I posted a few weeks ago about replacing doors in my house. One suggestion was to get MDF doors since everything will be painted. I found a nice supplier and the door construction seems quite good. The doors will be quite heavy though. I have a few concerns that I'm looking for comments on:
Overall durability/stability like from denting or tear-outs?
Whether the excessive weight will result in damage if slammed?
One exterior entry door will be painted and they say MDF is OK for that. Is it or are there potential problems like moisture damage?
>Sorry, I didn't see your original post, but why not steel or fiberglass for a painted exterior door? I'm not really familiar with MDF doors, but as heavy as a 4x8 sheet is, I'd be scared it would pull the screws out of the hinges! I would also imagine it would be quite susceptible to "dings", particularly on the corners. Personally, I used steel for my painted exterior door and am quite happy with it. Paint looks good as new after 5 years, and you can buy magnetic door kicks, door knockers, etc which are a breeze to install and look great.
>I know that This Old House did some interior doors out of MDF on a recent project and were taller than a stock 80" door. It had 4 big hinges on it and I believe they were all screwed into the jamb with long screws.
I'd be leary of using MDF for an exterior door for all the usual reasons...........it gets dinged and wet before you're able to repair it, etc.
>In my experience, the door manufacturers generally have their bases covered when it comes to applicability for the job, but you'd better read the fine print to see their painting and maintenance specifications if you plan to use MDF for an outside door. How well it holds up will depend a lot on what kind of MDF it is -- there are some new formulations that are much more moisture resistant than standard MDF -- and the type of paint and how carefully you apply it, especially on the edges. If the edges aren't eased well, any sharpness to the edge will be a weak spot for the paint, and you only need a tiny breach to let moisture begin degrading the MDF. (We are talking about MDF frames as well as panels, aren't we? If the frames are softwood, you have much less to worry about.)
Weight will certainly be a factor when it comes to hinges and screws, but no more than it would be with a typical solid core door, which has flakeboard in the middle. Flake and MDF are both in the 45 lbs./cu.ft. range, compared with the 25 - 30 lbs./cu.ft. range for softwood. A typical exterior door (1 3/4" x 36 x 80) has almost 3 cu. ft. of material, which puts it around 125 lbs. That's a lot of inertia to open and close, and you definitely will want heavy duty hinges, which might take some of the satisfaction out of the lower door cost. I used to use 4 1/2" ball-bearing hinges for doors this heavy, and they aren't cheap.
The impact of slamming will depend somewhat on the construction of your house. If the walls are 2x4 studs and the door is somewhere in the middle of an unsupported run of wall, a good slam could certainly cause some reverberation of the wall, if not enough to shake knick-knacks off your shelves. That's a factor with any door, but here the risk is greater because of the weight.
MDF won't ding as much as a softwood door because the faces are case hardened by the manufacturing process. But edges are more vulnerable to crumbling under certain circumstances, such as if you got a stone or something caught under the door as you closed it. Wood might dent or split in such circumstances, but it wouldn't crumble like a cookie.
Sorry for the nosebleed, but I think the net economy of MDF for passage doors is overestimated.