Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Hand cut dovetails: getting worse not better

Posts

Hand cut dovetails: getting worse not better

#1

Hand cut dovetails: getting worse not better

Brian In Dawson Creek

>This is my first attempt using the Rob Cosman�s method by cutting the tails first and then scribing a line from the tails to mark the pins. The first attempt was acceptable, barely. The wood was Birch to Birch.


The instructional DVD says to cut the pins on the waste side of the line but split the line with the saw. So now on the third and this is the fourth attempt all with the same results, if I cut any where�s near the line I get huge gaps, so I�m now cutting well away of the line and pare down to a fit (a lot of work). In the photos you can still see the scribe marks (I started planing them off and then realized I needed them for the photos.) I shouldn�t have to pare this much so all I can think of is that my marking or scribing is to fault, I tried small a jackknife, an exacto knife, a striking knife, all with the same result. Kind of getting frustrated as I not sure how to fix this so I can cut to the line as per the instruction.

Hope someone can put me on the right track.

Thanks

Fourth attempt with 7/16 thick willow




Re: Hand cut dovetails: getting worse not better

#2

Keep trying!

wilbur

>Practice makes perfect. Christopher Schwarz published an article this year about making a dovetail joint a day for a whole month, and how the practice helped out a lot with his dovetail joints.

That said, your fourth attempt looks pretty darn good to me. If your main issue is that your cuts are either too close or too far away to the base line of the dovetails, more practice will get your sawing to the right point so that you don't have big gaps and you don't have to do a heroic amount of paring.

One other thing to keep in mind is that undercutting can be used to get a better fit.

Re: Hand cut dovetails: getting worse not better

#3

Not bad!

Charles R. Smith from Victoria

>You have started well. Give yourself a pat on the back. I asked Rob to critique some of my early dovetails, as I wasn't happy with them. He pointed out that the wood I was using wasn't properly dimensioned -- and if the wood is not spot on, the results won't be either. It was good advice for a rank novice. Rob preaches the need for endless practice (and that from a man who manages to parent 9 or 10 children!).

Charles (who thinks dovetails can actually be fun, as can kids)

Re: Hand cut dovetails: getting worse not better

#4

Re: Hand cut dovetails: getting worse not better

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>They look pretty good to me, don't be harsh on yourself...

One thing that confuses people is the terms used. Cosman does it, so does Frank Klausz. They say "split the line" when in fact the line is outside the area to be removed. In his Pop Wood article from a year or two ago Klausz makes a passing remark as to leaving the line, but you have to be alert to catch it.

Basically, the line must be left whole, and then some. "Kissing the line" is a more apt description than splitting the line. Doesn't matter whether you use a knife mark or a pencil line or whatever, aim to leave all of it. If you leave too much you can pare afterwards, but the wood is resillient enough to withstand a tight joint.

I use a sharp pencil, leave the line and a tad more, and never pare. In about one hundred dovetail joints I have had just one split.

And practice, practice, at some point the whole thing works by itself...

DC

Re: Hand cut dovetails: getting worse not better

#5

Re: Hand cut dovetails: getting worse not better

Dan Donaldson

>Amen to all said plus:

I think that everyone develops a way to hold the saw, mark the lines, and make the cuts that works for them over time. As was mentioned, practice, practice.....

I sometimes take a board, mark a depth on it as if laying out a dt baseline then just draw a bunch of vertical lines and saw down them to the baselind over and over. When they are all cut, I cut the end off the board and start over. The sawing is at least 80% and probably more of the Good DT. When you get to where you can make those cuts exactly where you want them (split line, leave one side, then the other etc) and keep them plumb, then you are ready to cut DT's. Based on whatever you choose as a method to mark them, play around with your new sawing skills to see exactly where and how you need to cut to get good fitting DT's, then practice to get that consistent. It will vary a bit for each person. You need to know what works for you, and not what works for Frank, or anyone else.

Just my $.02 ;-) Works for me, although I still need a lot of practice.

Re: Hand cut dovetails: getting worse not better

#6

Re: Hand cut dovetails: getting worse not better

Dick Coers

>Soft woods are definitely easier to learn with. The wood will yield (fibers compress)to help with the fit. Try to join brass to brass making a hand plane. Now there are some extreme precision requirements!

I suggest you don't get hung up on the line. Learn what works for you and your tools, then just make dovetails. Hand work should always be celebrated, air tight joints or not. If you make drawers with joints like that, it'll last for generations. Congratulations to you.

Re: Hand cut dovetails: getting worse not better

#7

Re: Hand cut dovetails: getting worse not better

Jim Dillon

>Brian,

I agree with the other posters that you are being kinda tough on yourself. Your dovetails look pretty good to me as well. As others have mentioned, practice is important. For this reason, I think the woodworker Gary Rogowski(sp?) has his students cut two pieces of wood, say 3/4 x 3 x 18 inches. He then instructs them to cut a single dovetail using the ends of each: one for the tail and one for the pin. Once that is done, just lop off the end and do it again. And again. And again... . On the last few, I did two, then three dovetails to test my improving skill. I did maybe a dozen of these before I felt confident enough to tackle something more difficult like you are trying to do on the first try.

As an aside, I've had better luck with moderately hard woods like mahogany. On softer woods, like sycamore, pine etc., I have a more difficult time with crushing of the end-grain fibers - but then it is likely because I need more (actually, much more) practice (there is that word again 8-)) in sharpening. Good luck and keep at it. Thanks for posting.

Jim

Re: Hand cut dovetails: getting worse not better

#8

Reset your expectations *LINK*

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I too started with a few good dovetails and now I've progressed into worse. I think we need time to build up muscle memory, learn what our mistakes truly are (not splitting the line, not cutting square, not starting with square stock, rushing, etc).

I've now down dovetails on a toolbox I posted here sometime back. I had gaps I thought I could drive a truck through. But, the piece is plenty strong and when I took it to my recent guild meeting, nobody noticed. So, what I saw as horrible error wasn't really that bad.

Also, remember that Rob Cosman has been doing this for a long time and is very experienced.

Your dovetails look absolutely marvelous. However, now you have to determine what amount of error is acceptable in order to produce projects in any kind of reasonable time frame.

Check out Adam's blog on this very subject:


http://www.popularwoodworking.com/blog3/default.as

Re: Hand cut dovetails: getting worse not better

#9

dovetails

Andrew F in Australia

>They look fine, Brian.

The reason why the DVD says to split the pen line is that it's away from the true fit.

Try this -> use your knife (I use an OLFA knife with the snap-off blade,) to accurately mark the exact mating line for the dovetail. You'll need to cant the blade (tip it over slightly) so that the bevel of the knife blade runs on the pins/tails you're measuring off.

Run a sharp pencil along the knife score to highlight it.

Cut the dovetail with the kerf just kissing the knife line (obviously, on the waste side)

Should fit pretty well off the saw.

By the way, the dovetails you're showing would pass for trade quality, I'm just guessing that speed is the issue now.

Cheers,

Andrew