Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Ideas

Posts

OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Ideas

#1

OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Ideas

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Hey all,

There appears to be a good amount of electrical knowledge on this site, so I thought I would do something I rarely do and post an OT.

The other night I left the shop (our two car garage) and left the lights on (I usually forget to turn them off. When I get up the next morning there are not lights on out there. I go look and the circuit breaker has tripped overnight. Now, I flipped the breaker back on and it stayed on. The only thing that was different than the night before was a 150W light bulb (incandescent) whose base is dangling by its wires (too long to explain) was blown out.

Now, I know from reading other places on the web that cheap pbulbs can cause this to happen, but I am using Phillips bulbs. Do you think that could be the reason that the circuit breaker tripped? I have had the circuit back on several times and it will stay for hours. I have been turning it off at night and when we are away from the house.

Just for background, on this same circuit I have the inside garage lights (two-way circuit), an outdoor spotlight (three-way circuit with three switched), another outdoor lamp (single switch), and finally two more outside lamps which are on a timer.

I am going to get up in the attic today and inspect the wiring and fix a couple of problems that have been around since we had the house. Then I am thinking it wouldn't be a bad idea to replace all the switches (I think something is wrong with ons of the two-ways from a previous issue). At this point I am not going to rip into the walls and replace all of the wiring, I do not think that is necessary, and with the cost of copper, I really do not want to do that.

Please give me your ideas. My wife wants to hire an electrician to look at it. I personally have a masters degree in electrical engineering, and I hate to call an electrician (kinda like when Tim Taylor's wife called the repairman). Ideas will be appreciated.

Thanks for the input,

Rob Hix

Re: OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Ideas

#2

Re: OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Idea

Mark Nowicki

>Listen to your wife.

Regards

Mark

Re: OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Ideas

#3

Re: OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Idea

Mark Nowicki

>Some ideas.

The 150W incandescent is too strong for the fixture, causing it to overheat. The heat could have melted some of the wires inside the fixture and created a short circuit.

The load on the circuit exceeds the capacity of the breaker.

Regards

Mark

Re: OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Ideas

#4

Re: OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Idea

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Mark,

LOML wants the electrician for my sake. I tend to worry too much about things.

Good idea on the fixture. It is plastic. I have not looked at it yet, but that could definitely be it. I really don't think it is load related as this same circuit regularly has all of the lights on it on at the same time and regularly that is all night.

Thanks for the ideas though.

I do need a couple of extra circuits run in the garage. One 20A receptacle outlet for the tools, and a stand-alone 20A for the freezer that we have out there. If I get an electrician to do that for me, it will save a lot of headaches, and he could check this out at the same time.

I think I will at least do a cursory look-over today to make sure everything looks ok to have the circuit energized while I work in the shop.

Again, thanks,

Rob

Re: OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Ideas

#5

Re: OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Idea

Barry Irby

>Mark might have the right Idea. Listen to your wife. Not that you can't figure this out and fix it, or that the electrician will have a better grasp of it than you do, but she has a stake in this too. If it would make her more comfortable it might be worth it and it would take you off the hook.

If I were to approach it myself (and I would) I would try to figure out if there were a power surge. Add up the watts of all the bulbs left on and convert that to amps (watts/volts) and see if that is near the capacity of the breaker. If it 80% or more, it might mot take much to trip the circuit. There are code requirements that circuits with long term loads on them not operate above 80%. Generally this is things like the water heater that might stay on for hours, but if you have the habit of leaving the lights on all night, you might have moved this into that category. If the circuit is that heavily loaded you might need to split it up. (They make half sized or mini breakers that fit most panels if you have a crowded breaker box.

Was there a storm that night? Did your computer shut down? (It might be on a surge protector and UPS and not tell you much.) Ask the power company. Hard to detect a transient event after it is over.

PS, I have a cousin who is also an Electrical Engineer. He actually worked on the Mercury Space Capsules. His mother asked me to rewire a lamp. He happened to come home while I was doing it and watched closely. When I finished he said "I could draw the circuit diagram for that."

Good time to clean up some of those dangling concerns.

Re: OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Ideas

#6

Re: OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Idea

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Rob,

Your wife is right....I manage EE's......not a good mix with house electicals, you work with different "code" books..

LOL

Take care,

Jim

Re: OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Ideas

#7

Re: OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Idea

Gene Gauss

>I also have a master's in electrical engineering, and have some practical experience in power plants as well, plus having worked for a summer during college in a GE lamp manufacturing plant (51 years ago). My guess, and that's all it can be, is that the cement holding the bulb into the base finally gave it up, perhaps due to repeated hot-cold cycles and the heat of a 150 watt bulb (a fairly high wattage for domestic application), and when the bulb released, the wires soldered to the base crossed, caused a short circuit, and tripped the breaker, as it should have. I've had that happen with a 150 watt floodlight bulb, but luckily it didn't short. If I were going to investigate it myself, and I would, I'd do a thorough visual inspection, looking at the exterior of all of the wiring, open each receptacle (with the breaker open) looking for any signs of overheating or arcing, and then check resistance from conductor to conductor, and each conductor to ground using a multimeter (after disconnecting all of the loads on the circuit. In general, the rule is that if a breaker trips, take whatever corrective actions are obvious, and then give it one more try. If it trips again, go at it doing whatever disassembly is necessary to find and correct the cause. Gene Gauss

Re: OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Ideas

#8

Re: OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Idea

Bill Howatt

>This type of problem can certainly cause a lot of worry because of uncertainty. Obviously, the first thing as pointed out already, is a very careful inspection of all your light fixtures and easily visible connections.

Breakers trip, if they are behaving properly, due to overcurrent. Switches that short internally should just turn on the light or whatever which is just an erroneous form of normal operation.

Is your breaker a normal one - not a GFCI or Arc-fault?

I did have a blown bulb trip a breaker but circuit had a KW heater running and some other lighting. The bulb went with a big flash which usually happens when you turn on an old bulb. I imagine the current surge was enough to trip the breaker. I also had another bulb that failed in such a manner take out a solid-state dimmer switch but that isn't too surprising.

Is there a possibility of rodent damage to your exposed wiring in the garage?

If you can't find anything you might consider an Arc-Fault breaker which I gather are now required for bedrooms in new construction (in some places,perhaps).

Bill

Re: OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Ideas

#9

Re: OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Idea

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Ok, I could go for the bulb socket shorting if it weren't for the fact that the socket is still in the system and the breaker will stay on. If the socket shorted, would it not stay that way?

Rodent damage is doubtful. One night a mouse ran in the side door (normal man door) when it was open, but plenty of mouse traps never caught it and I have seen not another sign of it. I am guessing he went in the side and I ran him out the front (overhead door) chasing him and didn't see him.

My plans are today to turn the circuit on for a few hours and see if I see, or smell smoke or heat. I will inspect the wiring in the attic where I can easily see it and fix a couple of wires that are pinched by some boards that were put in by the previous owner. At this point I am not worrying about wall wiring. I am also going to replace the 150W light bulb sockets with flourescent fixtures (less bulb changes and less heat).

By the way, I asked an electrical contractor at church this morning, and he said he has seen several times that a light bulb caused a circuit breaker to throw.

So, if my visual inspection and "burn in test" produces no bad thigns today, I am going to write it off to the bulb and go on with my life. If it trips again, I will definately have it looked into.

Thanks for the help, any more is welcome,

Rob Hix

Re: OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Ideas

#10

Re: OT: Bulb Blew...Circuit Breaker Tripped...Idea

Bill Howatt

>Rob,

I wasn't referring to the socket shorting but what I believe is the filament "shorting" as the bulb dies. Some mechanism causes a very large short surge of current inside the bulb which results in a big flash and then a dead bulb.

Bill