Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

Posts

Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#1

Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>I'm looking at tenoning jigs for my PM2000 table saw. The Grizzly H7583 has appeal, given that it's about half the price of most of the others. These jigs all seem to be about the same functionally, though of course quality of construction and therefore precision may vary. I'd like to hear others experiences with this and other tenoning jigs.

TIA

Dan


Grizzly H7583

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#2

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Just a question here....but do you do a lot of operations where you feel you need a tenoning jig? The reason I asked is that I bought one for my Unisaw years ago and I have built a ton of projects large and small since then. I think I may have used my jig once in all those years. Maybe some day I'll need it but right now it's pretty caked in dust.

Not to say they are worthless. If you need one then you need one. Just food for thought.

Tom

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#3

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>I have had the same experience with my tennoning jig. Not to say it's useless, but I wish I'd just built one of the simple ones that ride the TS fence instead of buying a nice expensive one. I figured I'd save on setup time over the long haul, but that has not proven to be the case as it still takes a good amount of setup time per operation. So, I usually do things another way to avoid that anyway.

Jay

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#4

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Dan,

I had many MANY tenons to do for the Mission and A&C furniture which now fills most of our house. I considered the Delta, the New Delta, the JET, and a number of other ripoffs with price tags ranging from $80 to $180.

I had gotten a copy of Bill Hylton's Router Magic and flipping through saw his plan for a tenon-cutting sled for the router table. I made two, 1 set at 90*, the other adjustable, and for about $2.00 in materials have never looked back. I personally regard them as safer than the table saw jigs, and, since they are easier to control, I suspect more precise than the commercial jigs. They are surely faster to set up. I've now done 100's of M&T joints, including angled and through tenons, using the sleds and a 1-1/2" planing bit that at 12,000 rpm cuts cleaner than any TS blade I've ever tried.

I know several guys who, like Tommy, bought these 20lb. chunks of iron, only to let them sit and collect dust. Several of them are using Bill's sleds instead.

I suppose to actually respond to your question I should say "None of the above." |;-}}}

mm

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#5

JL

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig

JL

>I bought the equivalent Rockler tenoning jig a while back. Then I bought Yeung Chan's book - "Classic Joints with Power Tools". You can build a jig that does essentially the same thing for an investment in time and maybe 10% of the cost.

The nice thing about the tenoning jig is that it does let you switch back and forth between angled tenons and straight tenons very easily.

Your choice. I've used mine several times. I've also used my home built one several times. Both work.

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#6

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Mark, just so you know, it makes a dandy boat anchor. ;-)

I have not made Bill's sled but as you have eluded to, there are plenty of ways to make tenons and I find some of them to be faster and easier than dealing with a tenoning jig. A tenoning jig does the job but I found it to be a burden to set up when I could do it faster with other methods. That's probably why mine sits and rusts.

T.

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#7

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for the great replies. I'm pretty new at this. I hope to be making furniture (end tables, shelving units, etc). My list of equipment was:

1) Table saw & blade (PM2000 & Forrest woodworker II, got 'em)

2) Dado blade (Freud 208, got it)

2) Tenoning jig (hence my question)

3) Router table (that was going to be my next thread!)

Sounds like my assumption about the tenoning jig being fairly vital was incorrect. Maybe I'll move on to the router table!

BTW, just reserved "Classic Joints with Power Tools" at the local library, thanks for the tip!

Dan

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#8

I made one

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>using a plan from FWW a whole bunch of years ago. I should look up Bill H's plan.

Like you, I seem to build a bunch of mission and a/c furniture, and I sure don't relish the idea of cutting all those tenons without a jig of some kind.

thanks for the Bill H recommendation, though.

Bruce

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#9

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Dan,

I'm like the others. I have the Delta jig and have used it infrequently. The jig is a nice-to-have item, and certainly works very well. I'm glad I have it. However, had I to do it over again, I would have bought a less costly item.

George

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#10

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig

Barry Irby

>Boy do I feel foolish. I bought one of those Delta tenoning jigs on sale for about $80 and I use it. Ignorance was bliss. I got it in my pre-WoodCentral days. Now I need to get Bill H's book and Classic Joints.

I find the jig to be useful, but then obviously, I did not know better. One short-coming for me is the fact that my shop has an 8' ceiling. I cannot cut tenons on long pieces, because if you stand them up on the TS they hit the ceiling. So if the rails are over five feet, I'm out of luck. OTOH, when it works, it works well.

On another topic, I have a homemade router table built in the wing of my TS. I thought it was clever for it to share the fence. Not! It seems that every time I get it set up on the router I find something I need to rip on the TS. I have the small shop blues and cannot afford the space for a dedicated router table. But a fence is looking like a sure bet.

Could someone post pictures of the alternative jigs for tenons?

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#11

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>Here's a link to the one I was thinking of in the PWW blogs.

Looks like about $6 + some scraps.


PWW Tennoning Jig

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#12

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig

Dan Mitchell

>Barry-When I got the saw, it had the option of a router table in the extension table. About 200 bucks more, or so. I asked them if they had one in stock, the guy said no & that he had only sold a handful on any saw in the years he'd been there. Must be one of those things that seems like a good idea in theory, but turns out not to be so in practice.

Dan

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#13

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig

Dan Mitchell

>Certainly looks like it's worth a try, thanks for the link.

dan

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#14

Re: A tenoning jig

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Here ya go, Barry.

With this you lay your stock flat on the sled, set the length of the tenon with the slide block, and raise or lower the router bit to determine how much you take off to get your tenon. 4 cuts and you're done just about the time it takes to write this. The sled registers against the edge of the table. This is the 90* sled. The adjustable sled has a DeStaco clamp to hold the workpiece.


img

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#15

Re: A tenoning jig

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Other side.


img

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#16

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig

Jesse in New Mexico

>Guess I'm missing something. I use the Delta tenoning jig darn near every project. I can set it up in way less time than a router. The micro adjust feature lets me sneak up on a perfect fit. It will keep that setting for a hundred tenons if you need it to.

Yeah, I wouldn't put a tenon on a long piece with it, but then I wouldn't use a router or a dado blade either. For long pieces, I generally use floating tenons.

Anyhow, I guess my point is there are lots of ways to skin a cat. For me, it was a good investment.

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#17

Re: Opposing Views

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Are always welcome, Jessie; doesn't put you in an outgroup. |;-}

If it works for you, you go with it. Each of us needs to be comfortable with our tools and processes. After all, the boys over on The Quiet Side would give us all the raz for even using any power tools to cut tenons!!

mm

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#18

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig

Jim Dillon

>Dan,

You've gotten lots of good advice and different approaches. First, I disagree with the salesperson who implied that a router table built into a TS extension table wasn't useful - based on his dismal sales record. I built my own extension table (as well as an outfeed table) and put my router into it and it works great and saves space. I built my own router fence based on what Norm (Yankee Workshop) was using and it has worked well.

I second Yeung Chang's book and built the tenon jig he suggested (as well as his other jigs) and it has been very useful and can also be used to cut reinforced miters in picture frames and small boxes. And do indeed, as suggested, check out Bill Hylton's Router Magic book. Despite the goofy title, it has a wealth of info and plans for tenon and mortise jigs. I also built the jig that Mark suggested and, with a good mortising bit, it works like a champ. [My biggest problem is deciding which jig to use 8-) 8-)] But the real gem in his Bill's book IMHO is the mortising jig that temporarily attaches to a workbench. I have used that jig for a whole bunch of things beyond what it was intended for. Good luck.

Jim

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#19

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig

Barry Irby

>Jessie, I agree. I have gotten a lot of mileage out of my tenoning jig. I have a WWII on my TS and I can shave a tenon down in extremely small increments. They come out square and true. I cut the mortises first and sneak up on the tenons until they fit. As if always the case, excellent stock prep is a big help.

I need other ways to cut the ones on long pieces, but frankly, I was surprised to find out apparently you and I are in the minority on these tenoning attachments. I would buy mine again.

Thank you to the guys who posted the alternative methods. Gave me some good ideas.

And Dan, I did not mean to hijack your post.

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#20

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for all the replies. Interesting to see the varied opinion. As I said I'm fairly new to this, have watched a ton of New Yankee, based on the tools he uses I was trying to prioritize my purchases. Seems like Norm uses a tenoning jig on almost very project! They're not too expensive (especially that Grizzly, sure would like to hear from someone who owns one ;-) so I figured what the heck?!?

Dan

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#21

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Barry & Jesse,

I guess I'm the third Musketeer! I built six Mission chairs and a table not long ago, and got pretty good at setting up my Delta jig. I've tried several different ways, from router to dado blades on my RAS, but the TS and tenoning jig works best for me. To each his own, er, one for all and all for one, or whatever those three funny dressed guys used to say!

Ron in Iowa

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#22

One thing to consider

Dan Donaldson

>You said that you are new at this. Consider how many projects you have built, and what you intend to build in the future. Once you have the basic tools, which it looks like you are well on the way, I would wait and buy tools based on the projects at hand. That way you make sure that you buy stuff that you will actually use as opposed to what someone else likes or uses. For instance, on the tenoning jig; If you are going to make one or two tenons per year, it might not be a good purchase for you. If you are thinking of mission style stuff, then it might be a very good idea. Just depends on what you are building unless you have an unlimited supply of tool money, in which case, I am available for adoption ;-)

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#23

Re: Mine's the same

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I used it for one project, maybe two, and now it sits. It's a Delta, a good one, but I move it around whenever I clean that portion of the shelves...

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#24

Re: One thing to consider

Dan Mitchell

>That's a great point, waiting until I need something. I used to really be into working on cars (find as I get older the allure of scraped knuckles & antifreeze dripping in my face has faded a bit, plus as my cars have gotten newer they've gotten less trouble-prone ;-), and I have a ton of automotive tools as a result, and that's how I acquired them, as needed. You're right, this should be the same.

Dan

Re: Selecting a tenoning jig *LINK*

#25

Re: I've used mine quite a lot.

Larry Clinton

>I'm don't have the skills of Tommy (or most of the others above). I use mine (cheap rockler jig - Paid around $50 on sale), quite a lot. The blanket chest I'm finishing right now has nearly 50 M&T joints. I used the jig on my Unisaw wit Forrest WW 2. I cut the tennon thickness that way - then make a setup with my sled & a stop block on the TS to trim the shoulder on the tenon thickness, and a second setup with the sled (change blade height to cut the shoulder for the tenon width. The WW2 makes a very clean cut this way with perfectly square shoulders. I then trim the width of the tenon on the Band saw. Fairly easy as I just have to trim into the saw cut, not to the shoulder of the tenon. The setup takes a little time, but seems to hold very well (within .002"). To answer your question as to the Grizzly jig, it looks exactly like my Rockler jig. I did have to dissemble my jig when I set it up the first time as the guide bar was not tightened properly and was not coplanar with the face that aligns the stock. The tenons would have turned out wedge shaped. I would check the jig before trusting it. I used a dial indicator clamped to my fence and slid the jig in the slot indicating the face - as received it was out about .015 ~ .020 in about 4". After aligning and tightening everything it has been a good tool for me. I have been thinking of building a jig for my router table however as several people seem to like them. This is on my "Tuit" list so may be a couple years down the road.