Power consumption??
Tom Norton
>So how much power does a 5 hp motor use? I always thought that the way to see was the #of watts. Is there another formula?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Power consumption??
Tom Norton
>So how much power does a 5 hp motor use? I always thought that the way to see was the #of watts. Is there another formula?
Re: Power consumption??
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>Depends on the load. Volts x Amps = Watts. Watts / 745.7 = HP
Clint
Re: Power consumption??
Dan Donaldson
>You really need to look mostly at the amperage of the motor. Manufacturers are not always totally "honest about the horsepower. You can see two different motors that both purport to be 1 horse, but the amperage is different.
The amps times the voltage will give the actual watts regardless of what the horsepower is stated to be.
Re: Power consumption??
wayne in Topanga
>Actually it's a little more complicated than stated above. The volts times amps divided by 746 will produce the electrical horsepower. Electric motor are not near 100% efficient, therefore one electrical horspower. For example a motor that is 75% efficient will only produce 3/4 horsepower of output for each electrical horsepower. I hope what I have stated above is clear enough for all.
Also the current drawn by a motor without load is not representative of what the motor will draw at full load.
Happy Woodworking,
Wayne Goldstein
Re: Power consumption??
Dan Donaldson
>True, but if you are going to compare two motors, the amperage ratings is the best way to see which has the most power considering that they have the same efficiency ratings.
To get really technical, you also have to factor in the power factor because it is a reactive load and that has effects on measuring the current. Still, without taking all of the "techie" stuff into account, you can get a pretty good idea by the rated current, noting that that will only be a full load and that some motors can run at over 100%. ;-)
Simple math doesn't tell you much about HP
Forrest Addy
>This is a little specialty of mine. I've done some studying on the topic of electric motors. That doesn't make me an expert but I am fairly well imformed. I assume you're referring to AC induction motors such as found in everyday home shop woodworking equipment.
Simple math doesn't tell you much about HP when it comes to induction motors. 746 Watts equals 1 HP only if you have a 100% theoretically perfect motor and there are no inductive effects to screw up your observations.
The best way to determine the electrical ratings of an electrical motor is to look up comparable motors in a real live industrial motor catalog. The WW Grainer catalog is a prime example of excellent presentation and disclosure. It gives the ratings of all their motors in a detailed tabular format plus it gives the NEMA and IEC frame sizes PLUS a pithy tutorial on electric motors and how to select them. Their prices are a bit high but you have to remember Grainger is who you go to for wide selection and quick service from stock.
Referring to your example of a 5 HP motor. A 5 HP MEMA rated single phase motor will draw 21 Amps or there abouts from a 230 Volt single phase line. Service factor, duty cycle, insulation rating, and other considerations affect the rated full load Amps of any particular motor. Wimpy but honestly rated 5 HP motors may go as low as 19 Amps. A motor intended for the heaviest industrial service might be rated for 24 Amps.
Discount completely any HP claims emblazoned in large characters on consumer grade equipment. If you go to Sears, Lowes, or Home Depot and choose equipment based on their HP claims you will be defrauded. This is not to say the equipment will not perform well; it's being misrepresented for marketing purposes. The other guys lie about their stuff so we have to lie about ours.
The best you can do on a compressor or saw you're considering is look at the rated motor volts and amps (usually on a tiny lable somewhere on the hidden side of the motor) and then look up comparable motors having equivelent ratings in reputable motor manufacturer catalogs.
Volts times Amps calculations about HP will mislead you. Look up equivalent motors.
Three phase motors are a slightly different deal but you weren't asking about them.
Wrong!! Your formula presumes a perfect motor.
Forrest Addy
>Sorry but it's not that simple, not even for DC motors.
A 5 HP AC induction motor draws about 21 Amps from 230 Volt single phase line. That works out to 4830 watts (actually Volt-Amps) 5 HP times 746 Watts equals 3730 Watts.
There's 1100 watts difference. Does the motor radiate 1100 Watts of heat? No. It radiates some heat (more like 800 watts) but because of the behavior of inductive cicuits the Amps is forced out of phase with the Volts resulting in a phemominom called power factor.
Since HP is a unit of mechanical power, electical energy is converted in the motor to mechanical power, and motors are limited in their efficiency more power must be consimed to compensate for the motor's efficiency, power factor and other losses. This is not a straight forward percentage.
So handy simplistic formula will lead you into error when it comes to figuring induction motors.
Re: Simple math doesn't tell you much about HP
Tom Norton
>Ok , How about a the comparison between a lets say 3hp single phase and a 3hp 3ph with a converter?
Which will "use" more watts?
Thanks,Tom
Re: Power consumption??
Jim Swank
>In general, and at the same voltage, compare the amps. The motor will consume current to produce the power needed, up to or even a little above that current level. It will consume a great deal more current very briefly when you start it.
You can equate the current (roughly) with torque. Torque is needed to bring the motor up to speed, to maintain it at speed, and to perform useful work. I include constantly connected load (saw arbor and blade, lathe spindle, etc) with motor in the above. Torque is generally of more interest to us as woodworkers than HP, but we know torque times speed equal HP.
Slight Hijack, what does it cost?
Barry Irby
>Pardon me for hijacking the thread or at least pointing it in a different direction.
If that saw used about 4800 watts, lets round up to 5000 and we run it for an hour does that mean it uses 5 kilowatt/hours? And if I am paying 10 cents a KW would it cost $.50 to run the saw for an hour?
And yes, I know it would vary with whatever load is put on the saw and many other factors such as the length and size of the wiring, the efficiency of the motor and the temperature of the motor and whether it was after the rate decrease kicked in or whatever, but I was just trying to figure out if it really costs about Fitty Sents to run a big tool for an hour.
Re: Slight Hijack, what does it cost?
Larry Clinton
>Your figures are correct Barry. 5,000 Watts X 1 hour = 5 KWH. 5 KWH X $.10 KWH = $.50 Total cost for 1 hour of machine time.
The phase converter/3 phase motor combo
Forrest Addy
>The phase converter/3 phase motors combo will be less efficient that a single phase motor of the same deliver HP. The losses of the phase converter are additional to the losses of the three phase motor.
That said three phase motor driven equipment can be advantagious to a shingle phase home shop. For one there's plenty of suitable industrial equipment suited to the home shop. For another, the motors are simpler in that they have no stereted circuits. For yet another three phase motors cen be fed from an VFD meaning operation directly from single phase, variable shaft speed at full motor torque (delivered HP will be in proportion to 60 Hz rated RPM), and finally, controllable accel and decel meaning electronic braking (a safety advantage in reducing coat-down time to a few seconds.)
You have to remember that in the home shop most motors run at near idle. They're started, run for a few seconds or minutes in light cuts, then shut off. A table saw motor or a planer may be run to ratings for the length of a few thick boards and idle between. Home wood shop equipment is thus "low duty cycle." The only motor that works close to ratings will be ther compressor. That renders on-going disputes over HP mostly moot.
So phase converter driven three phase equipment will draw a bit more power than equivalent single phase equipment. Here someone with a clamp ammeter may pounce and say "Aha! Then why does my phase converter driven table saw draw less idle current than my single phase planer?" There are usually capacitors in phase converter and they have the effect of correcting power factor. The motor draws about the smae power but the metered idle Amps read less because they are more in phase with the Volts.
Look at:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_factor
and related search opjects.
If run at full load as in a pump or other
Forrest Addy
>Your motor would draw $0.50 of juice per hour if it ran at full load as in a pump or other full load ratings constant load. When running at light load or idle the motor will apparently draw about 40% of its full load current. This might seem an alarming waste until you consider the effect of power factor. At idle the motor has a large phase difference between the line voltage and the current consumed. Thus the power factor is low. The Watt hour meter senses only the algeraic sum of the volts and amps thus a motor that costs $0.50 to run at full load may cost $0.07 an hour to run at idle.
Re: Simple math doesn't tell you much about HP
eliot d
>I wonder why the Government regulation types haven't gotten into the misleading stuff. Way back when, there was a terrible situation going on in the world of hi fidelity, where all the manufacturers were lying their heads off about wattage. It got so bad that, for the first time in history, the government had to get into it and insist on real standards. I always laugh when I see a cheap shop vac rated at 5 hp.
Re: Simple math doesn't tell you much about HP
Phil Joines Krum, Tx
>Even if they still exist the government doesn't enforce the truth in advertising laws any more.