Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

Posts

Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#1

Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

John Cotten

>A number of years ago Tom (I think that was his name) Werth came out a joint cutting machine that used a router and several plastic templates that would allow the operator to cut several types of joints with it. I had a buddy who had one that we used to make gardem benches. It was the bees knees.

Would love to find one for some production work I have coming up. Anyone know where I can find one or a similar machine/jig on the market.

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#2

Just remembered

John Cotten

>Woodtek also offered a similar machine to the Werth, may have even been on his patent.

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#3

Re: Just remembered

Dick Coers

>John Wirth is the president of Woodworker's Supply. They still sell the machine and it is on sale right now for $1699.

http://woodworker.com/cgi-bin/FULLPRES.exe?PARTNUM=95-100

There is also the JDS Multi Router which I have owned for 20+ years. The website says to find a dealer for pricing. I think it's about twice the Wirth.

http://www.jdstools.com/index.asp?PageAction=Custom&ID=12

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#4

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

Thomas S Stockton

>I had the cheap version that woodworkers supply sells that uses a router. It worked ok but I like my multi-router a whole lot more. Look at slot mortisers Invicta makes a pretty heavy duty one that is about the same price as a multi router. Felder and laguna tool carries one also.

when the multi router first came out slot mortisers were pretty rare and expensive and it was and still is a good solution, but with the price similar to an industrial unit I would look hard at both before spending the money

Have you looked at the Festool domino it might fit your needs, it's a fanatastic tool but the sizes mortises it makes are limited.

tom

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#5

Thanks guys.

John Cotten

>I have a laguna jointer/planer that will take their mortiser. New mortiser is around $795.00 plus shipping. I know where a Invicta stand along is. Price is right, around $400.00 The guy who says he owns it has never run it, and is not sure how to use it, came from a woodworking auction. I don't think the machine has 100 hours on it. I played with it one afternoon and had it up and running in about 15 minutes. What a gem. There is some question as to ownership at the moment due to a lien against the business so I am holding off.

Tom Werth invented a multihead bandsaw band in the late 80's, early 90's for resawing pallet cants into pallet boards. I had forgotten about John Wirth and Woodworkers Supply.

The domino machine looked interesting until I really had a chance to try one recently. For making tennons for exterior doors, table legs, and beds, I don't think it would be the best route to go. That is why the other machine is of more interest to me. Also with the right templates you can make louvered shutters, and a host of other mortise and tennon requirements.

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#6

Re: Slot mortiser option, cheap *LINK*

Rcik L

>Been using and advocating slot moe\rtisers for over 25 years. The Grizzly 0540 is a viable option and cheap. I'd compare it

to the Rojek which is under $2,000 and the Grizzly is about 1/5th of that.


Slot mortiser

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#7

Re: Thanks guys.

Thomas S Stockton

>$400 for an invicta I would have been out the door yesterday, at that price if it didn't work out you could unload it and not be out anything. The stand alone would be my preference over adding one to a jointer/planer especially for production.

I would agree about the domino just not stout enough floating tenons for an exterior door.

Tom

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#8

Re: Thanks guys.

John Cotten

>I have dibs on the Invicta as soon as the owner can prove he has clear owner ship. He is several months behind on rent (over a year) and his landlord has placed a lien against the equipment. If I were to buy the Invicta, knowing about the lien, I am in fact purchasing what would be considered stolen equipment since the owner does not have clear ownership at present. He has looked at selling some of his equipment to clear his debt, but the landlord has blocked the sales till the debt is cleared.

Life is tough enough without adding to the stress by doing something that I am almost sure would come back to bite me in the posterior.

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#9

Ellis Walentine

And another reasonable option

Ellis Walentine

>Laguna had a Chinese floor-model mortiser at the AWFS show this summer for $800. Very nice machine -- as nice or nicer than the Rojek for half the price. I'm thinking of getting one myself.

Ellis

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#10

Re: Thanks guys.

Thomas S Stockton

>John,

That's to bad but a real smart decision on your part. Maybe you could make an offer in writing to the guy and hand the money to the landlord and have him sign off on the whole deal. Might be more complicated than it's worth depending on the "personalities" involved.

Tom

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#11

Re: And another reasonable option

Dick Coers

>I looked at the machine on their website. One thing to consider on it is the motor speed. It's less than 3000rpm. My Multi-Router really makes a clean and fast mortise because of the high motor speed. The slower industrial machines are more like using a drill and it is much slower. I've always used a see-saw cutting action(even with an upcut spiral) to limit the "squack" of the router bit when drilling. I think it gives me more of a milling cut versus drilling and the side walls of the motise are much cleaner.

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#12

Re: Slot mortiser option, cheap

Clay Foster

>I have both a Rojek horizontal mortiser and a Leigh M&T tool. They both serve a purpose, depending on what you make.

The Leigh is more precise and cuts cleaner mortises because of the high router speed. It is good for small components for furniture and chairs.

The Rojek works better for big components like doors and long table rails and heavy table legs. The Rojek will also cut deeper mortises.

I use both of them to cut mortises in each part and connect with floating tenons. For me, cutting tenons on a component isn't worth the trouble.

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#13

Re: Thanks guys.

John Cotten

>The landlord is one of my clients, and the shop owner is a personal friend. I have heard and know both sides of the story. Time will work it out. I suggested that idea to the landlord, but he said he would rather wait. He actually is trying to help my friend by giving him time to work it out, but the lien is just a matter of protecting his interest. Friends or not, business is business.

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#14

Re: And another reasonable option

Thomas S Stockton

>If you use the bits that are designed for the slower speeds of slot mortisers they work fine and are about as fast and not as noisy.

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#15

Re: Mortises for floating tenons

Denny

>Clay,

Do you find you end up with slightly different size mortises in end grain or long grain?

I'm using a router in a homebrew jig and my end grain mortises are always about .005" or .007" tighter than the same mortise cut in long grain. Cutting the long grain mortises is noisier, but I'm not sure what the cause is (I'm using an upcut spiral bit.)

I'd consider building a better jig (like the Router Magic version) if I thought the mortises would be more consistent.

Thanks,

Denny

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#16

Re: Mortises for floating tenons

Clay Foster

>I haven't had a problem with that, but .005 is a closer tolerance than I worry about.

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#17

Ellis Walentine

RPMs for mortising

Ellis Walentine

>A router does a fine job, but you really should use carbide-tipped tooling at those speeds. Regular end mills won't last.

Back in the days when my shop was a full-time business, we had two horizontal mortisers. One was a converted horizontal milling machine with draw collets and a Reeves drive motor. We typically mortised between 1200 and 2500 rpm -- never over 3000 rpm -- using standard two-flute end mills. The mortises were very accurate because of the stability of the bed and the collet chuck. The other machine was an Advantage, with a 3600 rpm direct-drive motor. It also worked well, but not as well as the milling machine. The downside of those lower rpms was that you had to feed the bit more slowly.

My point is that high rpms aren't necessary for mortising. In fact, on machines with relatively high rpms (around 7000) like some combination machines, they recommend special high-speed steel bits with very shallow spiral pitch to clear chips and guard against burnout.

Ellis

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#18

Thanks Clay...

Denny

>My .005 measurement may not be accurate, because I find the difference in size is enough to make a snug tenon fit on one piece and a sloppy fit on the mating piece. I think I'll go ahead and try building the "Router Magic" mortiser and see if that tightens things up.

Thanks,

Denny

Re: Werth Machine or Similar (good Ellis question)

#19

Re: Thanks Clay...

Clay Foster

>Denny,

I cut 20 mortises on my Leigh M&T tool today. They were all within .001 tolerance, both end grain and side grain. I use Whiteside router bits with a 1/2" shank.