Re: Hey Rob, Do you earn your living with your sho
Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach
>> Hey Rob, Do you earn your living with your shop?
Is this the start of one of those if you aren't making a living doing blah, blah, blah, you can't possibly know what you're talking about rants?
> And maybe an even more important question would be if yes, do you ever have helpers?
Why, yes, it appears it is.
> You know there is a big difference between the work that some of the readers and posters on these forums do with their tools, and the amount of time one can spend on each task.
But please explain how that translates to any one particular tool being particularly dangerous at a particular task.
> So let me ask you. When you choose to rip lumber. Do you change to a rip blade each time, or do you use the cross-cut blade for everything. Ok, If you have a rip blade on, and need to crosscut, are you tempted to use the rip blade for just a few crosscuts.
No, I don't always change to a rip blade to rip, however if I do, I never cross cut with a rip blade. One of the early lessons I learned was how important it was to have a second (or third, or fourth) saw of some kind available for the odd offcut that needs to be made when your main saw is set up for some specialty operation.
> Have you ever answered a phone call in the middle of changing from cross to rip, and maybe forgot to tighten one of locking knobs? Now would be a good time to send in the helper into the equation. Crosscutting with a rip blade and one loose knob.
Never, for all of those. Those would be poor practices in any shop. Is it acceptable in a shop where you earn your living? But tell me—do any of those circumstances somehow make a RAS uniquely poorly adapted for ripping?
> Back when I was using my little RAS like yours,…
Condescension alert! Condescension alert!
> …there were times that I might need to spend a half hour standing in front of it ripping 2" thick lumber.
Sounds like a variation on the if you aren't making a living doing blah, blah, blah, you can't possibly know what you're talking about theme.
> …You know, there are going to be some boards that just like to cause trouble. I just hated finding myself trying to push a board through, that was bowing around, pushing out from the fence, slowing the blade, needing to get through a knot or something, and not being able to back out of the cut, because the kerf is now off to one side, and those pawls wouldn't allow it anyway.
Well, duh. Is there a wood shop anywhere, hobby or pro, that hasn't encountered those circumstances at one time or another? How does that make a RAS particularly poorly suited for ripping?
> Wouldn't it be nice if that switch which is now on the back of the motor to where you are feeding from was in reach now.
At the risk of repeating myself, how does that make a RAS particularly poorly suited for ripping? Ever have a 4x8 piece of sheet goods (going the long way) start to bind up on the table saw? Where's that On/Off switch? Oh, I'll bet there's a big panel saw where you make your living and you don't have to cut sheet goods on the table saw. Does that mean the table saw is particularly unsafe for cutting sheet goods?
> What do you do when faced with the above situation? Do you just turn loose of the work, and walk around to the other side and turn it off before the blade is burnt toast?
Again, isn't this a circumstance that can arise with any of several tools? How does that make a RAS particularly poorly suited for ripping?
> Could you post some photos showing the safest way to rip with the blade tilted to the table at 45�.
Could you? And how does that relate to the canard that a RAS is allegedly particularly poorly suited for ripping?
> I am glad that you guys like ripping with a RAS, but I suspect that none of you are having to earn your living with your tools. …
Condescension alert! Condescension alert!
> …These tools are meant for you. But don't kid yourself. When you are puttering around in your shops, you are not likely to be faced with the same conditions of needing to turn out a lot of work in the least time. Fooling with all of those adjustments, changing blades, setting everything just right, then needing to use some crud lumber to get the job finished.
My lord, did you invent woodworking or something? Even hobbyists (oops, I seem to have slipped in a little denigrating of my own) face all of those circumstances from time to time. Does having to work under pressure somehow make a RAS particularly poorly suited for ripping?
> I am just very glad that I am not still using a tool like that.
Everyone has their own prejudices about their “little” tools. Some are well founded, some are based on bad information, some might even be based on experience. Whether one makes a living doing something or not has little to do with acquiring prejudices or experience, except, perhaps, in how quickly one does it.
I have seen and heard some appalling stories of unsafe work practices from the pros and I've heard some appalling stories of safe practice theory from people who were frightened of their tools. I've heard appalling conjecture based on the misapplication of one set of conditions to another, completely ignoring scale or circumstances. My principal interest is in illuminating the foundations of published prejudices. If you say ripping on a RAS is inherently dangerous by design then I say you are doing so from an unfounded premise.
Ro(b)d