can get a blade, I'll give it a shot. Right now the triple chip blade is all I have and it just doesn't crosscut wood.

Thanks,

Gary

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

#11

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi John,

I think you are correct about the fewer teeth for thicker wood. The only reason I was looking at the 72 tooth Delta blade was the potential to get a good deal.

You know my budgetary issues.

Gary

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

#12

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

Mike Fitterling

>Hi Gary. I know you are looking for a blade for your RAS, but the more I think about green wood, the more I think it not the best application for any circular saw blade. Any reason why you cannot do that work on a bandsaw? Wet wood has some nasty ways of surprising you when you cut it. Just an idea.

Cheers,

Mike

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

#13

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Mike,

At the risk of offending somebody by talking about my business, I'll tell you why I'm cutting thick green wood on the RAS.

Basically what I'm doing is blocking out turning blanks. I'm having my logs sawed into 2", 3", 4" and thicker pieces by whatever the log will yield. Then I'm cutting them into square blanks. Consequently, it's much easier to lay a 50"x3"x10" cant on the CMS or the RAS and move the blade than it would be to run the same cant through the bandsaw. I know I cut shorten the cant to start with, but that is just one more step in the process. I'm trying to make the process as quick and simple and, hopefully, as profitable as possible.

Gary

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

#14

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

Mike Fitterling

>I see. Makes sense in that situation.

Good luck,

Mike

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

#15

Re: More RAS saw blade questions *LINK*

Charles M

>Gary,

You definitely want less than 50T for that thickness range. The Freud blade I recommend is the LU72M012. It's positive hook but I think you would have too much feed resistance and have a hard time clearing chips with a negative hook blade.

Are you ripping the same thicknesses?

Charles M

Freud America, Inc.


Freud LU72M012

Re: More RAS saw blade questions

#16

Dipping my toe gently…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Gary,

One of the things I mention to people inquiring about RASes in general and blades for them in particular, is that the concept of a negative hook angle and the idea of designed for RAS blade is a relatively recent phenomenon. The RAS is generally considered to have exploded in popularity (if not actual development) in the post war '40s and '50s. Of course Dewalt was king in those years (and beyond).

My RAS purchase (new) was in 1971, and although a Craftsman, is generally the same design and principle as the Dewallies. In those days, there was no such thing as a “RAS blade”. When you went to the store for a blade for your RAS you sorted through the same bin of blades as you would for a contractor or cabinet saw. In fact, the first time I ever heard of a reference to a blade “designed for a RAS” was when Forrest introduced their RAS model (perhaps as early as the '80s).

Naturally, the negative hook angle design does reduce the grab of the blade, but there is a price for that. It requires more power to work through the wood, and as Keith suggested, more is better in that regard.

One other thing hinted at in RAS discussions is technique. The negative hook blade certainly reduces the inclination of the blade to climb, but in truth, virtually every RAS user in its history, up until the advent of the negative hook angle blades, was able to master the technique needed to control the movement of the carriage. When you couple the need for transmitting maximum power to the cut with proper technique, the need for that negative hook blade begins to diminish.

So far as the technique mentioned earlier about pushing the saw through the work, I can't provide any empirical data to support my position, but I don't recall any of the materials available to me which recommended it, and to me it doesn't sound like a good idea. It would be sort of like setting up your work on the table saw and then going behind it to pull it through. Doesn't feel right. But, maybe it's a valid technique invented in just the last few years.

Rod