Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Solvents and thinners - differences?

Posts

Solvents and thinners - differences?

#1

Solvents and thinners - differences?

wilbur

>Does anyone know or have a list of the various solvents you can get and what they are best used for? When I was in the borg the other day, I found lacquer thinner, paint thinner, naphtha, mineral spirits, turpentine, xylene, acetone, and denatured alcohol (ethanol).

Now, lacquer thinner is pretty easy to figure out, and I know that denatured alcohol is used for shellac, but I don't know what the others are best used for, or even what the differences are between the others.

Re: Solvents and thinners - differences?

#2

brief summary

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>paint thinner, mineral spirits- essentially the same stuff. Petroleum derived Hydrocarbon solvents good for oil based paint thinning and brush cleaning. Use what ever is cheapest is my rule

turpentine,an expensive hydrocarbon from pine trees that is essentially equivalent to above solvents. Some professionals say they see a difference but this frugal amateur does not.

naphtha- same as above but lower boiling point and hence faster drying. I use it to thin in cold weather.

xylene&toluene- petroleum derived hydrocarbon solvent used to thin certain high performance finishes, eg. conversion varnish. It is a stronger(better) solvent than those listed above and hence will dissolve things that the above will not. Great brush cleaner but pricey. Gas is cheaper for this application but more flammable and hence risky. Toluene more volatile.

acetone- a petroleum based ketone solvent, a different chemical class of solvent than those above and it is used to dissolve lacquers. I don't know where it is used by itself, but it is a component of lacquer thinners and lacquer formulations. It is cheap but very volatile with attendent flammability issues. It will often dissolve things that the above solvents will not, and visa versa.

and denatured alcohol (ethanol). does booze need explaining?

More advance stuff- Alcohol, acetone, xylene&toluene, and mineral spirits&naptha are different classes of chemicals. To an approximation, like dissolves like, so the chemical class of alcohols dissolves things whose molecular structure is similar to alcohols, mineral spirits dissolves things whose molecules resemble oil and grease, etc. For example alcohol mixes totally with water but not oil, while mineral spirits mixes totally with oil but not water. However when it comes to dissolving polymers (most of the film forming finish components are polymers) the simple "like dissolves like" rule gets more complicated and those not experience will not be able to predict what will be a good solvent without experimentation. Lacquer thinning solvents can be quite complex mixtures of chemicals with different solvent properties and volatility.

For practical purposes look on the finish can label and see what the finish has in it for a solvent. Use same to thin or clean equipment.

Re: Solvents and thinners - differences?

#3

Re: brief summary

Dan Donaldson

>May not be any better as a solvent, but, to me, turpentine smells better (or at least not as bad) than mineral spirits. ;-)

Re: Solvents and thinners - differences?

#4

Poly Specks on Safety Glass Plastic Lenses?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Hi Wilbur,

If I only knew the answer to that, I'd save the cost of new ones.

George

Re: Solvents and thinners - differences?

#5

Excellent summary, just one point

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Denatured alchool is not pure ethanol, it is "denatured" by adding toxic alchools to it (usually methanol, I believe), so as to make it improper for human consumption. Otherwise we would have to pay liquor taxes...

Methanol smells great but can blind or kill you, and is also absorbed through the skin. That's what I recall reading about the product.

I'm sure you knew all that, I just thought it was worth mentioning...

Over here we can get 188 proof ethanol at the liquor store, but it costs over $60 for a (Canadian) quart.

Incidentally, Zinsser SealCoat uses pure ethanol as its thinner. I was surprised when I found that out, but check the can, there's no skull and crossbones sign on it.

DC

Re: Solvents and thinners - differences?

#6

Re: Excellent summary, just one point

Larry Clinton

>Dennis, I'm not surprised to learn Zinser uses pure ethanol. As an Engineer before retirement, I was responsible for many of the solvents we used in our factory. I actually investigated using anhydrous (without water) ethanol as a cleaning agent for some of our equipment. As I recall the cost per gallon was on a par with Isopropyl. The reason I didn't was the enormous paperwork necessary to prove to the government agents (revenuers) that it was all used in our process and that we didn't drink or sell it. If you didn't keep perfect records, you ended up paying the (very high) taxes on consumable alcohol. The other reason was that some of the management thought some of it might be drank instead of used for cleaning. I ended up using anhydrous Isopropyl, (99.95% pure). I do have some in my shop for use as a slower solvent for shellac.

Re: Solvents and thinners - differences?

#7

Re: Poly Specks on Safety Glass Plastic Lenses?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Nothing will dissolve a cross linked polymer(finish). Some very strong solvents might soften the finish but these will dissolve the lenses. Other stuff will degrade the finish to something soluble but anything I can think of will also cloud the lenses. I think you are out of luck.

Polycarbonate is strange stuff and interacts with solvents in bizzar ways. Severly bend a scrap CD between thumb and first finger. While under tension add some drops of rubbing alcohol to the CD. It will shatter from the interaction of the solvent that initiates micro-cracks. Great class demo.

Re: Solvents and thinners - differences?

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Keeping glasses/spectacles clean

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I have done much spraying of various materials over the years, and I don't wear goggles or safety glasses, just my usual Coke bottles.

Anyways, after years of basically scratching the snot out of my glasses in a year or so, I finally asked about cleaning glasses at the optometrist as I was picking up a new pair. Some of what follows came from them, some of it I have figured out.

1. Use no wood-based products--no facial tissue, toilet paper or paper towels. These will scratch lenses, particularly polycarbonate or high-index plastic (what I wear due to my prescription).

2. Use a dedicated glass-cleaning agent. I get mine at Meijer's (mega grocery store) in a pump-spray bottle. Spray it on liberally and use your fingers to rub it around, then rinse it off and/or use a soft cloth to dry them. Terry cloth or cotton blends work fine.

3. If spraying a finish, clean early, clean often. "Young" finish is much easier to clean off than specks of finish that have been allowed to cure for even a day.

4. If you get some sort of dust on your lenses, rinse it off under running water before you clean your glasses, otherwise, it will just act as an abrasive.

5. In a pinch, I have found denatured alcohol or a strong ammonia solution excellent at cleaning my glasses as well, with no damage to the lenses. I even add it to my windshield washer fluid, as it lowers the freezing point of the summer formula, and I think it helps clean the windshield of my truck better (only takes a few ounces per gallon).

6. For the toughest specks on my specs, I will spray them down with the glass cleaner (seems to be an alcohol and some surfactants) without wiping them off before I take a shower, or I will put an ammonia solution in the sink and let them soak while I soak. After the shower, I clean them as described above.

Jason

Re: Solvents and thinners - differences?

#9

Re: Keeping glasses/spectacles clean

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Thanks Jason,

I'll try your "solutions". Those little specks drive me craqzy especially in bright light.

George

Re: Solvents and thinners - differences?

#10

Why you should thank a Canadian

Michael Dresdner

>Acetone is indeed used in lacquer thinner, but it is also sold in tiny bottles as nail polish remover. If there are women in your house who use such things, it is much cheaper to buy it by the pint at the home store than by the ounce in the nail polish department.

Denatured alcohol is indeed denatured with something non-potable, and at times it is methanol which is poisonous, but bear in mind that they usually add no more than one percent (1%) of whatever they use to denature, so it is nowhere near in the same ballpark in terms of danger as handling pure methanol. More recently people have been using other non-potables to denature, things that are also not drinkable but are nowhere near as toxic.

In case you were wondering why Zinsser switched to pure ethanol in its products instead of denatured alcohol, it is because of Canada. To sell their products in Canada they had to take out the methanol. They decided it was simpler to take it out of all formulations rather than have separate products for the Canadian market, so if you are glad about this, thank a Canadian.