Re: Commercial Property Values
Barry Irby
>Ron, Since you mentioned my name, I will jump in. You are correct, this is not my area of expertise so take this with a grain of salt.
The commercial market can appear almost whimsical compared to the housing market. People must have housing so there is some real demand that does not take into account interest rates and other factors. Well, The market does take all the factors into account, which is why we have the fluctuations (buyers market, sellers market, flat, robust, whatever) but underneath that there is real demand that eventually must be met. They claim that in a market like we have now, people are waiting to get married (household formation) to see where interest rates and confidence in the jobs market etc will go. That affects much of the economy. They don't buy wedding dress and suits. They don't buy furniture and carpet. They don't buy home improvement stuff, so everyone from Bridal Boutiques to Lowes get killed.
OTOH, Commercial property does not have that underpinning of innate demand. If the market turns down, people are waiting in the wings to buy houses and use creative financing or what ever to make it happen. But there will be a certain number of businesses that fail or are never launched. The ones that are never launched tend to evaporate. Some body's dream with no more substance or impact than the dream you had about flying to the moon. That demand is just gone. In many cases to never be heard from again.
I used to do commercial appraisals. 25 years ago. The appraiser I worked for is a great resource. He did appraisals for the highway department about taking land for projects and many other types as well. One Sunday, there was an article in the paper about how local developers had noted that the office market in Richmond was under built and they were going to build enough office space in three separate surrounding localities, that each project would double the amount of space available. That is, if all three had been built it would have quadrupled the amount of space. I called my former boss and asked him "Don't these people talk to each other?" The answer was NO. Each appraiser for each project operated in a vacuum, not knowing the others were out there with essentially identical plans. If only one had been built it might have been wildly successful, establishing a new part of town as "the" place to be. If all three had been built they would probably all have failed and all three appraisers would have been wrong.
Just like residential properties, its "location, location, location." If you are looking at a property in a distressed part of town its worth a lot less either to purchase or rent than one in a up and coming part. OTOH, you might not rely on walk-in trade and might be able to operate out of cheaper space. Or you could create something so HOT people will drive to you anyway (A destination store, Don't even think about it.)
I can't remember their name, but someone got the idea to create an Internet home sales site. They were going to sell you a sign for the yard, list your property on the Multiple Listing service, and put it on their website, all for $595. If a Realtor sold it, you would have to pay them half the commission. Great concept. They got licensed in all 50 states. They rented space in a prestigious high rise in down town Richmond. Eight floors of space, Premium furniture and art. Absolutely no walk-in trade. Out of business in less than a year. I wonder if they would still be in business today if they had been willing to operate out of some less expensive space? It was ego driven.
Wood Craft is a destination store. You drive there because they have pulled together merchandise you can't get at the Borg. Needs to be convenient, but not trendy.
OK, I have babbled on, and obviously don't have any specific help. If the general market is down right now, it could be an opportunity. If you feel your business can pay the rent, get in and ride the next wave back up. There's always a next wave, but the question is when. There are areas in Richmond that have been depressed for fifty years and they are coming back now. Suddenly its trendy to take and ancient warehouse and convert it into luxury condos. So don't count on the wave or trend picking you up in a year or two.
There might be a parallel to the stock market. If Macy's marks the summer merchandise down 50% and has a big sale, people rush in to buy. If the stock market marks stuff down 50% people run around like chickens with their heads cut off. WE are confident that we can use the shirt next summer. If we treated drops in stock prices like bargains, the stock market would recover a lot faster. So, If you are confident you can use your space in the nest season or the one after that, go for it.
Be careful on your lease, get legal advice. If you get depressed or favorable rent or even if you dont you want to be sure you can continue to rent without the landlord jumping the rent back up to "market" rates. You want rent increases capped to a known amount or percent. Also be sure what the rent covers. They have terms like NET, and Net,Net and NET,NET,NET. Sounds silly, but extremely important to know what they cover and what you cover. (Insurance is one of those things.) You might be running into ordinances that require Dust collection, noise abatement, fire suppression and on and on. Be careful.