Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

fine dust collection

Posts

fine dust collection

#1

fine dust collection

Jim

>I haven't been on in a while, fishing and all that stuff! I am back in the shop and ready to tackle the fine dust problem once more. The age old question or rather confusion on my part is this: I have a 500 sq.ft shop in my basement with separate entrance and I have a 2hp grizzly bag DC. I got on Bill pentz's web site and emailed him about a concern about fine dust in the shop.

QUESTION: Which is the most cost efficent machine to get; I have 6"duct with three branches (6") and 6"port on my cabinet saw, No step down to 3 or 4 inch duct work and min. amount of flex. plastic duct.

What do I need to adequately be safe in my shop? I also have an air filter system mounted on the ceiling.

Bill is so passionate about his studies, it's almost got me to close the shop down.

PLEASE HELP IF YOU CAN!

Re: fine dust collection

#2

Re: fine dust collection

Mike Fitterling

>Your 2 hp Grizzly is probably adequate for the job, assuming a good duct system that is not too long. I have a 2 hp Grizzly myself (not the 1029, an older model but almost identical, with a 12" fan) and I manage with it in my 672 sq ft shop, which is used a lot.

I don't want to get in a fight about DC and health, but keep in mind that Bill has some specific health issues that make fine dust collection even more critical for him, which he mentions on his site.

Particles under 2.5 microns are the ones generally associated with serious health issues because those particles can make it past most of the repiratory systems protections and settle in the deep recesses of the lungs. I have looked and looked for evidence of harmful quantities of these particles being produced in a small workshop and have not been able to find any reliable studies actually quantifying this. I someday would like to set up some kind of sampling, machine by machine, to establish the size and percentages of this type of dust produced by each machine. It is obvious that some machines produced large qunatities of fine dust than others; just look at the dust from your jointer compared to your drum sander; but I have yet to find any substantive data showing what machine produces what kind of dust. That said, it still makes sense to protect your self against exposure to these small particles as much as practical, making sure the worst offenders have the best collection.

There are many bags and cartridges capable of filtering fine particles down in this range; many will fit your DC. That would be the place to start. Combine use of those filters with the use of your ambient air cleaner to scrub the air of anything that escaped your DC (most of these scrub down to 1 micron) and you should have pretty good protection.

Another efficient way to remove that dust from your shop air is to vent your DC outside if possible, which is, I think, Bill's latest recommendation. Venting outside can remove cooled/heated air, though from your work space, so keep that in mind. This is not much of an issue in some locations and a big issue at others and will depend on how much use the DC gets.

There is much controversy regarding dust control and health effects of dust. No one doubts that certain amounts of fine dust is bad for you; but there is little science about the risk in small home shops. So I do what I can, filtering my DC and scrubbing the air. And once in a while I put on a respirator and blow all the dust out of the shop outside, followed up by running the air cleaner for some time. I continue to work and do what I can to reduce my risk. I understand what you mean about it all sounding so grim, so much so that I think some people ahve been scared out of even picking up a broom to sweep up their shops.

Cheers,

Mike

Re: fine dust collection

#3

Re: fine dust collection *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>Mike - Thanks for the well-written & informative post. I'm just getting started in woodworking & this issue is one of many I'm attempting to get up to speed on. I wasn't aware of the Pentz site; there's a lot of dust info there which will take me awhile to sift through (you'll pardon the pun). I was considering the Harbor Freight 2hp collector model 45378-1VGA, which looks pretty similar to the Grizzly, though if I'm not mistaken the Griz ships wired for 240 while the HF runs only on 120. The vac itself sells for $199, adding 1 micron capacity with ITEM 94278-0VGA is an additional $169. I'm wondering what people think of these pieces. Another option I have considered is forgoing the 1 micron parts and simply sticking the vac outside my 600 sq' space, running a hose to it though the wall. Downside is I'd have to construct a small shelter for it up against the garage wall. My shop is unheated, so pumping out conditioned air isn't an issue.

Anyone have any good construction articles on air filters? I've seen some that use furnace filters, probably not too effective on the really fine stuff.

Thanks again for the info.

Dan


BillPentz.com :: Dust Collection Research

Re: fine dust collection

#4

Re: fine dust collection

Mike Fitterling

>If I'm not mistaken, that Harbor Freight 2 hp unit has an 11" impellor, where my Grizzly has a 12". I don't know if the current Grizzly 2 hp model still has a 12", but it ought to be easy to find out. And check the motor nameplate amperage to make sure you are getting the full 2 hp. The HF DC goes on special pretty often and I don't know anyone who has paid full price for it. Just a heads up. IMO, 2 hp is the minimum for a decent fixed duct system. Make sure to compare apples to apples when buying. If you have to add bags to the HF model but another can be had with the bags already installed the second one might be a better deal.

Cheers,

Mike

Re: fine dust collection

#5

Re: Bags *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Dan,

Suggest you check with Process Systems about bags. I just upgraded my system with one of their 72" x 19" filter bags and the performance is awsome. Bag has a bonded interior layer that takes it beyond the usual pinpoint felt or canvass bags, making it commensurate with 1 micron bags sold elsewhere. My bag cost me $99 plus tax and ship because they're in New Jersey. I now use a plastic collector bag on the bottom.

I asked several people about the cartridge filter conversions, and every one said they were really great until they got clogged with the fines, then were a hugh headache to clean and restore full flow, and had to be cleaned more often. That's why I decided to go with the upgraded bag instead. Shake it a bit and everything drops to the bottom.

mm


Filter Bags

Re: fine dust collection

#6

JL

Re: fine dust collection

JL

>If you are in the market soon, consider Penn State Industries DC2000B Dust Collector w/ 1 micron Bags. It is on sale for about $260 and is comparable with the Grizzly.

Re: fine dust collection

#7

Re: fine dust collection

Dan Mitchell

>Mike-Thanks for that. The Griz does have a 12" impeller, the manual on the HF one doesn't state a size. I agree about the potential vagaries of HP ratings. On the HF unit, $199 is the "sale" price at the moment, you're right, always best to wait for a markdown with them ;-)

Dan

Re: fine dust collection

#8

Re: fine dust collection

Dan Mitchell

>Mark & JL - Thanks for the tips, I'll check 'em out!

Dan

Re: fine dust collection

#9

Re: fine dust collection

Barry Irby

>Dan, I Have a Delta unit that is supposed ot move 1300 CFM. On advice of Bob Dodge (here) I removed the restrictor plate out of it.

I have my unit in a lean-to closet outside the shop. I really like that. I don't want a dust collector, I want a dust remover. When I empty the bag, I shake the filter bag down. Some dust flies around. When I remove the trash bag, I seem to lose a little debris. With the unit outside, that crap is not in my shop. With the unit outside I don't much care whether I have a 1 micron or a 30 micron bag, anything that the bag fails to filter is gone with the wind.

I have blast gates on my system with the microswitches that turn the DC on. It runs in short bursts. I have a space heater in my shop and a small window AC. I have not noticed a significant heat loss/gain. Yes, if the DC runs for more than about ten minutes, I can tell, but as soon as I turn it off, the shop "recovers".

Since I seldom run more than one tool at a time, the relatively small DC takes care of it. I ran mine in 4 and 6" sewer and drain PVC and like it. I do not have the piping grounded and have not had trouble with static.

Make it easy to change the bag. I am amazed at how often I have to change it, but then I have a lathe and that seems to make shavings by the bushel.