Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

log cabins homes problems

Posts

log cabins homes problems

#1

log cabins homes problems

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>My supervisor is considering buying a log cabin home. We did an inspection of the house today and I found a couple of serious wood problems with the logs. One corner has some serious rot that someone has tried to seal with caulking material. It is in the corner of the building most exposed to the prevailing winds, snow, and rains. The inside indicates water damage at one time. The exterior shows some log fascia (my word here, explain later)repair in the past, but there is a significant chunk of one end of a log that is very loose and open to more moisture. Winter is coming.

The log construction is a double tenon insulated joint between the top and bottom of each log. On the outside in many places it appears that some part of the logs were milled away and a half round was fastened in its place. May be something else but that is what it looks like to me. Where do I find knowledgeable people to look at this and tell her how serious this problem is and what an effective repair entails and costs. She is real serious about buying this house, but she is also a first time home buyer and can be persuaded to wait until she has some answers to some questions. I am the wood person in her life so it is up to me to help her find the answers. Besides, it is always good to do favors for the boss.

Folks? Can you help? You are my ace in the hole.

I could go over and take pictures tomorrow afternoon if that would help.

Re: log cabins homes problems

#2

Re: log cabins homes problems

David Yoho

>Carol, in my area there are a good number of log home manufacturers. I don't know if any are located in your neck of the woods but if you could find one (Internet and yellow pages) they may be willing to come out and have a look. If there's not one close enough, perhaps you could take some pictures and email them to one who could help with some answers.

David

Re: log cabins homes problems

#3

Re: log cabins homes problems *LINK*

Bob Falk, FPL wood engineer

>IMHO, I'd take a pass unless you are willing to do some major work...how do you fix rotten logs on a log home? Not easy without replacing the whole log....caulking only serves to trap the water and leads to more decay. Sounds like this house was not properly maintained


USDA Forest Products Lab Website

Re: log cabins homes problems

#4

I'm not an expert on log homes but rot is like

Forrest Addy

>I'm not an expert on log homes but rot is like mice and roaches. If you see one there's a whole invasion force you haven't seen. I'd give this log home a pass unless your boss is willing to pay for a building surveyor go over the whole structure with a fine tooth comb. It might be the best $400 she ever spend.

If on one hand she buys a pig in a poke and there's concealed rot, electrical problems, plumbing problems etc she could have an unplanned rennovation on her hands.

If on the other hand the seller can be talked down in price in the evidence of a third party expert by the amount of the repair estimate then she will have entered into a problem fully aware of their existace and importance.

Ask around a few lumber yards and building departments and get a few references to building surveyors. A building surveyor by the way is not a crippled carpenter. It's an expert with experience and credentials. Ask for them.

Re: log cabins homes problems

#5

Re: log cabins homes problems

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Carol,

Are the damaged logs near the top of the wall, in the center, or near the bottom?

The answer to that question really determines the cost of resolving the problem.

We have lived in a log cabin for the past 30 years. At one point I replaced about 4' of a rotting bottom log with concrete block. It was a cheap fix and doesn't show inside the house.

On the cabin you describe, the repair could require dismantling the roof and 3 walls of the house to replace the bad log. If the problem is on an "exposed" corner, the problem could well stem from a lack of roof on that corner of the house. To guarantee a long life from a log home, you have to have sufficient coverage by the roof to prevent water splash and snow accumulation on the logs.

I agree with Forrest. If your boss really likes the house, it would be worth it to get an expert home inspector to take a look. Too bad Barry Irby doesn't live out that way.

My couple cents,

Gary

Re: log cabins homes problems

#6

Re: log cabins homes problems *LINK*

John Cotten

>Carol. Log Home Living magazine used to have a list of log home producers and contractors available to it's readers. I pasted a link below. I would contact them for a reputable local log home builder. Make sure they have built more than one log home, (several would be better). I have used them before when I was at the state and they (Log Home Living) were really great to work with. I am sure the editors can give you some good info also. Was great to see you earlier this summer.

John Cotten


Log Home living

Re: log cabins homes problems

#7

Re: log cabins homes problems

Jim Dillon

>Carol,

Sounds like you have identified some serious deal-breakers regarding the log home. Look in the telephone book under "log homes" for distributors/builders. While they are likely to only want to do new stuff, some might be willing and have the experience to tell you the straight truth on what needs to be done. Otherwise, go to a book/magazine store and find magazines devoted to log homes. Inside those you will find lots of ads for major log-home suppliers, like Kuhn Brothers, Lincoln Logs etc. Call them (or go to their web site) and ask for a list of local distributors in your area. Then contact them. Bob is right, log homes really do need to be maintained and it sure sounds like this one has not been. On the other hand - trying to be more positive here - maybe there are just a few logs near the foundation sill that could be replaced, but you need someone experienced in repair of log structures to advise you. Log homes are kinda like wooden boats - you need to keep on top of things maintenance-wise. Good luck.

Jim [who lives in (and maintains 8-( ) a log house 7 months a year]

Re: log cabins homes problems

#8

I lived in one for 4 years

Dustmaker Mike

>and I got a lot of information from a company called Log Home Store. http://www.aloghomestore.com/

another called Perma Chink http://www.permachink.com/

A log home is easy to take care of just start working on it now and continue until you leave it. Really if you can get them right the work on them is easy to do. The hard part is getting them right. The end of the weather faceing logs is always a problem but give Perma Chink a call and they can tell you if the log needs replace or you could use an Epoxy resin material to repair it. Sounds like you have a swiss cope log home. Check here for some one in your neck of the woods that knows log homes. http://www.loghomes.org/member.phtml?

Re: log cabins homes problems

#9

Re: log cabins homes problems

Barry Irby

>This has been an interesting post for me. As a builder and now Home Inspector, I have experience with log homes going back thirty years. Forrest is right, your boss needs a Building Surveyor or Home Inspector with expertise in log homes. (American Society of Home Inspectors (ASHI) has a locator function that allows you to find inspectors in your area.) And Gary is right, I would love to do the inspection, and I still make house calls, but Nebraska is too far to drive.

Check out the Perma Chink web site mentioned above. They have been in the business of providing chinking and other materials for log home for years. Nisus also provides BoraCare that is an excellent preservative for them also.

There are a number of problems with log homes. As you have discovered, they tend to rot. Wide overhangs, gutters, and good preservatives and good construction techniques all help along with maintenance, but once the rot is established it is harder to repair than to prevent. If you have seen some, there is more. Wood tends to rot from the inside out and we have found logs that looked pretty good on the outside only to find they were a thin shell surrounding a nearly completely rotted interior.

Repairs are difficult and expensive.

Another aspect to the problem is that the construction is very different than typical frame construction. This introduces a huge number of problems. For example, wood tends to expand and contract across the grain with changes in moisture content, but hardly at all lengthwise. In frame construction, the studs are vertical and their height changes very little. In log construction, the fibers in the logs are horizontal. Without going into a lot of detail on the mechanics of wood movement, it is very likely the logs expand and contract 1 to 2% seasonally. An 8 foot tall wall is about a 100 inches. That wall could change height by 1 to 2". (Yes, they really do.) The manufacturers know this and go to great pains to accommodate it. The windows and doors are usually fitted into frames or bucks that fit inside the openings and have slots in them to allow the wall to "telescope" up and down around the openings. The trim at the top of the openings must be designed to slide up and down as well and seal the openings.

Additionally, Most of these houses have log exteriors and stud wall with drywall interiors. This means the exterior moves vertically and the interior does not. One of my friends had a house that had a centerline wall supporting a loft above. Sometimes the floor in the loft was level and sometimes it had a two inch hump in it, Depending on whether the logs were "up" or "down".

Often, the dealer does not have an experienced builder in your area. This leads to them "licensing" anyone willing to put the house together. Huge problems result form Amatuer Workmanship. Often, enthusiastic owners build these things themselves.

A few things I have seen:

One owner builder did not want to lose the space required to put a stud wall between the fiberglass shower and the logs, so he nailed the shower directly to the studs. When the logs moved, it tore the flange right off the shower.

Another did not understand what the gasket material was that was supposed to be installed between every row of logs. They also thought the twenty or thirty five gallon buckets of bulk caulking that should have been laid down in two beads on either side of the gasket was "too Messy" and they left it out. The house faced the river and when the rain blew in off the river, it sprayed out twelve feet into the house. I could tell because the basement ceiling tile was ruined that far into the house. (I gave them a solution and if you are interested, I will expalin it. It worked)

On many of the houses, the tongue and grooved ceiling boards extend out over the logs to create the underside of the roof overhang. In one case wasps found the Vee groove between the planks irresistible and would crawl through and come into the house. These folks were getting a hundred or so wasps a day out to the master bedroom.

I could go on and on.

Its not that conventional construction does not have problems, its that log houses have a different set of problems and builders and owners are not used to them and not prepared for them. Ignoring them and combining log construction with frame construction compounds the problems.

Interesting side note: Log construction is the only uniquely American form of construction. Originally the country offered huge forests and very little farm land. They used the logs to build houses to get ride of the logs as much as anything else. In the days before factory built windows and indoor plumbing and wiring, they were excellent. Very good use of local materials. Reasonably well insulated and very good against Indian attack until the Indians figured out those fire arrows.

I am not much of a fan of log houses. It almost a cult thing. If you like them, you really like them. Otherwise, NOT. They are not a good first home and not particularly easy or low maintenance. Unless your friend has the skills and tools and time to do the maintenance or the money to hire it done, not a good place to start. They need a heads up and to do some research.

Re: log cabins homes problems

#10

Re: log cabins homes problems

Dick Coers

>Don't get me started on home inspectors. They are one of the greatest ripoffs, well since I don't know when. All they give you is an opinion and are only responsible for the amount that you paid them. They accept no fault for missing something. If I had not done the work an inspector should have done, my daughter would have had a house with rotten floor joists, rotten sill, and a rotten rim joist. He explained his lack of investigation on the fact that he was not allowed to remove the insulation bat from around the foundation in the crawl space. It was not finished, all you had to do was pull back the insulation. He was a great waste of money, but he sure had good credentials! It would have cost my daughter at least $20,000 for the structural repairs if I had not caught it before the purchase.

I would have a contractor give me the inspection.

Re: log cabins homes problems

#11

Re: log cabins homes problems-Barry

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>You really know your stuff!

I have a close friend that built a log home because he liked the looks of them. Three years later he sold it at a great loss, and never looked back. I asked him why, as I was think of someday building one, and he told me many of the reasons you just mentioned. Glad I never followed through with it! You drive by that log home today, and it's nearly ready to fall in. The guy that owns it has had it on the market for several years and continually lowers the asking price, but no one is interested! I think a cheap garage from one of the borgs would be better than it!

Ron in Iowa

Re: log cabins homes problems

#12

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

You laid it out pretty well, Barry.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I have never lived in a log home, but have worked on many of them. We used to apply interior and exterior sealants on them. We primarily worked for one distributor, and that relationship has become quite strained so that we haven't worked for them in about a year. The guy leaves a trail of dissatisfied customers AND subcontractors (us included). Anyway the guy built his own log home about 10 years ago, and last year wanted to re-do the exterior finish completely, so he bought a corn-cob blasting system (he wanted to sell this service in the future, too) and had his house blasted. They were taking buckets of cob media out of the house for weeks... Then I came along to seal the exterior again, and I had to blow the media off all the logs with a compressor, some of it went inside...

Personally, I wouldn't touch one with a ten-foot pole anymore. I used to think they were a neat idea, but no more. They are a LOT of work, just in keeping the exterior of the logs sealed, never mind all the settling, expansion and contraction issues Barry mentioned.

You're in a tough spot Carol. Your boss should run, not walk away from this log home, but she will probably never fully appreciate that advice, unless she had lived in one.

Jason

Re: log cabins homes problems

#13

Re: log cabins homes problems

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>Carol, I have lived in this log home full time for almost three years and I lived in part time for six years plus before that. The log construction is different than the one you refer to but the care of log homes is always similar.

First, I have yet to meet a home inspector that is really knowledgeable of log homes. Barry may be the exception since some of his comments ring true. I would look for someone in the area that has been building log homes for many years to inspect the house. Permachink would be a good place to check if you can't find anyone from the local yellow pages.

It takes a certain type of personality to enjoy living in a log home. I can't describe that personality but some people just aren't suited to log homes. I find it to be very relaxing and rewarding myself.

There are always ways to repair a log home. Some of them can be very expensive but not always. If the house was in Strawberry I would gladly come and look at it and probable could talk the guy that built this house to come with me. Randy has been building log homes for over twenty five years so I think he knows what he is doing. He only builds handcrafted homes which means that the logs are brought in from the forest and made to fit on site.

Howard