Finishing aromatic cedar
Brian
>I bought a mailbox post at Lowes. It is aromatic cedar - light with dark blotches - and I don't know if I can stain it or not. Your thoughts.
Thanks
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Finishing aromatic cedar
Brian
>I bought a mailbox post at Lowes. It is aromatic cedar - light with dark blotches - and I don't know if I can stain it or not. Your thoughts.
Thanks
Re: Finishing aromatic cedar
Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa
>Brian,
I'd just put a couple coats of Spar varnish on it.
Ron in Iowa
Re: Finishing aromatic cedar
R. Lance in GR, Michigan
>Do not finish aromatic cedar with any kind of oil based finish...aromatic cedar gives off compounds similar to turpentine and will soften an oil based finish to a sticky state...became aware of this in researching to build a blanket chest with aromatic cedar lining and was often advised to not finish at all any part of chest interior containing aromatic cedar.
Timely answer
Pat Evans
>I was just about to post a question about finishing the cedar lining in a hope chest. (I have requests for 5 of them.) Did you apply a non-oil based finish, or just leave it bare wood?
Re: Timely answer
R. Lance in GR, Michigan
>my apologies to Brian as I don't want to get off topic on his question...but in a chest, place no finish at all on the cedar...this would kill its pleasant odor which can be revived with a lite sanding...and use no oil based product on inside of chest or any closed piece that will hold cloth because of accumulation of bad odor...I have not yet finished with my chest but think shellac would work as a finish if needed as it is alcohol based and doesn't have odor issues...but I defer to someone with expertise in finishing to address this.
Re: Finishing aromatic cedar
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>It can be finished with either a solvent based lacquer or any water borne latex, acrylic, or urethane finish.
Clint
Re: Finishing aromatic cedar
Brian
>Sounds like a water based finish or I'll just let it go natural.
Re: Timely answer
Dan Donaldson
>I am no expert, but with cedar, I usually use shellac on what few areas need a finish and leave the rest bare wood.
Re: Finishing aromatic cedar
Jim Dillon
>Brian,
I'm guessing you meant that the mail box itself was aromatic cedar, and not the post. Anyway, since we are not talking fine furniture here (like the interior of a blanket chest), and any clear finish (assuming you want to use a clear finish) you put on will have to be replaced in several years, I vote for any readily available good clear outdoor finish - maybe one you have sitting on your paint shelf already. Like Ron suggested, Spar varnish should work. Sikkens brand clear finish should be good. But since you sure won't need much finish, and some of these finishes are very expensive - especially in 1-quart sizes (if available), less expensive brands might be better value. I also imagine there are some non-film forming outdoor finishes that might work as well, but I have no experience with them. Good luck.
Jim
Re: Finishing aromatic cedar
Brian
>Actually, it's the post. Lowes had PT and these cedar posts. I have learned that cedar lasts very long outdoors. It seemed strange as I have only seet PT and rec cedar - but never aromatic. I might be calling it the wrong thing but the tag said cedar and it has that distinct smell. I'll take a pic.
Re: Finishing aromatic cedar
Larry Clinton
>Aromatic AKA eastern red cedar, is very durable, I remember as a lad in the 50's removing a post about 8" diameter in our yard. My mother said it had been there for about 20 years, although the outside inch or so had disintegrated, the center of the post (about 6" dia.) was still in top condition (and still smelled great). If you leave it natural, it will weather to a silver grey in a year or so, should last for 20 - 30 years unless in wet ground. Doubt if any coating would appreciably add to its life span as the portion that will deteriorate is that which is buried.
Re: Finishing aromatic cedar
Yonak
>I've never found a finish that would maintain the beautiful colors of red cedar in outdoor use. Whatever you use, understand that it will turn gray or tan.
Re: Finishing aromatic cedar
Jim Dillon
>Brian,
Thanks for the clarification regarding the post. Following my second cup of coffee this morning, I realized I've put a lot of Behrs' clear outdoor finish (a linseed oil based finish enhanced with silicones) on cedar deck railings and a cedar shake-sided house. [Got to stop posting early in the morning before my feeble brain is in gear 8-)] But that wood is not really aromatic cedar (as I understand it) even though it might smell of cedar. The horizontal top of the deck railings slowly turned very dark due to dirt from the surrounding oak trees. The vertical weathered cedar shakes on the house turned a nice reddish-brown. So Behrs might be a way to go as it is relatively inexpensive. I've also used Floods CWF "enhanced" clear finish on the cedar decking and that is OK too, but it is a strange pink color when first applied, then soaks in and turns clear (at least in areas where there are no excessive drips). I think these would work for a non-film finish that is not glossy. Olympic and Cabots also make clear outdoor finishes that some people think highly of. Or, as suggested, just let it weather to a nice gray and be done with it. Just some thoughts.
Jim
Re: Finishing aromatic cedar
Brian
>Your thoughtful replies have brought me to the decision to let it stay natural. Thanks.
Re: Finishing aromatic cedar
George (Oxford, NC)
>Sorry about chiming in late but I've been off the web a few days. From your picture, thats a whole lot of sapwood. The sapwood of cedar is nowhere near as decay resistant as the red heartwood. In fact, I was off the web because I was in east Tennessee visiting my brother and raided his wood pile for some cedar chunks to cut into pen blanks and stopper blanks. The logs I picked up were about 8"-10" diameter and the outer inch or so was virtually rotten while the red heartwood was in excellent shape (these have been sitting out in the weather). Bottom line for the post is, put something on the post, something meant for decks will do fine.
George
Yikes.
JohnKJordan in East TN
>Yikes, I was going to say much the same thing the second I saw that picture. The white will rot away relatively quickly outdoors and especially in contact with the ground. Round fence posts sometimes get wobbly when the white is gone and the red center remains. The USDA spec for fence posts (NRCS-382-1) reads "At least half the diameter of red cedar shall be heartwood." (Fences built to these specs are required to last 10 years)
When I cut cedar 4x4s for fence posts on my sawmill, I make sure most of each face is heartwood and allow some white only on the corners. I save boards with white for inside use.
The old pole barn on this place was built with red cedar poles. It had a 4'x6' corner of the roof missing for at least 20 years. The sapwood on that corner had rotted completely to mush from getting wet everytime it rained, but the heartwood was still in perfect shape.
It's hard to tell exactly from your picture, but if there is plenty of heartwood on the other sides of the vertical piece, especially where it goes into the ground, it should be OK at least for a few years. But I'd be inclined to put at least some wood preservative on it.
BTW, are you setting in concrete? You probably already know this but someone else might not: if setting a wooden post with concrete, for the longest life it's generally recommended to not put the post into a "pocket" of concrete where moisture can collect, but have the wood pass through the concrete to rest on a rock or gravel at the bottom of the hole. This allows moisture that passes through the wood drain out the bottom. If the post is load bearing, I generally put a few nails or screws into the sides of the post to give the concrete a better grip.
JKJ
Re: I wouldn't have purchased that post!
Larry Clinton
>if there is as much sapwood as it looks like in the picture. Can't really tell without other views, may be mostly heartwood - just a thin layer of sapwood. As others have stated the sapwood of cedar is not very "durable". When buying a cedar post you definitely want to find one with mostly heartwood. It is likely that ALL the sapwood in the ground will rot away within a couple of years. If there is a lot it can result in a loose post or one that will break off. That above ground will split and slough off in very few years. I can't tell from the picture just how much of the post is good heartwood (deep red color), but you should expect that to last many years. IMHO, I would not use any concrete to set any post. I would dig the posthole about 6" to a foot deeper than you want to set the post, fill the bottom with gravel to the depth desired, set the post and pour gravel around it, tamping well on all sides while leveling it. I would fill the last foot or so with well tamped soil. Looking at your post, I think I would apply some preservative to the area that will be in the ground.
What Part of East TN?
George (Oxford, NC)
>I was up near Harrogate, on the Powell river. My brother has a mile of river front from the river to the ridgeline with a self built log home half way up the mountain. Made with trees he cut and trimmed himself off the mountain.
George
Re: Finishing aromatic cedar
Jim Dillon
>Brian,
I had the same reaction as Larry and John regarding your cedar post. I was going to post yesterday regarding the use of gravel around the post, but saw what looked like mixed concrete or something in your wheelbarrow and figured it was too late and you were well on your way to "getting-it-done". If you haven't already, do strongly consider the comments by Larry and John. If it were me, I'd use just gravel with a few inches of gravel poured in first to allow better drainage. Plus, replacing it in a few years will be easier. But, hey, if you already have that sucker buried in concrete, don't worry about it, and chalk it up to one of lifes learning experiences.
Jim
Re: What Part of East TN?
JohnKJordan in East TN
>>I was up near Harrogate, on the Powell river.
We're a little south of Lake City, couple miles north of Clinton (SW from Harrogate.) Bought a farm a few years back and have been retired since the first of this year. Life is good!
Your brother's place sounds like paradise. The country is beautiful up that way.
JKJ
Re: Finishing aromatic cedar
Brian
>Thanks everyone. I'm returning the post ans will buy a red cedar post instead.