Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Kind of OT - Replacing bathroom fan

Posts

Kind of OT - Replacing bathroom fan

#1

Kind of OT - Replacing bathroom fan

Hoa Dinh

>Mine is a two story-house. The cheapo bottom-model Broan fan in the bathroom downstair is too noisy. So here's what I have:

- No access from above.

- Existing 3" duct.

I would like a Panasonic fan/heater combo (I can run new circuit for the heater) but they all require access from above, which I don't have. Also, they require 4" or 6" duct. Replacing the ducting is not possible.

Cost (up to certain limit) is not an issue. But I don't want to rip things apart.

The heater option is nice, but not required. I need a quiet fan.

Please help. My reputation is at stake!

-- Hoa

Re: Kind of OT - Replacing bathroom fan

#2

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Why some fans are noisy...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Several years ago, the trend in residential (and even commercial) construction was to make all the bathroom fans as quiet as possible, the quietest being the top-of-the-line. Now that all those fans are installed and have been used for years, people have realized why it is GOOD to have a somewhat noisy bathroom fan--they help to cover up various, uhhh, "noises" that the bathroom occupant may make in the performance of their, ummm, "duties". So your fan may not be as bad as you think; you might re-evaluate which features are important...

Jason

Re: Kind of OT - Replacing bathroom fan

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Kind of OT - Replacing bathroom fan

Jesper, Denmark

>Hoa, Fan noise is directly related to the pressure it can produce. More noise, more pressure to push air through the duct.

As you have a small duct, you will have to live with either some noise or very little airflow.

Re: Kind of OT - Replacing bathroom fan

#4

Only in some ways

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>All things being equal you are right, the more airflow the louder it will be, but that's only comparing fans built the same way. I've found it depends more on how they are made.

I have several:

Loudest - metal fan blades - least airflow

Loud - plastic fan blades - more airflow

Quiestest - squirrel cage fan - most airflow

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Kind of OT - Replacing bathroom fan

#5

Re: Kind of OT - Replacing bathroom fan

Grant in Iowa

>Hoa,

If the fan is still a current model, I suggest you upgrade it to a quieter version of what you have from Broan. If you go to a home center that carries them, and ask nicely, they should be willing to let you see which of the better units can use the same sheet metal box. It should be a matter of opening boxes of the ones above yours to see which ones would work in that box.

Take your "innards" along with you to compare.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Kind of OT - Replacing bathroom fan

#6

least intrusive option

Nat Robison

>Grant's option is probably the best for disturbing the least. I just installed a Panasonic in a new bathroom and you can barely tell it's on. It seems to push the air fairly well.

With no access, sounds like your only option is to replace the motor.

Re: Kind of OT - Replacing bathroom fan

#7

Re: least intrusive option

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>I second Panasonic. It's what the commercial HVAC guys put in their houses too..

Rob

Re: Kind of OT - Replacing bathroom fan

#8

Re: least intrusive option

Warren E. White

>Hoa,

Another option that you might have already tried. I pull my fan down every once in a while and clean and oil it. I actually take the motor apart, clean everything, and relube the armature shaft bearings. I then reassemble, tightening everything up.

It is amazing how much better it sounds.

Warren

Re: Kind of OT - Replacing bathroom fan

#9

Replace it with..

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>When I remodeled our bathroom, I was faced with a similar problem, with out the heater question. The old bathroom fan was as loud as my dust collector and didn't move a lot of air. It would also start out slow and wind up the longer it ran and would sometimes hit a resonant frequency with the ceiling and really vibrated.

We looked at the various options available and settled on a medium priced unit with a low Db rating. I had to enlarge the hole in teh ceinling about 1" on one side, but was able to connect tot he old four inch flex duct. I had just enough slack in teh wiring to pull it down so I could make the coneection below the opeing and work it back up through the hole. You can still hear the fan when it runs, but it is much quieter and moves significantly more air.

Lee

Re: Kind of OT - Replacing bathroom fan

#10

Re: Kind of OT - Replacing bathroom fan

DizD

>I've wondered about putting the fan unit at the discharge end of the hose - kinda like a vacuum cleaner? Any reason the fan has to be in the room being vented?

Re: Kind of OT - Replacing bathroom fan

#11

There are systems

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>There are systems that do just that. One large fan in the attic, pulling air from several hoses from each bathroom. Sort of like a central vac.

Makes much more sense having 1 good fan out of the way, rather than 4 fans at ($50-$100/each) in each bathroom. Guess the only trick is the switch, which shouldnt' be a big issue since it would use low voltage switches and relays.

Happy Woodworking!