Re: Selecting a tenoning jig
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Dan,
I had many MANY tenons to do for the Mission and A&C furniture which now fills most of our house. I considered the Delta, the New Delta, the JET, and a number of other ripoffs with price tags ranging from $80 to $180.
I had gotten a copy of Bill Hylton's Router Magic and flipping through saw his plan for a tenon-cutting sled for the router table. I made two, 1 set at 90*, the other adjustable, and for about $2.00 in materials have never looked back. I personally regard them as safer than the table saw jigs, and, since they are easier to control, I suspect more precise than the commercial jigs. They are surely faster to set up. I've now done 100's of M&T joints, including angled and through tenons, using the sleds and a 1-1/2" planing bit that at 12,000 rpm cuts cleaner than any TS blade I've ever tried.
I know several guys who, like Tommy, bought these 20lb. chunks of iron, only to let them sit and collect dust. Several of them are using Bill's sleds instead.
I suppose to actually respond to your question I should say "None of the above." |;-}}}
mm