Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

radiant floor heating

Posts

radiant floor heating

#1

radiant floor heating

David Haywood

>I'll try to make this brief. I live in the Richmond, VA area. I have a 1500 sq ft shop which is heated with hot water radiant heat. It works just fine, but the cost is high with propane. I am using a 50 gal water heater to do the job. I have been thing of switching to a tank less heater, either propane or electric, but I don't know (1) if it would work in this application (2) if I would save any money considering the cost of the unit and residual costs. Has anyone done this or know of anyone/company who is experienced in this area. The heating contractor that installed it had only done one. He had no experience with anything other than a boiler. He didn't thing the water would work and wouldn't venture a guess on the tank less issue.

Re: radiant floor heating

#2

Re: radiant floor heating

arw01

>It is doubtful you will save enough in the time you can live there to make a change to the system.

A quick way to make an estimate is to post here your cost per kWh, and your cost per gallon of Propane.

Then a simple calculation can be made based on a million btu's of heat at each rate.

A 1500 square foot shop is VERY large, nearly the size of my home out here on the west side of the country.

The shop I built last fall and am still finishing is 780 sqft with radiant tubes in the floor, but I have not installed my gas lines yet. Current plans in a Takagi jr. instant water heater as it's rated for space heating.

Alan

Re: radiant floor heating

#3

Re: radiant floor heating

Nat Robison

>Disclaimer: Writer is, by no means, an expert on water heating.

That said, I recently replaced a hot water tank due to a basement remodel with a power vented hot water tank. I figured, based on what I pay to heat water, it would take many, many years to recoup the costs of a tankless system. Personally, I like the idea of tankless systems but I couldn't make the numbers work.

I read the opinion of a construction guy/handyman who writes a column for the Detroit News who said he thinks tankless systems are best for on-demand hot water, not $$ savings.

Re: radiant floor heating

#4

Re: radiant floor heating

Terry Quiram

>David

I have a 1400 sq ft shop heated with raidant. For 5 years I used a 50 gal water heater. I realized that I was paying to heat water even if the thermostat didn't call for heat. Last year I took out the water heater and replaced it with a radiant specific boiler. It wasn't cheap but it will eventually pay me back.

Terry

Re: radiant floor heating

#5

Re: radiant floor heating

DB

>I do not think that you will save money using a tankless water heater in a radiant floor application because the heater will be running almost constantly during heating season. Electricity is most likely more expensive to use than propane in the Richmond area.

Try turning down the thermostat on the water heater when heating and off when heat is not needed.

Last but not least go to www.heatinghelp.com and post your question. They know more about heating then anyone here with the possible exception of one or two people.

Re: radiant floor heating

#6

Re: radiant floor heating

Barry Irby

>Two or three things:

You need to find out if the tankless heater you are considering is "rated" for a heating application.

Also, think about the situation. Heat is lost from the system in several ways. It takes a given amount of energy to heat your shop. So if the water heater puts that energy into the tank and then into the floor, where are the uses or loses the tankless heater might save? The heat that goes into the floor is the same either way, so what else is there?

Tank losses. The tank sits there and cools down and occasionally the burner fires and reheats the water. Turning the temperature down and insulating the tank better would cut those losses. OTOH, if the tank is inside your heated space in the shop, the tank losses go into the shop and are not really lost. They just warm the air rather than the floor. (If you leave the heater on in the summer then you pay to air condition the tank losses out, that's when insulating the tank and turning the temp down would actually help. Or turn it off)

Another loss that is often ignored is the loss from combustion air. If the tank is inside the heated space then the air it burns and sends out the flue/vent is a loss. The colder the day outside, the harder the system runs and the more cold air it sucks in to run the burner. (The electric industry hates this. Electric water heaters do not use combustion air and cause this loss, but the gas industry is allowed to ignore it. If combustion air is considered, gas heaters don't have nearly the advantage over the electric ones it appears. OTOH, the electric industry routinely ignores the line or transmission losses in their industry.)

If the tankless heater and the tank one are both located inside the heated space, they both induce losses from combustion air. You can get an exterior mount tankless heater, and that would eliminate these losses, but it must be a version that is freeze protected and that adds to the costs. (Any tankless heater is probably more subject to freeze damage than any tank heater. It takes seriously cold weather for us in Richmond to freeze a water tank.)Also, you may be able to get heaters that are "decoupled" or have an inlet for combustion air from outdoors. These losses may be higher on a tank heater because it may sit there and "daft" while the system if off. The warmth in the tank would provide the energy to keep the draft flowing and that would be a loss. Might look at a draft damper to cut this.

Another loss is piping losses. Heat radiates off the piping. Perhaps more than you would think. Not only while the system is running and circulating, but there can be conduction and convection losses while it is just sitting. Again, if the pipes are inside the shop and you are in the heating season the same thing applies as to the tank losses.

I seriously doubt you can justify the cost of changing to a tankless system for the fuel savings for this application. This is very different from the spot use of water in the house for hand washing, dishes, laundry, etc. These things often occur in almost momentary bursts and it does not make sense to have the fifty gallon tank of water waiting for the two gallon use. Radiant heating would tend to have longer and more even demands. If you change it out and it saves you money let me know, As a Home Inspector I would be curious.

Here's an invitation to come to the turning club meetings at the Woodcraft store in Richmond on the third Thursday evening at 6:00pm. Even if you are not interested in turning, its a good group.

Re: radiant floor heating

#7

Re: radiant floor heating

Larry Clinton

>I have serious doubts you would ever save the cost of the unit. The only advantages of the tankless units are: 1) You don't have the heat loss from the tank - This is a none-issue if the tank is in your heated area as the heat is not "lost", but just contributes to the heat in the building. 2) The "tankless" unit can be located near the hot water use area to reduce the heat loss from the pipes running from the tank type heater to the point of use. - Again a non-issue as you have the tank at the point of use. You can improve your heating situation (although I'm not really sure how much you will save) by doing a couple things. As was mentioned one of the hidden costs of operating a vented tank heater is that the combustion air (and additional heated inside air) is vented to the outside when the burner is in operation - The vent also loses heat constantly when the outside is colder than the inside. You can feel this by putting your hand near the chimney / vent when the unit is not in operation. This can be eliminated by making your unit a "direct vent". This involves the construction of an airtight cabinet to enclose the water heater, with an outside vent of sufficient size to provide combustion air. As I recall, I believe the recommendation is about 1 Square inch for each 2,000 btu. This should be brought in near the bottom of the unit, and must be constructed so it can't be blocked by snow, leaves etc.. The water heater tank and all pipes should then be double insulated to prevent freezing. Again, I'm not real sure of the savings this would provide. The NG hot air furnace I installed in my shop can be operated as a Direct vent or can use inside air. I believe the efficiency rating is about 95% with the inside air and improves to 97% with the Direct vent installed. However this is a high efficiency unit which has a closed combustion chamber with powered vent so exhausts no air except when in operation. Another option is to look at the efficiency of the heater you have and look at a high efficiency direct vent boiler. The attached link is an advertisement so take the info for what it's worth - but does give a comparison (biased, I'm sure). http://www.houseneeds.com/shop/HeatingProducts/boilers/heatsourcercostsexp.asp?stype=monitor/monitorboilersmainpage.asp

Re: radiant floor heating

#8

Re: radiant floor heating

David Yoho

>Barry, I'd say he's probably been around during those meetings a few times... David works there!!

David