Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Help -- starting motor trips circuit breaker

Posts

Help -- starting motor trips circuit breaker

#1

Help -- starting motor trips circuit breaker

wilbur

>I have a dust collector with a 1.5 HP motor on a 120V 20 amp circuit. By my calculations, 1.5 hp should draw about 13 amps, give or take. (I know this information is on the motor badge, but I forgot to look at it before I left for work today.)

The thing is, when I turn the dust collector on, it trips the circuit breaker pretty consistently. If I reset the circuit breaker and restart the dust collector, it runs just fine then. My guess is that the current draw from the starting capacitors in the motor if they are "cold" is causing this to happen.

Is there an easy fix for this, and should I be worried about continuing to run the motor?

Re: Help -- starting motor trips circuit breaker

#2

Re: Help -- starting motor trips circuit breaker

Rick in Colgate, Wi

>Hi Wilbur,

I have a shop fox dc with a 1 1/2hp motor that was doing the same thing. Turned out the centrifugal switch in the motor was arcing to the motor casing and caused the points to freeze together.

I readjusted the switch so it wouldnt arc and filed the points and it has worked fine for over a year now. Its not an easy job taking the motor apart but its doable. Hope this helps.

Re: Help -- starting motor trips circuit breaker

#3

I may be wrong but...

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I think your problem is your breaker. While it is true that the 1.5 Hp motor will draw only about 13 amps when running, as it starts it draws considerably more for a short period of time. Look at the motor nameplate for the full load amps. That is what your breaker should be sized for. In your case a 1.5 Hp motor draws about 22.4 amps on startup.

Others with more electrical experience please jump in here if I am wrong on this.

Lee

Re: Help -- starting motor trips circuit breaker

#4

Re: I may be wrong but...

Jim Swank

>You're right on about the motor pulling higher current on start-up. This ooccurs until it gets up to speed. Your current estimates sound reasonable too.

What you missed is that the circuit breaker rating is not an absolute tipping point. It will tolerate overcurrent for a period of time, small amounts of overcurrent for several minutes, large amounts a few seconds or less. In other words, it shouldn't trip that easy unless something really bad is happening. I'd try plugging the DC into a different breaker if I could, and would consider replacing the circuit breaker as on of my first attempted fixes.

Re: Help -- starting motor trips circuit breaker

#5

I agree with a bad breaker.

John Cotten

>Change out the breaker. They do go bad occassionally, and sometimes come that way from the factory.

Re: Help -- starting motor trips circuit breaker

#6

Re: I also agree it most likely is the breaker

Larry Clinton

>This is not uncommon, breakers are not exact (I was an engineer over a manufacturing line that produced breakers for the headlamp circuit for GM automobiles). They all have a tolerance. A 20 amp breaker may break at 18 or 21, some may stand a normal motor "starting surge", others may not. The temperature of the breaker is also involved - on a hot day they will carry less current. They also weaken and will trip at lower current after a time and / or after breaking a few times. You may have to replace the breaker with a "motor starting" breaker that will allow the startup current. If a new 20 standard breaker doesn't hold, I would check with a local electrical supply house in your area for the motor starting breaker. Remember breakers are not designed to protect your motor, just the wiring in the wall. I'm sure the motor has its own overload protection.